
First-tier Tribunal Care Standards
The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care) Rules 2008
NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01078 (HESC)
Heard on 20 July 2026, remotely via video, on the papers only
BEFORE
Mr SJW Lewis (Tribunal Judge)
Ms M Tynan (Specialist Member)
BETWEEN:
Kay & Dan's Daycare
Appellant
v
Ofsted
Respondent
DECISION
The Appeal
The Appellant brings this appeal (“the Appeal”) against a decision by Ofsted (“the Decision”), set out in Ofsted’s written notice dated 16 June 2026, to suspend the Appellant’s registration to provide childcare at Kay & Dan’s Daycare (“the Setting”), for six weeks from 16 June 2026 to 27 July 2026 (“the Suspension”). The Appeal is brought under regulation 12 of the Childcare (Early Years and General Childcare Registers) (Common Provisions) Regulations 2008 (“the Regulations”). The Appellant also seeks to challenge a subsequent decision by Ofsted to not lift the Suspension, following a written request from the Appellant on 19 June 2026 to do so. The Appellant acts as a litigant in person (i.e. without the benefit of legal representation).
The Respondent opposes the Appeal.
The Hearing
The Appeal was determined at a remote hearing (“the Hearing”) which took place on the papers without attendance from the parties, in line with an order dated 10 July 2026 made, following a case management hearing, at the request of the Appellant and with consent from Ofsted.
Documents, Evidence, Submissions
The bundle of documents runs to 86 pages. It includes: (1) the appeal application form, with a cover note and a supporting document setting out the grounds on which the Appellant seeks to rely; (2) the response form, with a document setting out the Response to Appeal; (3) case management orders dated 1 July 2026 and 10 July 2026; (4) various witness statements or written accounts, with some wider supporting evidence; and (5) extracts from relevant legislation/ regulations.
The Appellant relies on five written accounts: (1) Kayleigh Baker, undated, the Appellant’s owner/manager and the Nominated Individual; (2) Jayne Green, dated 9 July 2026, an employee; (3) Kieran Edgson, dated 9 July 2026, who is said to have visited the Setting regularly to provide football classes; (4) Sophie Bilton, dated 10 July 2026, an employee; and (5) Amy Teale, undated, another employee. None of these statements/accounts include a statement of truth.
Ofsted relies on a relatively detailed and formal witness statement, dated 7 July 2026, from Aimee Hill. It does include a statement of truth. Ms Hill is a manager of a team of early years regulatory inspectors at Ofsted, and the person who made the Decision.
Ofsted has provided a skeleton argument. In summary, it submits the Decision is justified on the basis that (1) there is a sufficient risk of harm to children and (2) the Suspension is proportionate. The Appellant did not provide a skeleton.
Given that the Hearing proceeded on the papers alone, we did not have an opportunity to test evidence with witnesses directly, or to test with the parties the grounds/submissions set out in their respective legal documents.
Restricted Reporting Order
While no restricted reporting orders were expressly applied for, we considered whether we ought to make any. Primarily, we considered the position in relation to children associated with the Setting. We concluded, in the circumstances, that we should make an order under rules 14(1)(a)-(b) of the rules governing the Tribunal and these proceedings (Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care Chamber) Rules 2008) to prohibit the disclosure or publication of any document or matter likely, directly or indirectly, to lead members of the public to identify any such child, or any other child connected with these proceedings, so as to adequately protect their private/family lives. For the avoidance of doubt, this extends in particular to the child associated with an alleged incident at the centre of this case (see below) and to that child’s mother.
Legal Framework and Principles
Section 69(1) of the Childcare Act 2006 (“the Act”) provides for regulations to be made dealing with the suspension of the registration of providers:
Regulations may provide for the registration of a person registered under Chapter 2, 3 or 4 in the early years register or the general childcare register to be suspended for a prescribed period in prescribed circumstances.
The same section provides that the regulations must include a right of appeal to the Tribunal.
Regulation 8 of the Regulations provides:
The registration of a [person who is registered under Chapter 2, 3 or 4 in the early years register or the general childcare register] may be suspended [generally or only in relation to particular premises,] by the Chief Inspector, by notice, in the circumstances prescribed in regulation 9 for the period prescribed in regulation 10.
