
Swindon Combined Court
The Law Courts
Islington Street
Swindon SN1 2HG
Before
HIS HONOUR JUDGE RICHARD CASE
Re Alfie (a Child)(Welfare)
WILTSHIRE COUNCIL
Applicant
and
MOTHER (1)
FATHER (2)
ALFIE (THE CHILD) (3)
Respondents
Representation
For the Applicant:
Colin Morgan, counsel instructed by the Applicant Council
For the Respondents:
Sorrel Dixon, counsel instructed by the First Respondent Mother
Nicole Tanner, solicitor for the Second Respondent Father
Charlotte Pitts, counsel instructed by the Third Respondent child by their Child’s Guardian, Natalie Morgan
Hearing dates: 23-24 September and 28 September 2026
This judgment was delivered in private. The judge has given permission for this version of the judgment to be published on condition that (irrespective of what is contained in the judgment) in any published version of the judgment the anonymity of the children and members of their family must be strictly preserved. All persons, including representatives of the media and legal bloggers, must ensure that this condition is strictly complied with. Failure to do so may be a contempt of court.
APPROVED JUDGMENT
This judgment was handed down at a hearing listed at 3pm 28 September 2026.
Contents
Physical, emotional, educational needs and age, sex and background 12
Any harm suffered or at risk of suffering 13
(1) What type of harm has arisen and might arise? 13
(2) How likely is it to arise? 15
(4) To what extent might the risks be reduced or managed? 15
(3) What would be the consequences for the child if it did? 25
(5) What other welfare considerations have to be taken into account? 25
(6) In consequence, which of the realistic plans best promotes the child’s welfare? 25
Relationship with relatives, prospective adopter and their wishes and feelings 25
Holistic balancing exercise 30
Realistic Option 1: Adjournment 30
Realistic Option 2: Placement with Mother in the future under Supervision Order or no order 30
Realistic Option 3: Care Order with a care plan of foster care 31
Narrative Summary
This case concerns Alfie, now aged three. When he was between 18 and 21 months old he suffered a series of serious injuries whilst living with his Mother and her then partner. Following a fact-finding hearing, I found that the Mother’s former partner deliberately inflicted multiple injuries on Alfie over a period of several months. I also found that the Mother failed to protect Alfie from harm, failed to seek appropriate medical treatment for some of his injuries, exposed him to domestic abuse within the home and misused cannabis whilst caring for him.
Alfie has now lived with his foster carers since January 2025. The evidence before me is that he has thrived in their care. He is developing well, has formed secure attachments to them and is beginning to receive specialist therapeutic support to address the significant emotional impact of his early experiences. The evidence from CAMHS, the social worker, the parenting assessor and the Children’s Guardian demonstrates that, although Alfie has recovered physically, he continues to show signs of psychological trauma resulting from the abuse and neglect he experienced.
The Mother plainly loves Alfie and has maintained regular contact with him throughout these proceedings. Her commitment to him is not in doubt. However, the professional evidence is unanimous that she lacks sufficient insight into why Alfie was harmed and into the steps necessary to protect him in the future. She continues to minimise aspects of the findings made against her, has ongoing vulnerabilities relating to her mental health and substance misuse, and remains unable to demonstrate that she could safely meet Alfie’s complex emotional and therapeutic needs. Shortly before this hearing she experienced a further mental health crisis and criminal proceedings relating to her care of Alfie are expected to follow. The evidence does not support a conclusion that Alfie could safely return to her care within a timescale that meets his needs.
I have considered whether proceedings should be adjourned to allow further assessment of the Mother or of a maternal great aunt. I have also considered a plan of long-term foster care. However, these proceedings have already lasted approximately twenty months. Alfie urgently requires permanence, stability and certainty. Further delay would risk undermining both his emotional wellbeing and the therapeutic work that is now beginning. There is no positive assessment of any family member able to care for him and the evidence is that delaying a decision would be contrary to his welfare.
Having considered all realistic options, I conclude that Alfie’s welfare requires him to remain permanently with his current carers, who have been approved as prospective adopters. Adoption will provide him with the lifelong security, stability and sense of belonging that he needs. Although adoption will sever his legal relationship with his birth family and significantly reduce future contact, I am satisfied that no lesser order would adequately protect him or meet his lifelong welfare needs. Care and Placement Orders are therefore necessary and proportionate.
In reaching that conclusion I recognise the sadness of the outcome for Alfie’s parents. Nevertheless, my responsibility is to determine what best promotes Alfie’s welfare throughout the rest of his life. The overwhelming professional evidence is that his future welfare is best served through adoption.
Parties
I am concerned with Alfie (anonymised); he is aged 3 but was aged between 18 and 21 months at the time of injuries I found he suffered. I will refer to the parents as the Mother and Father and the Mother’s partner at all relevant times as the Intervenor. Again, this is for anonymisation purposes and no disrespect is intended.
Background
I previously conducted a fact-finding hearing. The background, together with my findings, are set out in detail in the judgment following that hearing in Re Alfie (a Child)(Fact Finding: Multiple Inflicted Injuries) [2026] EWFC 103 (B). I have copied the summary from that judgment below:
Alfie (anonymised name), a boy aged between 18 and 21 months at the relevant time and now aged 3, sustained multiple injuries including very serious fractures whilst in the care of his Mother and her former partner. I have to decide how the injuries were caused and whether they were inflicted; if I find they were inflicted I have to decide if they were inflicted by the Mother or her former partner or if there is a real possibility it was either of them.
In summary I find that on various dates between 11 October 2024 and 17 January 2025 the Mother’s former partner (the Intervenor) deliberately inflicted serious injuries on Alfie on eight separate occasions. He inflicted a serious skull fracture, a right arm fracture, four rib fractures on two occasions, bruising to Alfie’s head and face on two occasions, he slapped him hard enough to the face to leave a very clear handprint and he forcefully gripped his face leaving fingertip bruises...
The Mother failed to protect Alfie from the Intervenor; she failed to separate from him to protect Alfie and failed to report him to police or Children’s Social Care, in particular after she became aware the Intervenor had slapped Alfie to the face and inflicted fingertip bruising to his face.
