
First-tier Tribunal Care Standards
The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care) Rules 2008
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKFTT 01414 (HESC)
Heard on 2 October 2026 by Video Link.
Before
Mr H Khan (Judge)
Ms D Rabbetts (Specialist Member)
Mr M Cann (Specialist Member)
Between:
Quality Team Healthcare Ltd
Appellant
-v-
Care Quality Commission
Respondent
DECISION
The Appeal
Quality Team Healthcare Ltd ("the Appellant") appeals against the Care Quality Commission's ("the Respondent") Notice of Decision dated 7 January 2026 to cancel the Appellant's registration as a service provider in respect of the regulated activity of Personal care ("the Regulated Activity"), at or from Quality Team Healthcare Ltd, 15 Topaz Drive, Sittingbourne, ME10 5TP ("the Location").
The Respondent's Notice of Decision was issued pursuant to section 17(1)(e) of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 ("the 2008 Act") and regulation 6(1)(c) of the Care Quality Commission (Registration) Regulations 2009 ("the 2009 Regulations"). It was served on the basis that the Appellant was not carrying on, and had not carried on, the Regulated Activity for a continuous period of more than 12 months.
Video Hearing
This was a remote hearing. The form of remote hearing was by video. The documents that the Tribunal were referred to were contained in the electronic hearing bundle (128 pages). The Tribunal was satisfied that the parties were able to participate effectively in the proceedings.
There was an issue at the start of the hearing as the Appellant had not sent its skeleton argument to the Respondent. We stood the matter down in order to enable the Respondent to get a copy of the skeleton argument.
Attendance
The Appellant represented by Mr Adonia Mudeweti, Director of Quality Team Healthcare Limited.
The Respondent was represented by Miss Amber Walker (Counsel). The Respondent called Mrs Teresa Eadon, CQC Operations Manager, to give evidence.
There were two observers from the Respondent. They did not play any part in the proceedings.
The Appellant
The Appellant was registered by the Respondent on 16 September 2024 as a service provider in respect of the Regulated Activity. The regulated activity was registered to be carried on at or from the Location.
The Appellant accepts that it has not carried on the regulated activity since registration. Its case is that “exceptional family circumstances” prevented it from making the necessary preparations during 2025 and that it should be allowed further time to commence providing personal care.
The Respondent
The Respondent is the independent regulator of healthcare, adult social care and primary care services in England, established under the 2008 Act.
The Respondent opposes the appeal. It maintains that the statutory ground for cancellation is established, that the Appellant has remained dormant since registration and that cancellation remains reasonable and proportionate.
Events Leading up to the Notice of Decision
The chronology of events was largely agreed.
On 16 September 2024, the Appellant was registered to provide the regulated activity of Personal care at or from the Location.
On 16 December 2024, the Respondent contacted the Appellant seeking confirmation as to whether the regulated activity was being carried on.
On 24 December 2024, the Appellant confirmed that it remained dormant and was not yet delivering personal care.
On 17 March 2025, the Respondent made a further dormancy enquiry. On 15 April 2025, the Appellant confirmed that no regulated activity was being carried on at the Location.
On 16 June 2025, the Respondent made a further enquiry. On 23 June 2025, the Appellant again confirmed that it had not yet provided personal care.
On 16 October 2025, the Respondent informed the Appellant that it had been dormant for 12 months and asked it to confirm whether the Regulated Activity was being delivered.
On 12 November 2025, the Appellant confirmed that it had not yet delivered personal care but wished to remain registered. The Appellant explained that Adonia Mudeweti was abroad and had experienced difficulties accessing correspondence.
On 24 November 2025, the Respondent issued a Notice of Proposal to cancel the Appellant's registration on the ground that it had not carried on the Regulated Activity for a continuous period of 12 months or more.
The Appellant did not submit representations in response to the Notice of Proposal.
On 7 January 2026, the Respondent issued a Notice of Decision adopting the proposal and cancelling the Appellant's registration in respect of the Regulated Activity.