Regulation 9 provides:
The circumstances prescribed for the purposes of section 69(1) of the Act are that the Chief Inspector reasonably believes that the continued provision of childcare by the registered person to any child may expose such a child to a risk of harm.
Regulation 13 provides that “harm” has the same meaning as in section 31(9) of the Children Act 1989. In other words, harm is a reference to: “ill-treatment or the impairment of health or development including, for example, impairment suffered from seeing or hearing the ill-treatment of another.”
Pursuant to regulation 10, the initial duration of suspension is six weeks. Such a suspension may, however, be extended, in circumstances set out in regulations 10(2) and (3). Suspension may also be lifted at any time, if the circumstances referred to in regulation 9 cease to exist.
Regulation 12 provides the right of appeal to the Tribunal. On such an appeal, the Tribunal must either confirm the decision to suspend the registration or direct that it shall cease to have effect.
In our judgment, the correct approach in considering the Appeal is as follows:
First, we must ask ourselves whether, as at the date of the Hearing (rather than, for example, the date of the Decision or the subsequent decision to not lift the Suspension), we are satisfied that there is reasonable cause to believe the continued provision of childcare by the Appellant to any child mayexpose such a child to a material risk of harm. In this sense, we are to “step into the shoes” of the Chief Inspector and make the Decision afresh, rather than reviewing Ofsted’s earlier decision(s). As such, we can consider information/evidence not available to Ofsted at the time of its decision(s). The burden of proof is on the Respondent. The relevant standard of proof (“reasonable cause to believe”) falls somewhere between “the balance of probabilities” and the lower threshold “reasonable cause to suspect”. The relevant belief is to be judged by whether a reasonable person, assumed to know the relevant law and be in possession of the relevant information, would believe a child may be put at a material risk of harm. The threshold, therefore, at this stage, is relatively low. We do not need, for example, to be satisfied there has been any actual harm, or that harm is likely in future. That said, having regard to the Upper Tribunal decision (see paragraph 20) in GM & WM v Ofsted [2009] UKUT 89 (ACC), the contemplated risk needs to be one of “significant” harm. Being focused on assessing current/future risk, we do not need to make any conclusive findings of fact (or resolve associated disputes of fact).
Second, if satisfied that the above test/threshold relating to risk is met, we need to consider whether, objectively viewed, the relevant regulatory intervention (i.e. the Suspension) is proportionate, in all of the relevant circumstances of this case. The Respondent, in our view, bears a persuasive burden in relation to this second issue. We set out our approach to considering this proportionality question further below.
We had careful regard to these principles, and to the (limited) evidence and information before us, approaching the matter with an open mind.
Background
Given the broad principle that our role is primarily to assess risk (and then to consider the overall proportionality of the intervention appealed), rather than to resolve factual disputes, nothing in this section (or elsewhere in this document) ought to be taken as any conclusive finding of fact. However, it is nonetheless important that we set out what appears to us to be the most relevant context.
The Appellant is a relatively small organisation. While not clear, and while there is some suggestion it has been interested in expanding, the Appellant may at present have just one setting attached to its registration. The Setting is registered as a childcare on non-domestic premises setting, providing day care. We are told it had around 20 children on the roll at the material time. It is registered on the Early Years Register, Compulsory Childcare Register and Voluntary Childcare Register. It registered in 2022. It seems to be operated as a partnership (of some kind) between Ms Baker, the Nominated Individual, and her husband Mr Daniel Baker, who appears to have been, at material times, a registered individual, the deputy manager at the Setting, and a designated safeguarding lead.
Although there are a number of relevant aspects to it, this case has, in essence, arisen from an alleged incident at the Setting on 12 June 2026 involving Mr Baker (“the Incident”). In a nutshell, it is alleged that Mr Baker used inappropriate and concerning techniques to try to get a three-year-old child (“the Child”) to sleep at the Setting. More specifically, it is alleged he placed a blanket over the Child’s head, while the Child was laid down, and then “straddled” the Child. The Child is said to have cried and been upset for several minutes, before falling asleep.
The basic background (without seeking to be comprehensive, and without finding facts conclusively) appears likely to include the following:
On 12 June 2026, Ofsted received what are described as “whistleblowing” concerns from two members of staff at the Setting: Ms Morgan and Ms Emery (“the Whistleblowers”). Both claimed to have witnessed the Incident. Both set out accounts of the Incident which suggest Mr Baker acted in a way that was inappropriate and which caused the Child harm and/or put the Child at risk of harm. On 15 June 2026, Ms Morgan provided some further information about what she said occurred and a third employee, who is also the mother of the Child, provided some information from her perspective.