The Intervenor videoed himself applying pressure to bruised areas of Alfie’s face on two occasions and peeling back an obviously swollen lip on one occasion. The videos, particularly of the lip being peeled back, are distressing to watch. The Mother’s counsel said he “effectively tortured” Alfie “to satisfy something in him”; I do not know why he did it and I do not know why he videoed himself probing injuries but his actions caused Alfie very obvious pain. On one occasion, when Alfie had a bruised and swollen face, he videoed himself with Alfie and said “got a fucking elephant face haven’t you” before laughing out loud. It is truly sickening to watch.
The Intervenor and the Mother failed to seek appropriate medical attention for Alfie following an additional fracture to the leg, the arm fracture and facial bruising. Both used cannabis whilst living with Alfie and fought with each other whilst he was present. Alfie is at risk of physical and emotional harm in the care of the Intervenor and Mother.
Alfie is currently in foster care. He will require support via the under 5 psychotherapy pathway within CAMHS to help him re-write the narrative of early trauma experiences. The court appointed Guardian describes it as “an intense service and will consist of 3 appointments a week lasting an hour”. The Local Authority tell me it may last up to two years. It is a measure of the serious and likely life-long consequences of the Mother and Intervenor’s behaviour.
The Mother appealed against three findings that she was in the pool of possible perpetrators of physical harm to Alfie’s groin, left ear and right hip and the Court of Appeal granted that appeal and substituted a finding that the three injuries were caused by the Intervenor (see paragraph 39 of Re B (A Child: Uncertain Perpetrator) [2026] EWCA Civ 1024).
The explanations for the very long delay in this case (proceedings were issued 20 months ago) are the need to review mobile phone evidence and an associated appeal (first fact-finding hearing adjourned), difficulties in relation to obtaining police disclosure (second fact-finding hearing adjourned), a protracted fact-finding hearing (by reason of the Intervenor’s absence) which meant the planned consecutive welfare hearing could not proceed and included an appeal by the Intervenor, a further welfare hearing adjourned (by reason of the most recent appeal by the Mother) and a provisional welfare hearing vacated (by reason of professional availability).
On day one of this fourth attempt at the welfare hearing the Mother did not attend; she had taken an overdose 36 hours beforehand following receipt of information from the police about charging her in relation to her care of Alfie (see below). She attended hospital but did not require medical or mental health treatment and was not admitted but was, I was told, in an understandably fragile mental state. I had previously canvassed her being excused from attendance save for giving evidence or attending by video link. Through counsel I wished her a speedy recovery from this mental health crisis. On the morning of day one I gave a judgment explaining why I would proceed to hear evidence from the parenting assessor and social worker in her absence (with the option of them being recalled if required). I refer to my full judgment but in short I emphasised the need to conclude proceedings in Alfie’s welfare interest. Over the lunch adjournment that day counsel was able to take instructions from the Mother on her position and the Mother elected not to give evidence and wanted counsel to make submissions on her behalf. I did not require her to attend or give evidence.
The Father is not named on Alfie’s birth certificate and does not have parental responsibility. The Mother shares parental responsibility under the current Interim Care Order.
Positions
Local Authority
The Local Authority seek Care and Placement Orders. The Mother currently has twice weekly family time with Alfie; this is supervised in accordance with current police bail conditions.
Upon making Care and Placement Orders the care plan envisages that contact will reduce to weekly (for 2 weeks), then fortnightly (for four weeks) and then monthly although in oral evidence the social worker indicating in fact there would be a farewell contact at that point. Thereafter it is proposed that Mother will have once a year direct, supervised contact and twice-yearly indirect letterbox contact.
The plan is for no contact with the Father but proposes letterbox contact with the maternal and paternal grandparents yearly.
Mother
The Mother previously opposed the Local Authority care plan seeking a return of Alfie to her care, under a Supervision Order if required or an adjournment for a further assessment. Having taken instructions on day one, counsel confirmed the Mother accepted she was not able to have Alfie in her care. As I understood it, this was a reflection both of the bail conditions associated with the criminal proceedings and the recent mental health crisis. She submits I should adjourn proceedings to enable the Maternal Great Aunt to be assessed. This submission was made for the first time in closing submissions. The explanation was that the Mother “had always had faith in the chance of Alfie coming back to her care”. I find that hard to credit in light of the entirety of the professional evidence being directly to the contrary but I must consider the submission on its merits and will do below. In the alternative, her case is that I should make a Care Order with a care plan of long-term foster care rather than a Placement Order.
In relation to contact she seeks an amendment to the care plan to reflect her having direct contact every three months as a minimum.
Father
The Father does not oppose the Local Authority care plan but seeks some form of direct contact and indirect contact.
Children’s Guardian
The Guardian supports the Local Authority care plan, including on contact save that she invited the Local Authority to amend the care plan to provide for annual letterbox contact from the Father.
Evidence Summary
I have had the benefit of considering the welfare bundle for this hearing, in particular:
Parenting assessments prepared by Danielle Shearing dated 19 June 2025 [F116], 12 June 2026 [F209] and 4 September 2026 [F293];
Witness statements of the assistant team manager and allocated social worker dated 18 June 2026 [C224] and 7 September 2026 [C260], care plan [D26] and care plan analysis [C251];
Mother’s statements dated 23 September 2025 [C145], 13 April 2026 [C212], 30 June 2026 [C243] and 16 September 2026 [C264]; and
Guardian’s final analysis dated 17 April 2026 [E126] and addendum dated 3 July 2026 [E168].
I have also seen an email from the police in relation to their charging decision (21 September 2026) and a letter from CAMHS in relation to Alfie’s treatment (3 September 2026).
I heard oral evidence from:
Danielle Shearing, parenting assessor;
Charleigh Porter, assistant team manager; and
The Guardian.
Law
I remind myself that the burden of proving the need for a public law order rests with the Local Authority on the balance of probabilities.
Threshold
I have previously found threshold met.
