20501
DEFAULT SURCHARGE – reasonable excuse – illness of bookkeeper – underlying reasons giving rise to insufficiency – did the Appellant satisfy burden of proof – yes – section 59(7) Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 71(1) Value Added Tax Act 1994
LONDON TRIBUNAL CENTRE
T SHIRT & SONS LIMITED Appellant
- and -
THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HER MAJESTY’S
REVENUE AND CUSTOMS Respondents
Tribunal: Nicholas Aleksander (Chairman)
Praful Davda
Sitting in public in London on 21 November 2007
The Appellant did not appear and was not represented
Simon Chambers, advocate of the Solicitor’s Office of HM Revenue and Customs, for the Respondents
© CROWN COPYRIGHT 2007
DECISION
This is an appeal against a default surcharge in respect of the late payment of VAT for the period February 2007 to April 2007. Mr Simon Chambers represented Customs. The Appellant wrote to the tribunal in advance of the hearing stating that in view of work constraints they were unable to attend the hearing, but requested that the hearing proceed in their absence. Accordingly the tribunal determined to proceed under rule 26(2) of the Value Added Tax Tribunals Rules 1986 (as amended).
The default surcharge arose in respect of the Appellant’s VAT return for the period February 2007 to April 2007. The VAT was paid electronically and was received by Customs on 8 June 2007. Under long standing arrangements, Customs grant an automatic extension for the submission of VAT returns and payments if payment is made by an approved electronic method. In such cases payment must be received in Customs’ bank account by the seventh calendar day after the standard due date. The standard due date for the period would have been 31 May 2007. As payment was made electronically, this was extended to 7 June 2004. Payment was actually received by Customs on 8 June 2007.
The Appellant is a small business. The business employs Ms M Stephens as a part time bookkeeper who works on Tuesdays and Wednesdays only. She cannot work on other days due to child care commitments. In order for the VAT payment to reach Customs’ bank account via BACS by the due date (as extended), the payment would need to be made by the Appellant on Tuesday 5 June 2007, as it takes three working days for payments to clear when made through BACS. On that date Ms Stephens and her young child were both ill, and she was unable to attend work. In her correspondence with the tribunal she states that the managing director (who deals with the businesses finances with her) was out making calls on Tuesday 5 June and was not available to deal with the VAT payment in her absence. Ms Stephens also states that despite the fact that she still did not feel well, and was worrying about her child she did attend on the following day to deal with urgent business, which included making the VAT payment and dealing with the VAT return.
Mr Chambers, for Customs, does not dispute the illness of Ms Stephens or her child and acknowledges that she was unable to attend work on 5 June. However he submits that the illness of Ms Stephens and her small child cannot amount to a reasonable excuse. He submits that there is always a risk of illness and unexpected absence in a small business, and that such businesses should have contingency plans. He also submits that the Appellant’s directors are primarily responsible for dealing with filing VAT returns and paying VAT, and that in Ms Stephens’ absence, one of the directors should have dealt with the return. He also submits that if the Appellant had called Customs’ telephone enquiry line, it would have been told that it could make its payment on 6 June by CHAPS rather than BACS, and the amount would have reached Customs’ bank account by the extended due date.
Section 71(1) Value Added Tax Act 1994 provides that reliance by the Appellant upon any other person to perform a task cannot be a reasonable excuse, and therefore the reliance by the Appellant upon Ms Stephens cannot of itself be a reasonable excuse. However the Tribunal can look at the underlying reasons why Ms Stephens did not arrange for the VAT to be paid and on time. We consider that the illness of herself and her son on Tuesday 5 June was a reasonable excuse, and we note that on the following day Ms Stephens (whilst still not feeling well) attended work and arranged for the VAT to be paid. We do not agree that it is reasonable to expect a small business to have to make contingency plans to deal with illness or absence of this nature, or that in these circumstances it should be required to call the Customs’ telephone enquiry line.
Our decision on the issue for determination in the appeal is that the Appellant had a reasonable excuse for the late late payment of the VAT for the period April 07. That means that the appeal is allowed.
Nicholas Aleksander
CHAIRMAN
RELEASE DATE: 7 December 2007
LON/2007/1503