On 16 June 2026, Ofsted issued the notice communicating the Decision. It explained that there had been “an allegation of a safeguarding nature”, but did not set out details of the Incident. It referred to having a reasonable belief that the continued provision of childcare may expose children to a risk of harm. It indicated that the purpose of the Suspension was to allow time for enquiries and/or steps to be taken to eliminate or reduce any such risk. It referred to liaising with other agencies and to a referral having been made to the relevant Local Authority Designated Officer (“the LADO”).
The Decision was made at or following a case review meeting, between Ms Hill and a colleague at Ofsted. The colleague is said to have provided some additional information to Ms Hill. First, the Appellant had had its registration suspended in 2024, following some other allegations made against Mr Baker. It had been alleged that Mr Baker hit a child with special educational needs and/or disabilities on three occasions. That allegation had not been “substantiated” by the LADO at the time, however, and the suspension had been lifted following “assurances” from Ms Baker that Mr Baker would not work unsupervised at the Setting. Second, some previous allegations (of some kind) had been made against Ms Baker, when she had been working as a childminder in the Bristol area in 2021. Those allegations (which are not particularised for us) had also not been “substantiated”, at the time, as, according to Ofsted, Mr Baker had “corroborated” Ms Baker’s account. Third, Ofsted published an outcome summary in February 2026, following information that an allegation had been made against another member of staff regarding the care of their own child. Ofsted formed a view that, at the time, the Appellant did not follow appropriate processes to manage that allegation or report it in a timely manner to it or the LADO.
Following the Decision, Ofsted received some further information in relation to the Appellant. Ms Hill states that “a music professional”, who attends the Setting on a regular basis, had shared some concerns about the Appellant. It is said that this professional alleged that the environment appeared to be overly strict and to lack warmth, and that he or she had directly observed staff: using some force to place children on floors/chairs; pointing in the faces of children; ignoring children; raising voices and getting angry (to the extent their faces became “red”) with children.
On 19 June 2026, Ms Baker wrote to Ofsted to set out information and/or measures which she hoped may lead it to lift the Suspension. She referred to having now suspended Mr Baker “until further notice”, given that, she said, she had by then been made aware that the core allegation related to him. She referred to matters such as staffing ratios, making Ms Green the deputy manager “for the time being”, previous safeguarding training for her and Ms Green, additional measures to limit any access/involvement from Mr Baker (including him being “demoted”), and having reviewed risks assessments. She referred to operating “shorter hours”, if permitted to re-open the Setting.
Ofsted maintained its position that the Suspension was justified.
On 26 June 2026, there was an Allegations Management Meeting chaired by the LADO (“the LADO Meeting”). The LADO Meeting was attended by a detective, an early years and safeguarding lead at the local authority, an advanced case practitioner at the local authority, and a regulatory inspector at Ofsted (Ms Dickinson). The evidence and information before that group – i.e. relating to the Incident and other potentially relevant matters – was considered. Along with the information we have already referred to above, there is a note of some steps apparently taken by children’s social services. It is recorded that children’s social care has been (and/or is in the process of) conducting an assessment in relation to Mr and Mrs Baker and their children. They are reported to have been left with some concerns, following a meeting with Mr Baker and Ms Baker at their home, about their attitude to the Incident. More specifically, Ms Baker is described as “defensive”, not focusing on children’s needs, and seeking to “excuse” Mr Baker’s alleged acts, blaming challenges relating to the Child’s behaviour. It is said that a “safety plan” has been put in place requiring, for the time being, Mr Baker to be supervised with their children. Further, it is recorded that the music professional also described what she claimed to perceive as a close inner management group at the Setting of Ms Baker, Mr Baker, and Ms Green, and said that Ms Baker had not been present at the Setting for three weeks or so (we add that she appears to have been unwell in this period). Further, the Child’s mother is said to have shared that the Child, in her view, had some “slight reddening” to the face/ears following the Incident (but could not be sure of the cause and any potential link).