Welfare
So far as the law on welfare issues is concerned my paramount concern is Alfie’s welfare throughout the rest of his life. In assessing whether to make an order I must take account of the matters set out in section 1(4) Adoption and Children Act 2002 . I must then have regard to the realistic options put forward taking a holistic and balanced as opposed to linear approach to them consistent with the guidance given in Re B-S (Children) [2013] EWCA Civ 1146.
I remind myself I must also have regard to Article 6 and 8 ECHR rights. Pursuant to Re B (Care: Interference with Family Life) [2003] 2 FLR 813 I must not make a public law order unless I am satisfied it is both necessary and proportionate and no other less radical form of order would achieve the need to promote the welfare of the child.
I note that section 21(3) of the Adoption and Children Act 2002 requires parental consent or parental consent to be dispensed with. Pursuant to section 52 Adoption and Children Act 2002 I may only dispense with the required parental consent to a child being placed for adoption if the welfare of the child requires it. In the words of Baroness Hale in the Supreme Court in Re B [2013] UKSC 33 it must be that, “nothing else will do” or in the words of Lord Neuberger it is seen, “as a last resort-when all else fails”.
Contact
By section 27(4) Adoption and Children Act 2002 I must consider the arrangements proposed to be made for allowing any person contact with the child.
I must consider whether to make an order under section 26 Adoption and Children Act 2002. That provides that an order for contact may be made on the making of a Placement Order. Guidance has been provided by the Court of Appeal in Re S (Placement Order Contact) [2025] EWCA Civ 823 in which McFarlane P gave the following judgment:
Standing back from these three authorities, there is a distinction to be drawn between those cases where continuing direct sibling contact is considered to be necessary for the child’s future welfare, and cases where the achievement of an adoptive home is the overarching goal, with future sibling contact being desirable as opposed to a pre-requisite. In the former circumstances (as in Re P and Re R) the court has ‘a responsibility’ to make a s 26 contact order.
The reasoning applies equally to parental contact. The judgment continued (my emphasis):
From a range of perspectives, it is possible to discern a clear shift over recent years in the direction of travel in understanding the approach to be taken to the issue of post-adoption contact. This shift has been driven by research (from a social work and psychological perspective) into arrangements that best meet the complex and life-long needs of children who are to be placed for adoption. The direction of travel is well delineated in the detailed analysis given by Baker LJ in Re R. It is underpinned by the extensive research of Professor Neil and others (both domestically and internationally). It was described in detail and taken up in the recommendations of the PLWG, and, importantly, it is endorsed by CoramBAAF, which has recently enhanced the focus on arrangements for a child to ‘stay in touch’ with family members post-adoption.
The question of how this shift in understanding should be reflected, if at all, by the court in making orders under ACA 2002, s 26 is at the centre of this appeal, and it is a difficult one. The difficulty, in part, arises from the binary nature of a court’s decision whether to make, or not to make, an order, where the underlying factors are in essence subtle and, to a large extent, involve looking into the future when a key element of that future, namely the attitude of specific potential adopters, is a known-unknown. It is easy to understand how courts may opt to play safe and decline to make a s 26 order, when faced with the ‘default opposition’ identified by the ALC, but, as was submitted, a court should consider whether the evidence in the case before it establishes grounds for holding that would-be adopters are likely to be deterred or whether, as the ALC submitted, research does not, in fact, support that conclusion.
…
74...The position of potential adopters should not, to use Baker LJ’s words, obviate the court’s responsibility to set the template for contact at the placement order stage. There will be cases where the importance of preserving a measure of direct sibling contact is such that the court should stipulate that that is so in an order, rather than leaving it to the adoption agency and adopters to negotiate. In other cases, the comparative importance of maintaining contact will be secondary to achieving an adoptive placement, and making a formal order may not be justified.
…
Finally, in terms of general observations on this issue, I wish to endorse Ms Conroy Harris’ valuable suggestion that a form of s 26 order which recognised the importance of continuing contact, but allowed for a significant degree of flexibility, might be the most appropriate means of meeting a child’s needs in some cases. An express order for finite contact arrangements, specifying the number and circumstances in which it is to take place, may not be apt in some cases. Given the number of uncertainties in play at the time that a placement order is being made, a more flexible statement of the road map for future contact that the court has determined for the child may well be more appropriate. In such cases, rather than having an order for contact in concrete terms, the court might record its views, and its endorsement of the future contact plans, in a recital to the placement order.
Risk of Harm
When assessing risk of harm I must ask (by reference to the summary in Re T (Children: Risk Assessment) [2025] EWCA Civ 93 at paragraph 33):
What type of harm has arisen and might arise?
How likely is it to arise?
What would be the consequences for the child if it did?
To what extent might the risks be reduced or managed?
What other welfare considerations have to be taken into account?
In consequence, which of the realistic plans best promotes the child’s welfare?
If the preferred plan involves interference with the Article 8 rights of the child or of others, is that necessary and proportionate?
Welfare checklist
I now turn to the considerations under section 1(4) Adoption and Children Act 2002.
Wishes and feelings
The team manager’s evidence is that Alfie has cried at the end of contact, “a positive reflection on Mother and engagement and commitment to ensuring her time with Alfie is meaningful” but it is also a reflection on how he enjoys time with her. It would be reasonable to conclude he would want to remain in Mother’s care if at all possible although the Guardian’s assessment was:
[E139/53]
I believe if Alfie were able to express a choice, he would choose to remain in [the foster carers’]
care, because he feels safe with them, and has learned to experience joy in their care.
Physical, emotional, educational needs and age, sex and background
Alfie remains in the same placement as when he entered foster care on 29 January 2025, he is said to have “thrived in this placement and is very happy…he is meeting all his milestones”. He has an “exceptional” ability to converse with other children and adults which is said to be “a reflection of the high level of care [he] has had in the last 15 months”. He was “awaiting to begin trauma informed therapy with CAMHS” [C225/2.3] but it was subsequently confirmed this will begin imminently [C261].