On 29 January 2026, the Appellant appealed to the First-tier Tribunal. It accepted that it had not delivered personal care and asked to remain registered while it expedited preparations to commence the Regulated Activity.
Legal Framework
We have adopted elements of the legal framework as set out in the Respondent’s submissions. The legal framework was not in dispute.
Section 17 (1) (e) of the HSCA 2008 confers upon the Respondent the power to cancel the registration of a Service Provider:
“The Commission may at any time cancel the registration of a person under this Chapter as a service provider or manager in respect of a regulated activity –
(e) “on any ground specified by regulations.”
The applicable Regulations are the Care Quality Commission (Registration) Regulations 2009. The pertinent provisions are as follows: -
Regulation 3: This requires the Respondent to maintain a register of information as appears appropriate to the Commission to be necessary to keep the public informed about the identity of registered persons, and their carrying on of regulated activities.
Regulation 6 (1) (c): This provides that the Respondent can cancel a registered person’s registration in circumstances where no regulated activity has been carried on over a continuous period of 12 months.
The Regulated Activity
In the instant case, the relevant Regulated Activity is that of Personal Care. This is defined in Regulation 2 of the Health and Social Care Act (2008) (Regulated Activities) Regulations
It is defined as: -
Physical assistance given to a person in connection with –
Eating or drinking (including maintenance of established parenteral nutrition),
Toileting (including in relation to the process of menstruation),
washing or bathing,
dressing,
oral care, or
the care of skin, hair and nails (with the exception of nail care provided by a person registered with the HCPC as a chiropodist or podiatrist pursuant to article 5 of the 2001 Order) or,
the prompting, together with supervision, of a person, in relation to the performance of any of the activities listed in paragraph (a), where that person is unable to make a decision for themselves in relation to performing such activity without such prompting and supervision.
The Tribunal may confirm the decision(s) taken by the Respondent or direct that the decision(s) not have effect, or it may impose any condition(s) on the registration that it sees fit.
The Respondent bears the burden of persuading the Tribunal that the decision(s) to cancel the service and/or impose of a condition is/are proportionate as at the time of the appeal hearing.
The Respondent must establish the facts upon which it relies to support satisfaction of the proportionality of the decision on the balance of probabilities.
Evidence
We took into account all the evidence that was presented in the bundle and at the hearing. We heard evidence from a number of witnesses at the hearing. The following is a summary of the evidence that was presented at the hearing (or in a witness statement) and in no way is it meant to reflect everything that was said or written.
Mrs Eadon confirmed the contents of her witness statement. She set out that the position was that there was no information which has been provided to suggest that the Appellant was to commence Regulated Activity. Ms Eadon confirmed that if any evidence had been provided, it would be considered.
Mrs Eadon emphasised that maintaining an accurate register was central to the Respondent’s duty to protect and promote the health and safety of people who use health and social care services. Mrs Eadon expressed a concern that where a provider remains dormant, the Respondent cannot be assured that services could be delivered safely.
This would also include the Respondent not being assured that the Service provider has remained up to date with best practice. In this case, the Appellant had not provided any evidence that it had been seeking regulated activity. There was no evidence of regulated activity. This would have included assessments and care plans.
Mr Mudeweti accepted that no regulated activity had been carried out since registration. He put forward that this was due to a number of reasons including the unfortunate illness of his nephew. This necessity him travelling abroad to Zimbabwe. He ended up staying there for 12 months when the plan had been to stay there for three months.
He stated that at the time of the hearing, he was not carrying out regulated activity, he was not engaged in any discussions with any commissioners, but he was trying to build up the finances. His concern was that he could not do this whilst this registration was under threat. However, he was taking some action such as subscribing to various services and was paying for insurance.
He acknowledged that he had not put forward any evidence of any “imminent” regulated activity. However, he wanted to be given a further six months to be able to build up to providing regulated activity. He was confident that he could do so but wanted to do it “meticulously”.