On 30 June 2026, Ms Baker lodged the Appeal on behalf of the Appellant. Among other things, she asked for an opportunity to reopen the Setting in order to “save it” in “the last few weeks before summer”, suggesting that otherwise there would, come September, be “no business” left to save. She referred to having taken “all the necessary steps” to “safeguard everyone” during the investigation and beyond. She added that Ofsted would not, at the time of the Decision, have had all the information it needed. She argued that the Appellant had previously been allowed to reopen under what she described as “the same circumstances” a couple of years ago. She added that, in the meantime, Ofsted had carried out an inspection, in which it had rated the Appellant’s “safeguarding” as “good”.
On 6 July 2026, Ofsted produced its formal written response to the Appeal and, on 16 July 2026, its skeleton argument for the Hearing.
Ofsted has, according to Ms Hill, continued to liaise with various other agencies. We are told that there continues to be a police investigation of some kind into the Incident, but that the police have given permission to Ofsted to carry out its own enquiries. We are told that, on 1 July 2026, Mr Baker participated, on a voluntary basis, in a police interview under caution and provided “no comment” responses.
Conclusions with Reasons
Summary
We have come to the following conclusions on the limited information before us:
First, in our judgment, there would, at present, be a material risk of harm to children if the Suspension was not in place. We are satisfied that the relevant (and relatively low) threshold relating to risk is met. In other words, we are satisfied that a reasonable person would believe that continued provision of childcare by the Appellant to any child at the Setting may expose such a child to a risk of significant harm.
Second, in our judgment, the Suspension is, at present, objectively justified as proportionate.
We set out further reasoning below. What follows is not designed to cover all of the matters touched on in documents. It is however designed to be sufficient to clarify the core reasons why we reached our decision.
Our Decision Regarding Risk
Stepping back and trying to look at things in the round, we are satisfied that, as at the date of the Hearing, there are reasonable grounds to believe that the provision of the relevant service by the Appellant may expose children to a risk of significant harm. We rely on the following in support of this view.
The Incident
While – and we stress this – we make no conclusive findings about the Incident, we are satisfied that the Incident may well have occurred broadly in the way alleged by the Whistleblowers.
There are a number of factors which, in our judgment, support this. First there is the evidence relating to what the Whistleblowers claim to have witnessed:
In her disclosures on 12 and 15 June 2026, Ms Morgan stated that Mr Baker had, in her view, put the Child “in danger” by his actions. She referred to seeing him put a blanket “over [the Child’s] head” and to have “held it there with his arm so [the Child] couldn’t get [the Child’s] head out as the Child kept moving”. She referred to then seeing Mr Baker “get on top of the child and sit on [the Child] to stop [the Child] until [the Child] had cried [themselves] to sleep and then got off” the Child. She referred to the Child having not wanted to go to sleep and to being “forced” to do so. She referred to understanding/believing that the Child now “cried when going to bed at home” due, in her view, to the Child being “scared”.
Ms Emery’s email of 12 June is similar. She stated that the Incident took place about 12.45pm, during what she described as “sleep time”. She stated that she, along with another practitioner (who we infer is a reference to Ms Morgan), was trying to get the Child to sleep. She said the Child didn’t seem to want to sleep. She said the Child was “having cuddles” with her instead, but then “went to bite”. She said she told the Child not to do that and Mr Baker then “came over” to get the Child to sleep. She stated that Mr Baker “placed a blanket over the child’s head and then put his arm around the top of the blanket so the child could not get out the child was crying alot [sic] at this point.” She added: “He then straddled the child but didn’t put any downwards pressure on them.” She said the Child continued to cry for five minutes, then stopped, at which point Mr Baker got off and pulled the blanket from the Child’s head.
Ms Morgan may, according to the notes of the LADO Meeting, have then provided an account to the police. It is suggested that she stated that Mr Baker did not apply any “pressure” to the Child’s body and added some details: referring to a “fleecy” blanket, to the Child “screaming and crying”, and to “faint marks” under the eyes. She is reported to have stated that only she, Ms Emery, and Mr Baker were in the room when the Incident occurred (which we take to mean that they were the only other adults in the room).
Ms Emery may also, it seems, have provided a follow-up account to police. She appears to have added that she had not witnessed any similar behaviour from, or had any other relevant concerns relating to, Mr Baker.
There is nothing to suggest to us that the Whistleblowers have a motivation to lie about what they saw. While they may be mistaken about what they saw, that seems less likely given there are two of them and both seem to have provided consistent accounts.