The recent CAMHS letter offers the foster carers “weekly psychotherapy parent sessions for you, so that you can have a space to explore Alfie’s communications and needs as well as to think about and process some of your experiences as parents [sic] and the challenges that may lie ahead”. It is a troubling letter to read; it recounts quite disturbing play: “repeated crashing down of the [Playmobil] mother onto the baby”, play that might suggest “he had learned very early in his life that the ordinary demands of a baby or little boy might be unsafe to express and must be hidden away where they cannot be let out” referencing a toy baby shut tightly away in a medicine bottle. Further:
We were curious about what he showed us about his fear of dangerous harm, perhaps from unpredictable adults, suddenly taking over in his mind. At one point he dropped the duplo slide
construction onto the floor, causing the blocks to come apart, and seemed suddenly very anxious about being in trouble. He said ‘Mummy I am not doing this again’, as if he needed to show he was only a very good boy so that we would not get annoyed with him.
I had understood from previous evidence this therapy could last up to two years.
It is reported Alfie remains under the paediatric team for the physical injuries sustained but “there have been no concerns raised about the long term physical impact from the significant injuries he has sustained” but “grave concerns on the emotional and mental health implications…due to the trauma of his experiences” and the foster carers have “raised that in recent months, Alfie has regressed in terms of potty training and is becoming very unsettled and distressed following contact” [C226/2.3]. It was that which prompted the CAMHS therapy to be started before a final order was made.
Any harm suffered or at risk of suffering
Considering the checklist in Re T (Children: Risk Assessment) [2025] EWCA Civ 93:
What type of harm has arisen and might arise?
I have considered the harm suffered by Alfie in my previous judgment. In particular I made findings concerning the Mother’s knowledge of injuries and her failure to protect Alfie. I have removed any finding overturned by the Court of Appeal and have highlighted the key elements in underlined text below:
On 6 November 2024 at around 11.36 the Intervenor slapped Alfie on his left cheek leaving a clear and distinctive handprint which would have resolved to a red mark within one to seven days and which would therefore have been visible to the Mother who was absent at the time but returned shortly afterwards. The mark would have been visible to the Mother who would have been aware it was the result of a slap perpetrated by the Intervenor. The Mother has failed to acknowledge seeing it in order to minimise the extent of her failure to protect Alfie from the Intervenor.
On or about 13 December 2024 the Intervenor gripped Alfie’s head leaving fingerprint bruising to the right cheek and temple. The bruising would have been visible to the Mother who would have been aware it was the result of excessive force from the application of fingertips and perpetrated by the Intervenor.
I made the following further findings:
Alfie is at risk of physical and emotional harm in the care of the Intervenor and/or the Mother.
The Mother and Intervenor failed appropriately to seek medical advice in relation to a leg injury sustained by Alfie on or before 12 January 2025 when symptoms failed to resolve following initial advice on 14 January 2025. The delay was from 18 January 2025 until 23 January 2025.
The Mother and Intervenor failed appropriately to seek advice in relation to bruising to Alfie’s face sustained on or about 11 October 2024, 14 October 2024 and 28 October 2024.
Neither the Mother nor Intervenor presented Alfie to a medical professional in relation to the right radius fracture in circumstances where distress post-fracture would have been notable and behaviour noticeably different as evidenced in part by two photos of Alfie guarding his right arm on 3 November 2024.
The Mother and Intervenor used cannabis in the home where Alfie resided during the day when Alfie was present. This placed him at risk of significant physical and emotional harm and neglect.
The Mother’s misuse of cannabis put Alfie at serious risk of harm and made her less responsive and able to protect him.
The Mother failed to take action after 6 November 2024 (slap to left side of face) at which point she would also have been aware of a recent injury on 28 October 2024 (bruising to the right cheek and temple) and around 3 November 2024 (fracture to right radius).
The Mother failed to take action after 13 December 2024 (fingertip bruising to right side of face).
The Mother failed to separate from the Intervenor despite having the opportunity to do so and/or failed to report him to Children’s Social Care or the police.
The Mother failed to protect Alfie from emotional harm arising from domestic abuse by permitting him to be present when she and the Intervenor were arguing in person (for example on 20 November 2024, 4 December 2024, and 20 December 2024) and by phone (on 20 December 2024).
On 20 November and 20 December 2024 the Mother and Intervenor argued loudly with Alfie present in the room. On 4 December 2024 the Intervenor slapped the Mother on the forehead. On two occasions the Mother slapped the Intervenor. On one occasion the Intervenor pushed the Mother. The actions of the Mother and Intervenor are likely to have placed Alfie at risk of emotional harm.
Alfie suffered physical and emotional harm in the care of the Intervenor and the Mother between 11 October 2024 and 23 January 2025.
The risks from the Mother therefore arise from failures to seek medical advice in relation to the leg fracture, facial bruising and arm fracture, drug misuse, exposure to a risky adult (the Intervenor) and emotional harm by exposure to domestic abuse.
How likely is it to arise?
To what extent might the risks be reduced or managed?
I will take these two together. They need to be considered in various contexts:
Physical harm
In the first parenting assessment the assessor said she was “not convinced [the Mother] has a full understanding” of the impact of physical harm on Alfie [F136/9.28] and whilst she recognised that it was a mistake to introduce a new partner to Alfie “so early on without knowing him herself…what I have not heard the Mother state is that she will be more active at reaching out for her support network” [F138/10.7].
The Mother does not accept that she knew Alfie had been slapped on 6 November 2024 [C244/4]. That is maintained even now in her most recent statement in which the Mother says, “had I known that he was being hurt by the Intervenor, then I would have responded differently” [C265/4]. I find that particularly troubling. The medical evidence was that the mark would have been visible for one to seven days. In the photos taken at 11.36 on 6 November 2024 [H352 and H376 in the fact-finding bundle] it is abundantly clear Alfie had been slapped. The net effect of the timing of the photos and the Mother’s evidence was she would have been home within about 55 minutes of the photo being taken (see my judgment at [A331/254]). It is just not credible she did not see the slap mark and could not have identified it as such. I found she lied about it. The fact she does not accept this presents a very serious risk of harm: how can she be trusted in the future to report harm to Alfie?