He did not want to make a further application for a new registration. This is because he would have to engage the services of another consultant. The reason put forward was that the requirements for regulated activity might have changed
The Tribunal’s conclusion with reasons
We took into account all the evidence that was included in the hearing bundle and presented at the hearing. This includes the Appellant’s and Respondent’s evidence.
We wish to place on record our thanks to Mr Adonia Mudeweti, Ms A Walker and Ms Teresa Eadon for their assistance at the hearing.
We reminded ourselves that the Tribunal considers the circumstances as at the date of its decision and the onus is on the Respondent to satisfy the Tribunal that the relevant standard, namely the balance of probabilities was met.
We acknowledge that the facts are largely agreed. The Appellant fully accepts that it hasn’t yet to commenced providing personal care. There is no challenge to the allegation of dormancy. It was agreed that the regulated activity is that of personal care. There was also no challenge to the Appellant’s assertion that he had travelled abroad because of a seriously ill nephew.
We acknowledge the evidence of Mrs Eadon. We sought clarification on some parts of evidence which focused on what the Appellant needed to provide. There was some discussion regarding whether this needed to be evidence of actual regulated activity or could it include evidence of “imminent” regulated activity. Her evidence suggested that this could include “imminent” regulated activity, because, for example, speaking to commissioners and providing a care plan although her evidence on this point was not as clear as it would have been.
The evidence of Mr Mudeweti set out the Appellant’s position. We acknowledge his evidence as to what he perceived the position to be.
The Appellant accepted right at the outset that it had not carried out any regulated activity since its registration on 16 September 2024. We found that the Appellant as a service provider was not and had not been for a continuous period of 12 months ending with the date of the decision to cancel registration (7 January 2026 - and as at the date of our decision) carried on regulated activity. We found that the Appellant had not carried on regulated activity since 16 September 2024 since it was registered.
We found that the grounds for cancellation were made out. The issue then follows was whether or not the Appellant’s registration should be cancelled. We concluded, having considered all the circumstances, that it was reasonable, necessary and proportionate for the Appellant’s registration to be cancelled. Our reasons for doing so are set out below
We acknowledge the Appellant’s reasons that he was concerned about his registration being under threat and had not taken any concrete steps to undertake regulated activity by the time of the hearing. However, we note that the notice of decision clearly set out that
“…If you do not make an appeal, our decision will become final as soon as we receive your letter or at the end of the 28 day period, whichever is sooner. If you do make an appeal, the final outcome will
depend on the decisions made by the Tribunal.”
We acknowledge that he had to travel abroad and returned in March 2026. However, no evidence has been provided of what action he has taken to secure regulated activity. He referred to setting up the necessary funds, subscribing to various services and establishing connections with other service providers to receive “hints and tip”. However, there was no imminent provision of regulated activity, there were no service users or potential service users.
In our view, whilst we acknowledge the Appellant’s stated intentions to provide regulated activity in the future, there is simply no persuasive evidence to substantiate that objective.
We acknowledge that in accordance with the statutory responsibilities imposed on the Respondent by regulation 3 of the 2009 Regulations, it must establish and maintain a register of providers. This serves to accurately inform the public as to the operation of regulated activity. We understood the need to remove dormant providers from it and that if providers were permitted to be registered without carrying on regulated activity, the public would be misinformed.
We note that the Appellant can make a new application for registration. Any new decision would carry with it a separate right of appeal.
We concluded that, having considered all the circumstances of the case and the evidence before us, it was reasonable, necessary and proportionate for the Appellant’s registration to be cancelled.
The Decision
The appeal is dismissed.
The decision of the Respondent dated 7 January 2026 to cancel the Appellant's registration as a service provider in respect of the regulated activity of Personal care at or from Quality Team Healthcare Ltd, 15 Topaz Drive, Sittingbourne, ME10 5TP is confirmed.
Judge H Khan
Lead Judge
First-tier Tribunals
(Care Standards & Primary Health Lists)
Interim Resident Judge
Health, Education and Social Care Chamber
Date Issued: 15 October 2026