Second, there is the evidence relating to the Child’s mother’s position. According to that, she was on a lunch break at the time of the Incident, so did not witness it directly. She had two children at the Setting. She stated that, on her return, Mr Baker informed her he had got the Child to sleep. She was grateful, initially, as the Child had seemed tired and in need of a nap. Later, she stated, a colleague told her Mr Baker had placed a blanket over the Child’s head and rested his arms so the Child could not get out, and that the Child had cried and tried to get out from underneath the blanket. At that point, she was told, Mr Baker had “squatted” over the Child, albeit without applying pressure, and carried on trying to get the Child to sleep. She said she was told that another colleague later removed the blanket and that the Child was “all hot and sweaty”. She said that, once awake, the Child was “really quiet” and “cuddly”. The evidence indicates that the Child’s mother resigned following the Incident and will not be bringing the Child back to the Setting.
Third, and while we are cautious about placing too much weight on this given that they were not substantiated, there are the previous allegations. There is an allegation Mr Baker had, just a couple of years ago, hit a child with special needs and/or a disability. It appears to be indicated by Ofsted that part of the reason that was not taken further – and/or why a suspension put in place by Ofsted was lifted – was that Ms Baker had provided assurances. Then, it said that Ms Baker had had some relevant allegations made against her in 2021, and that Mr Baker’s corroboration had been important in them not being found to be substantiated. There is a pattern of potentially relevant allegations, involving Mr Baker directly or indirectly, which, we think, appears to add something to the overall risk profile.
Fourth, there is a notable absence of any evidence from Mr Baker before us. He could have provided a statement, denying the Incident or placing it in a certain context. But we have nothing directly from him (whether in the form of a written statement or oral evidence). There is also evidence that Mr Baker gave “no comment” responses in a police interview. We are cautious about placing weight on either matter and do not regard them as significant features of this case. Mr Baker may, of course, have been acting on legal advice, particularly given the apparently ongoing police investigation. However, the absence of a clear and direct account from him means there is less evidence before us that is capable of undermining, explaining, or placing in context the accounts provided by others.
In coming to our view, we do note there is evidence which points against our view in relation to the Incident. First, there is an indirect (if brief) account of Mr Baker’s position recorded in the LADO Meeting. The Advanced Case Practitioner is reported as having shared in the meeting that Mr Baker had “reportedly described supporting a child to sleep by rubbing the Child’s back and referred to challenges linked to the child’s behaviour”. Second, there is evidence, from various sources, that Mr Baker has apparently not been directly observed to have engaged in other concerning conduct at the Setting. Third, there is a written account said to come from Ms Teale. According to this account, Mr Baker and Ms Baker have been open, honest, warm and welcoming with her. Ms Teale has put her own children in the Setting, where she’s not observed any issues. She has recently been given a career opportunity at the Setting. In relation to the Incident, Ms Teale states the Child’s mother made it clear she’d like the Child to sleep, over the lunch period, as the Child was set to go to the Child’s father’s and would need or benefit from a nap before doing so. Ms Teale states that Mr Baker “was asked to come and try settle” the Child and “agreed to give it a try”. She writes that he “sat at the side” of the Child, spoke softly and patted the Child’s back. She says, as the Child was still “unsettled”, Mr Baker “moved” so he was “on all fours in a crawling position over the lower half” of the Child’s body, with “his hands on either side of the mat”. She says the Child was “still able to move and get up if he had wanted to”. She says that, “from where [she] was in the room”, she could see daylight between them, there was no force, and the Child was not “held or pinned down”. She says Mr Baker then moved back to the side as the Child settled and “stroked [the Child’s] face” as the Child fell asleep. She does not say that a blanket was (or was not) involved: she is silent on that.
It seems clear that there is likely to be some dispute, at least to an extent, on the particular facts of the Incident. It is not necessary to resolve any such dispute for the purposes of this appeal. However, we are satisfied there is sufficient evidence to meet the relatively low threshold required at this stage in our analysis. In other words, and while recognising we may be wrong, we have developed what we judge to be a “reasonable belief” that the Incident occurred broadly along the lines of the accounts provided by the Whistleblowers.