Even leaving that aside, I made numerous findings against her which she does accept saying “I largely accept that I failed to protect Alfie during the five months that he sustained those injuries” [C243/3]. It is still concerning this is not said with as much certainty as might have been expected given the seven findings of failure to protect or failure to act on injuries that I made. It is more troubling still that the Guardian reports the Mother telling her on 2 July 2026 “‘If I thought Alfie was coming to harm, I would have done something about it’, and ‘at no point did I think Alfie was being abused’” [E173/15]. I found she did know and she did nothing meaningful. The fact that she does not accept it again makes it very difficult to see how Alfie can be safe in her care in the future. It is an abdication of responsibility.
Further, in her addendum analysis the Guardian reported the Mother saying (in relation to the current foster carers and the Local Authority) “They took him off me when I had done nothing wrong, then placed him in the same area as his abuser [i.e. with foster carers who live in the same area as the Intervenor]” [E175/19]. To say she “had done nothing wrong” is breathtaking given the findings I made against her; it demonstrates more than limited insight, it is either closing her mind to the reality of the situation she finds herself in as a means of self-protection or it betrays her real view which is she was not responsible in any way. In either case it puts Alfie at risk of harm in her care.
The Guardian went further, even before my findings were made, saying (my emphasis):
[E135]
31…The Mother’s role in the serious and prolonged harm suffered by Alfie cannot be viewed solely as a case of one adult in the home being the perpetrator and the other a non-perpetrator. The abuse was not a one-off incident; it was prolonged abuse over 4-5 months.
[E136]
The reality is that Alfie was not yet two years of age, was incredibly vulnerable, and was entirely reliant on his mother to act protectively. In the care of his mother and her partner, he suffered numerous injuries- likely caused by deliberate incidences of violence- and the pain he suffered must have been intolerable.
[E137]
Had Mother been honest from the outset- or even if she had made admissions at any point in these proceedings- there might have been some optimism for her gaining insight and developing more protective abilities, to safely care for Alfie in the future…However, failing to disclose the truth has in my view firmly closed the door to reunification.
Whilst I have formed these views based on my analysis of the evidence, I recognise that the Court may find that the Mother did not know about what was happening to Alfie. In that eventuality I remain of the view that the deficits in her parenting are such that they prevent her from providing safe care to Alfie in the future. These deficits include her failure to recognise that his multiple bruises were highly suspicious; her inability to recognise how Alfie might have felt when caught up in the crossfire of her relationship; her failure to seek medical attention after sustaining his many injuries; as well as the wider issues relating to her mental health and substance and alcohol misuse.
It is also quite troubling that having “largely” accepted the findings, the Mother goes on in her statement of 30 June 2026 to say she feels “very let down by the Local Authority and feel like they have held me to an impossible standard”. Having addressed, to a very limited extent, her reflections on my judgment in two very short paragraphs the Mother went on to criticise the Local Authority’s former social worker, the parenting assessor, the new social worker, the placement location and express concern that “Alfie’s voice isn’t being listened to” and about the foster carers [C244-246].
In her second report the parenting assessor said:
[F229/13.22]
I appreciate that The Mother is now saying she would not be making this mistake again [introducing the Intervenor quickly into Alfie’s life] and would not be looking for a relationship currently and would wait before moving Alfie into the home. However, these decisions previously appeared to be bred out of some level of loneliness and the Mother appeared to have limited socialising opportunities as a parent than previously. The Mother has reverted to a similar lifestyle it appears, of socialising in clubs and pubs that she states were the likely exposure to cocaine use and drinking high levels of alcohol. I would question how Mother will adapt to prioritising Alfie’s [needs?] by giving up on that lifestyle when evidently that has not happened in his absence.
Commenting more generally she said that the severity of the situation, as determined at the fact-finding hearing, was such that it is difficult to accept that it was “exclusively a result of her drug taking at the time and these concerns stretch much wider into reflecting incredibly poor parenting. The degree of the severity of the concerns suggests that this parenting pattern was entrenched” and she concluded that “The Mother presents a continuing risk of both physical and emotional harm to a child, particularly in circumstances where she may again defer care to others or fail to intervene when concerns arise” [F230].
The assistant team manager accepted that the Mother had reflected on the findings but “her reflections, at present, tend to be surface level” [C233]. In light of my analysis above, I agree. She developed this saying that her statements “reflect a lack of responsibility to what she ‘did not do’ to protect Alfie” and “limited insight into the risks posed and an ongoing minimisation of her role in safeguarding Alfie” [C233]. Again, I agree. The oral evidence of the parenting assessor was that, “whilst she’s quite alert to avoiding this particular type of harm it was quite a unique set of circumstances, she hasn’t grasped other forms and lesser harms than this can still be harmful, not grasped why it happened on her watch and how to prevent it in the future”.
Having met the Mother on 3 July 2026, the Guardian concluded in her addendum:
[E173/14]
…whilst she recognised she had failed to protect Alfie and accepted this particular finding of the Court, this was followed with the caveat that she was completely unaware of what was happening to Alfie at the time. I consider this to be a significant downplaying of the finding; accepting that she failed to protect Alfie but then discharging self-responsibility through a plea of ignorance, points to poor insight and ongoing denial.
That chimes entirely with the team manager’s and my own analysis.
The parenting assessor was asked in cross-examination how these shortcomings may be addressed, she agreed it is hard to have a clear view when in a coercive relationship but “she has had that support, the conventional support for someone a victim of domestic abuse and coercive control”. The implication is that despite this there are still the concerns set out above.
Domestic abuse
Although the parenting assessor thought that there may be some merit in a Family Group Conference (first report [F141/11.9]) she said that:
[F140]
It is curious that despite Mother talking so positively about her family and her belief that they are very close knit; she only named her mother as a source of support from family. It may be because [she] is the only one that can provide practical support to her. However, I worry that the Mother’s mother has identified that Mother has been struggling in a domestically abusive relationship within the presence of her grandchild and has failed to intervene to protect Alfie or support Mother in escaping the relationship. In this context her support does not appear to extend to offer any valuable protection to her grandson or daughter.
…
[F143]
I worry that despite having a large and loving family, her support network is weak, and it is a particular vulnerability that her mother, as her main source of support was not able to demonstrate an awareness of how domestic abuse can impact children and chose to become less involved with Mother when she did identify a potential concern.
The assessor recorded the Mother was undertaking domestic abuse work [F123/7.12], the engagement had been good but there was a concern about minimising and normalising drug misuse [F124/7.15] (see further below).
By the time of the second report the work had been completed but the assessor considered that “given the gravity of what is now known regarding the context of Alfie’s experiences, I am not convinced further support of this nature would be enough to mitigate further risks of this nature” [F214/6.3].
In the third report the assessor expressed concern that the Mother’s approach appears to be that she wants to move forwards quickly in a relationship which is not unusual within “her circle of friends and family” and did not fully understand the rationale of why new partners should not be taking on caring responsibilities for Alfie early [F297]. Her concern was, if the Mother thought a new relationship was positive for her it would be positive for Alfie and “she may not commit to resisting a premature introduction of that person to Alfie. This seems a more likely possibility when this is normal behaviour within her community and therefore her support network is unlikely to be able to recognise the concern with this decision” [F299/6.9]. She concluded on the point:
[F299/6.10]
I do not feel Mother has been able to reflect on the full depth of concern regarding her handing over her parenting duties to the Intervenor with what appears to be such ease. She put in no barriers when the Intervenor involved himself with her parenting, for example stating he would not be permitted to be alone with Alfie or undertake personal care tasks. She still appears to struggle to see why this would have been a risk to Alfie and mentalise how that experience could have been for Alfie.
Drug misuse
The Local Authority case summary dated 6 July 2026 summarises the drug and alcohol testing in this way, I do not understand it to be in issue:
[A320]
There have been a number of alcohol and substance tests undertaken in respect of Mother. There was active use of cannabis between the end of July 2024 and the end of January 2025. Subsequent HST testing took place on 30 May 2025. In respect of cannabis, the results demonstrated active use of cannabis, a decrease which could be attributed to the cessation of cannabis use either during the period from start of February 2025 until the start of May 2025, or prior use before approximately the start of February 2025. The blood alcohol results demonstrated excessive consumption of alcohol from between approximately 24 April – 21 May 2025.
The results dated 7 August 2025, provided support for the active use of cannabis either between approximately the middle of May and the middle of June 2025 or shortly prior to the middle of May 2025. The results could be consistent with having last used cannabis in May 2025 as declared. The results strongly suggested the excessive consumption of alcohol between approximately the middle of May to the middle of July 2025. The blood results demonstrate excessive consumption of alcohol between approximately 3 – 30 July 2025.
Testing dated 26 February 2026 sets out that the head hair results demonstrate the excessive consumption of alcohol between approximately the start of November 2025 and start of February 2026. The blood test result does not demonstrate excessive alcohol consumption between approximately 23 January – 19 February 2026…In respect of cannabis and cocaine taken in isolation the findings were more likely to be the result of exposure to cannabis/cocaine as opposed to direct ingestion.
The most recent test, dated 16 June 2026, was covering the approximate period of the end of January 2026 and the end of May 2026. Mother declared the use of hair chemical treatments (bleach and dye) during the representative period. In respect of cannabis, taken in isolation the results could be due to either the direct ingestion of cannabis, exposure to the bodily fluids (e.g. sweat) of a cannabis user, or a combination of both. Mother’s declared exposure to the drug could be consistent with the results. In respect of cocaine the findings are more likely to be the result of exposure to cocaine as opposed to direct ingestion…The head hair results do not demonstrate the excessive consumption of alcohol between approximately end of January 2026 and the end of May 2026. The blood result does not demonstrate excessive consumption of alcohol between approximately the 13 May – 9 June 2026. Mother declared last consuming alcohol on 9 May 2026 and that she had last used cannabis in April 2025. She declared
ongoing exposure to cannabis use as recently at 8 June 2026.
In the first parenting assessment the assessor considered the Mother’s substance misuse was a “vulnerability” and that she “does increase substance misuse in times of stress” [F143/12.7]. She referenced an increase in alcohol consumption following the death of the Mother’s father [F126/8.1] and an increase in cannabis use following the start of the relationship with the Intervenor [F127/8.2]. Alcohol use was reported to have increased since Alfie was removed from her care [F127/8.3]. There was a concern that stressful situations provoked this response [F127/8.6].
In her September 2025 statement the Mother acknowledged that she “went through a bad period” where her mental health declined and she misused drugs and alcohol. She said this stopped when she found out she was pregnant with Alfie [C148/14]. She “started smoking cannabis more during” her relationship with the Intervenor and began to drink heavily when Alfie was removed from her care [C149].
In her April 2026 statement she said that friends and family members use cannabis and she has been with them whilst they have been smoking [C215/11]. Consistent with that the most recent hair strand test demonstrated the presence of cannabinoids and cocaine in the Mother’s hair. The presence of cannabinoids was consistent with either ingestion (denied by Mother) or exposure and the presence of cocaine with exposure.
In the second parenting assessment it was recorded the Mother accepted her use of cannabis had been significant and had contributed to her reduced ability to recognise risk to Alfie [F212/5.5], by this time she reported abstinence from cannabis for over a year and from alcohol for “close to one month” recognising that alcohol was used as a coping mechanism [F212] but whilst the assessor considered it positive it was “a new development and not an entrenched change”. It is perhaps surprising then that the Mother in her April statement (admittedly before the second parenting assessment) said that she did not feel she needed any more support at this time [C215/13].
Of most concern under this heading in the second assessment the assessor said:
[F213/5.12]
It appears that the Mother’s wider lifestyle and environment have not changed as she continues to socialise in environments and with people that do use drugs. I am concerned that without making changes to her social network then this would mean that during periods of stress, for example if she once [again?] faced the responsibility of full-time parenting, then she may struggle to maintain her current abstinence.