Wider Concerns
We also consider there to be sufficient evidence, at this stage, pointing towards wider concerns which add materially to the overall risk profile. We consider there to be reasonable grounds to believe there is a material risk relating to what can be referred to as the wider safeguarding culture or leadership culture.
Having formed a reasonable belief that the Incident occurred or may well have occurred broadly as alleged by the Whistleblowers, the evidence indicates, in our view, that the following matters point towards wider cultural problems/issues:
First, it would appear that the Whistleblowers did not, whether individually or collectively, feel able to raise their concerns within the Setting. This may be because the person they ought to do that with was Mr Baker. It may be because of the nature/closeness of the relationship between Mr Baker and Ms Baker (i.e. as life and work partners). It may be because of an overly close management group extending to Ms Green. Again, we make no conclusive finding, but there is a risk that the leadership/management group, for whatever reason, conducts itself in ways that have led to staff not feeling able to raise potentially serious concerns directly and swiftly with it.
Second, and on a similar theme, it would appear that the Whistleblowers did not feel able, or consider it appropriate, to seek to challenge – or intervene, in the moment, in any other direct way – what they say they saw Mr Baker doing, despite, on their accounts, believing it to be wrong. That again suggests there may well be a material issue with the organisational culture at the Setting.
Third, there is only limited evidence, to date at least, that Ms Baker (and/or Mr Baker) has sufficient insight into the salient risk(s) arising from this case. She is said for example to have been very defensive when it was discussed at home (despite not having been present during the Incident). She does not deal head on with apparent issues in her letter to Ofsted or in her appeal documentation. There is a possibility, based on the historical information, that Mr Baker and Ms Baker have a pattern of supporting each other in light of allegations of poor practice or misconduct.
Fourth, there is a suggestion that, in the past, when allegations were made about another member of staff, the leadership team did not report the matter properly to either Ofsted or the LADO.
Fifth, there is some evidence, from the external music professional, that there are, in his or her view, wider issues relating to culture or wider practice (as referred to further above).
Building on and related to this point, we are not satisfied that the steps that have been taken or proposed by Ms Baker would be sufficient to reduce the risks we have in mind to an acceptable level:
First, although she has stated that Mr Baker has been suspended, there is insufficient information or assurance in relation to this measure. It may well be complicated by the fact he is her partner in business/life. There is no information about what steps will come next in relation to the suspension. Will there be an investigation? Who will do it? Will it be sufficiently independent? Will it be a reasonable one? There is nothing, it seems, to effectively prevent Ms Baker from simply lifting the suspension at any time. Further, she refers to “demoting” Mr Baker, which perhaps indicates an intention for him to return, albeit in a less senior role. All of this is unclear.
Second, although there is a suggestion that, at least temporarily, Ms Green would step into Mr Baker’s shoes, there are some question marks about whether she may be part of the problem rather than the solution, noting the reference to her allegedly being part of an overly close management group.
Third, and in any event, there are concerns about Ms Baker herself, arising from this case. There is the apparent view of at least one professional that Ms Baker’s attitude towards the apparent incident has not been of a type one would expect from a leader of a nursery trusted to look after vulnerable children. There is also the historical allegation(s), which may still have some (if limited) relevance in light of more recent events.
We note there is evidence pointing towards a more positive leadership and/or safeguarding culture. There are positive accounts, for example, from Ms Baker, Ms Green, Mr Edgson, Ms Bilton, and Ms Teale. Again, therefore, there is likely to be a dispute as to such matters. It may have been helpful, from the Appellant’s perspective, had we had an opportunity to hear directly from Ms Baker, Mr Baker, Ms Green (or others). We could have asked them some questions and sought to test their evidence. That may have given us more confidence in such accounts. That cuts both ways, however, and applies to Ofsted’s witness. But we note that it was the Appellant who sought a hearing on the papers. On balance, we are satisfied, on the limited evidence before us, that there is a material risk in relation to wider cultural/leadership/organisational matters and that any apparent plans are not sufficient, at present, to reduce or manage the risk(s) sufficiently.
Our Decision Regarding Proportionality
Being satisfied that the risk threshold is met, we turn to the second question about proportionality. In the circumstances, we are satisfied that the Suspension is, at present, objectively justified as proportionate.