I consider that the Mother’s evidence demonstrates very limited insight into the effects of drug misuse. In a short paragraph in her 30 June 2026 statement she said she has a female friend she has been spending more time with recently who smokes cannabis but she would not spend time with her if Alfie was with her [C246/11]. It rather begs the question, why not stop contact now if, as the Mother asserted, Alfie should return to her care. That limited insight is demonstrated in the following paragraph in which she said of her support network “Yes, I have some friends who smoke cannabis but I also have plenty who do not” [C246/12]. That rather misses the point. It is hard to see the friends who smoke cannabis being much of a support network for someone seeking to remain abstinent. Worryingly the Mother cannot identify how she was exposed to cocaine at sufficient levels to be detected in her hair [C246/11]. In addressing alcohol misuse the Mother simply said “My mental health worker is supporting me in finding healthy coping strategies to manage stress other than alcohol” [C246/13]. There is no evidence, even having had the second parenting report, of what further support she will put around her to maintain abstinence such as peer support groups like Alcoholics Anonymous or Narcotics Anonymous. In fact the evidence is that the Mother is perpetuating relationships with friends and family who themselves are using drugs.
Mental health
As with drug misuse the Mother accepts poor mental health prior to Alfie’s birth with periods of self-harming [C149/20] but it deteriorated in her relationship with the Intervenor [C149/22].
In the first parenting assessment it was reported the Mother began to struggle with her mental health from the beginning of the relationship with the Intervenor and “that this has escalated significantly since Alfie was removed from her care” [F118/6.1]. In May 2025 she took an overdose of anti-depressants. She admitted self-harm following the death of her father. The parenting assessor commented:
[F119/6.4]
Whilst she hid her self-harm from her family, I question why no one in her family were able to identify from other signs that she may be struggling (such as change in mood or behaviour). One would hope that as the loss of her father was known about by her family that they would
have been more obvious in their presence in supporting Mother. This is a worry because it demonstrates that Mother’s support network may not always be able to recognise that she is developing poor coping strategies, even when they are aware she is having a difficult time. This point is also relevant in the context of Mother’s recent deterioration in her mental health when in the relationship with the Intervenor. The Mother did her best to hide her feelings from her family instead of utilising them for support.
In the second assessment the assessor considered:
[F216]
Mother directly linked her struggles to not having Alfie in her care, describing this as the main reason she feels as she does. However, it is important to remember, as outlined in my first assessment, the Mother was already experiencing vulnerabilities with her mental health prior to falling pregnant with Alfie or meeting the Intervenor. Historically she has been known to manage this with drug use. As it stands there have not been new coping strategies entrenched, this work remains ongoing.
The assistant team manager was concerned the Mother did not attend the Looked After Child review on 16 June 2026 because she was having a bad day but did not let any professional know; the team manager observed “if Alfie was in her care, she would not be able to just not attend an appointment for Alfie and would be expected to be present” [C234].
It is very sad to read that the Mother’s mental health situation still puts her at risk. In her most recent statement she candidly explained a second attempt at taking her own life in July 2026 and just prior to the start of this hearing I was informed by counsel she had taken an overdose following police communicating they intend to charge her in relation to her care of Alfie.
However, as with drug and alcohol concerns, I find the Mother’s insight is limited. In her statement dated 30 June 2026 she said “My mental health was good when I became pregnant with Alfie and after I had him until my relationship with the Intervenor. The fluctuations in my mental health are a direct result of these proceedings” [C247/14]. To a limited extent I can accept that but it ignores the bigger picture, first that the Mother’s mental health was not okay prior to Alfie’s birth and second that having a child in her care whose lived experience is likely to require more attuned parenting is itself likely to be stressful: she will have to live with the fact that she failed to protect Alfie from harm at the same time as sharing age appropriate information about his injuries, her role in them and failing to protect him and meeting his greater needs arising from the emotional harm from them. That is a really tall order. It is insufficient to say, as she seems to in her most recent statement, that her mental health will be fine just as soon as Alfie is back in her care. It is a woefully inadequate analysis of the situation. In this conclusion I concur with the Guardian:
[E138]
Parenting a three-year-old boy- particularly one with Alfie’s history of trauma- will be significantly challenging and stressful for the Mother, and in my view, she is likely to struggle, which would either result in his needs being neglected again, or her turning to another ‘[Intervenor like]’ boyfriend figure to co-parent.
In oral evidence the team manager referenced a missed child looked after review by the Mother, saying in answer to a question about the Mother taking on the CAMHS/therapeutic carer role, “she is not in a position to do that because of her mental health difficulties and recently she didn’t attend the CLA [see C234] because she was unwell, but she would need to attend every session for Alfie and I’m not confident she would be able to do that. The IRO spoke to her about that and in a case note reported the Mother said she was having a bad day with her mental health and struggling and finding the whole process hard with Alfie not in her care”. That is just not an option for Alfie.
Mitigations not covered above
Generally the parenting assessor recorded in the second assessment:
[F231]
I have additional concerns that the family support network is limited and not demonstrating a good understanding of how to mitigate risks to Alfie in the future. My first assessment already raised concerns regarding the protectability of the Mother’s own mother, who stated in her own viability assessment that she distanced herself from Mother when she was in the relationship due to disliking the Intervenor (therefore leaving Alfie in the situation with no support). The Mother now tells me her mother is stating her rationale was due to her belief she was in a ‘love bubble’ with the Intervenor or focusing on her relationship. Neither of these rationales have been helpful for keeping Alfie safe. Moving forward I continue to hold similar concerns.
In her second assessment, although she noted there had been no Family Group Conference and the Mother believed that her support network was stronger, she worried that the Mother’s environment and lifestyle was still exposing her to drug use “despite the strong support network the Mother feels she has” [F221/12.5].
The Guardian said that there were no further services that could be provided that would enable the Mother to provide the care Alfie requires [E147/92].
What would be the consequences for the child if it did?
This is really summed up by the assistant team manager in this way:
[C238/3.4]
Alfie now requires a stable, predictable, emotionally attuned environment with consistent carers who can meet his needs every day, without delay or uncertainty. A decision upon Alfie’s permanency will assist him to establish a secure sense of safety and he will be able to begin trauma informed therapy with CAMHS, which given the recent regression, is more relevant now than ever. Any further delay will cause additional impact to Alfie, which creates a further threat of irreversible damage.
That is echoed in the most recent parenting assessment:
[F300/6.11]
In Alfie’s case, his experiences mean he will already have a much greater need for this level of stability, predictability and consistency in his care and relationships. The introduction of new adults before a relationship is fully established may create confusion regarding trust, roles and attachment, and could undermine his sense of emotional security.