First, the harm contemplated is more than merely trivial or minor: it is, in our view, sufficiently significant/serious. It could, realistically, include a significant level of physical, emotional, psychological, or developmental harm. If the Incident occurred in the way alleged by the Whistleblowers, the Child appears to have been put at a risk of: (a) physical harm (we note that there is some suggestion of marks to the face); and/or (b) emotional/psychological/developmental harm (e.g. the Incident, as alleged, may well have been highly unpleasant for the Child at the time, and the Child may struggle in future to trust adults meant to be caring for them, or have issues around sleep). Indeed, and while we would not wish to overstate this, there may have been a risk of serious injury or even potentially death from the Incident as alleged: the Child may have, while crying/struggling, have been impacted by some other issue that would not have been clear to Mr Baker or others and which could have been left not dealt with (e.g. choking); or the Child may have potentially have been suffocated from the blanket, or from the Child’s position on going to sleep (there is some suggestion, we note, that the Child may have been facing down). There is a possibility that other children witnessed the Incident and, if so, were adversely impacted in a significant way by having done so. There is only limited evidence, at present, of well-developed insight. At this time, in light of the other evidence, any positive points or plans are not sufficient, in our view, to reduce the overall risk profile enough.
Second, there is a legitimate aim engaged in relation to the measure adopted. It relates to the protection of vulnerable children from a risk of significant harm. The Suspension relates directly to the pursuance or achievement of that aim. The high importance of that aim means that the Suspension is more readily justified as proportionate. The immediate purpose is to keep children safe during a (limited) period of time in which the Appellant and/or Ofsted can carry out further assessment or take further steps to reduce risk to an acceptable level. The Suspension is justified, for these reasons, at present. We are told Ofsted is now advancing its enquiries at pace – and we would expect to see that happen – and that the same will (or perhaps has now already) involve interviews with the people involved, including Mr and Ms Baker. Further steps may well need to be taken, by Ofsted or the Appellant, to manage any relevant risk. There are some steps that could potentially be taken, even though the Setting is currently closed, such as the provision of stronger evidence in relation to insight, learning, future plans, etc. It may be possible for Ofsted to lift the Suspension, if satisfied at some future point, that the Appellant has taken adequate steps. Importantly, Ofsted is under a duty (pursuant to Regulation 11) to keep the Suspension under review.
Third, we have endeavoured to have careful regard to the adverse impact of the Suspension, on the Appellant and any other relevant people. We can see that, generally, it may well have an adverse impact. It may very well reduce the Appellant’s income, and/or cause reputational damage, and/or result in problems next year (if permitted to re-open). That said there is a lack of direct or persuasive evidence from the Appellant about the real nature and degree of any such impact. There is no sufficient evidence before us that it, or any relevant children or others, are or will be, as a result of the Suspension continuing, disproportionately impacted. There is, for example, no financial evidence before us to support a suggestion the business is at risk of total failure. The Suspension is limited in both scope and time – and, importantly, now has only 7 or so more days to run. The adverse impact may well have already occurred now, in any event, given that the window “before summer” referred to by Ms Baker in her Appeal documentation may well have passed. Overall we are content, on the current evidence, that the high importance of the legitimate aim outweighs the adverse impact at present. In forming this view, we have in mind the limited period of restriction and, in addition, the obligation on Ofsted to actively keep it under review.
Fourth, in light of the above, we are satisfied that the legitimate aim cannot realistically be achieved adequately by a less-restrictive measure (whether by way of potential “conditions” or any other alternative). This is especially the case, in our view, given that relevant concerns extend beyond the (alleged) acts of just one member of staff. It is both appropriate and reasonably necessary, in our view, for the Suspension to remain in force at this point in time. Our decision is based, as it must be, at the time of the Hearing and on the basis that the restriction is now due (in principle at least – although we cannot say whether Ofsted intend to seek to extend it) to end shortly. We did not consider it necessary to, in addition, rely on the importance of any wider legitimate aim, such as that of maintaining public confidence in the overall statutory scheme. But, had we done so, that may have been a further factor supporting our decision.
In our judgment, the Decision (and, to be clear, the subsequent decision to not lift the Suspension) was rational, proportionate, and lawful – and continues, for now at least, to be so. The statutory criteria for suspension remain satisfied.
Outcome
The Appeal is dismissed. The Decision is confirmed.
Judge SJW Lewis
First-tier Tribunal (Health, Education and Social Care)
Date Issued: 21 July 2026