A return to the care of the Mother with the deficits identified above will put him at similar risk of harm.
What other welfare considerations have to be taken into account?
I have considered this above and below.
In consequence, which of the realistic plans best promotes the child’s welfare?
I will consider this below.
If the preferred plan involves interference with the Article 8 rights of the child or of others, is that necessary and proportionate?
I will consider this below.
Relationship with relatives, prospective adopter and their wishes and feelings
Mother
In relation to the period before the Intervenor moved in with the Mother, it was put to the parenting assessor that there were no concerns about the Mother’s care of Alfie. Her response was that there was no oversight by Children’s Social Care at that time “so we don’t really know what was going on then”. I consider it a neutral piece of evidence.
In relation to the period whilst the Intervenor was living with the Mother and the serious injuries Alfie sustained the Guardian agreed the Mother was “remorseful” and “feels guilty”
I have touched upon this above in relation to the Mother but the Guardian recorded “great commitment” from Mother to Alfie and said that it was “abundantly clear [she] loves Alfie dearly” [E133/24] and that there was a “nice relationship and close bond” between Mother and Alfie [E139/52]. The assistant team manager recorded the Mother having had 1:1 support from the family time team during contact twice a week “for the last 15 months” [C237] and she is making “significant progress in her family time sessions” with “appropriate and attentive basic care skills” [C235]. The parenting assessor in the first report recorded that Alfie appeared relaxed and happy in his Mother’s care [F134/9.19]. However, in her second report she said this:
[F231/13.26]
…not only will Mother need to work to ensure the secure attachment bond with Alfie develops, but she will need to be prepared that the development trajectory for Alfie is likely to come with a lot more challenges as a result of his experiences. I worry the Mother may not have a full understanding of Alfie’s needs in this respect or why it is paramount that he is provided with predictable and stable care consistently. For example, in our conversations Mother was quick to mention friends and neighbours who Alfie will no longer have any significant relationship with as an example of support… Ad hoc carers will likely exacerbate that vulnerability and those feelings despite any good intent.
That is echoed in her most recent report:
[F301/6.14]
I remained concern [sic] that she did not fully demonstrate an appreciation of the complexity of Alfie’s therapeutic, developmental and attachment needs following the significant physical and emotional harm he experienced. On several occasions Mother described reunification as a return to normality, whereas my concern remained that Alfie’s future care needs will be considerably more complex than those that existed before the abuse occurred.
The Guardian expressed concern about the relationship that went beyond not being able to meet Alfie’s needs. She said:
[E139]
Alfie…is starting to say things that indicate he remembers some of his trauma…
52…Alfie is likely to have memories from when he lived with the Mother and Intervenor and is likely to associate- consciously or subconsciously- his mother and her home with the abuse he suffered when in her care. I believe he would struggle, emotionally, if he returned to her care”.
I think this analysis stems from her evidence that:
[E140/56]
There continue to be some concerns regarding certain comments he makes or behaviours he displays, often relating to ‘hurt’, as well as occasional moments where he freezes, which indicate that whilst physically Alfie has recovered from his injuries, psychologically he remains traumatised.
Her conclusion was:
[E140]
It is vital that Alfie is living in a safe environment, with insightful, emotionally supportive and emotionally containing caregivers, when he has this therapeutic support. In my view, this work would not be possible if Alfie were placed in his mother’s care, as she was a source of his trauma in the first place.
In her oral evidence she added a concern that Mother’s involvement in therapy may risk destabilising Alfie if the focus of work for Alfie becomes entangled (my word not hers) in her own therapeutic process.
Problematically for the Mother’s case, the Guardian reported the Mother informing her on 2 July 2026 that “the police investigation remains ongoing, with a charging decision yet to be made. She advised that her bail conditions were recently extended until October 2026, with the condition that she should not have unsupervised time with Alfie still in place” [E175/21]. An update was provided shortly before this hearing to the effect that a decision to charge has now been made and the Mother will be charged with causing or allowing a child to suffer serious physical harm and child cruelty and the bail conditions will continue including that the Mother should not have direct or indirect time with Alfie unless supervised by a person nominated by Children’s Social Care.
It is difficult to see how the Mother could care for Alfie in those circumstances and that is even before considering what might happen if she was subsequently convicted. It introduces yet more uncertainty into Alfie’s life.
Father
The Father does not have an established relationship with Alfie [C112], he has not seen Alfie since prior to proceedings being issued and has not made proactive efforts to resume contact and he “has a significant history of offending, including violent offences, use of weapons, and a recent drug-driving offence in May 2025 which remains under investigation. He was sentenced to 38 months in prison in 2023” [C253] and a long-standing history of drug misuse [C253]. He does not challenge his negative parenting assessment.
Other relatives
There have been no positive assessments of other relatives. As noted above the Mother now puts forward the Maternal Great Aunt.
Prospective adopters
Much of what I heard about the current foster carers is encapsulated in this comment from the CAMHS letter:
…as recognised by social care, you are providing the responsive, skilled, experienced and attentive care that Alfie so very much needs from his parents. When we met, you were very thoughtful about your understandable concerns around how the significant trauma and loss Alfie has experienced might impact him in the future…
…
From what we have seen it seems clear that he is receiving from within your family the therapeutic care he needs at this point…
The letter recounts Alfie going to the carers during the assessment for reassurance and showing appropriate attachment.
The parenting assessor was asked about the capacity of the foster carers to continue long term foster care instead of pursuing a plan of adoption and she said she understood they would be prepared to care in this alternative way if matched.
Likely effect of change in circumstances/throughout his life of ceasing to be member of family and becoming adopted person
The current foster carers have been approved as potential adopters, they are due to be considered at a matching panel on 25 September 2026 which post-dates the hearing but pre-dates formal handing down of this judgment. If Care and Placement Orders are made the Local Authority intend that Alfie will remain with the current foster carers who will in due course apply for an Adoption Order. Clearly this will eliminate further disruption to Alfie’s home. Under the care plan there would be a step down in contact with his Mother. In light of the report of regression and dysregulated behaviour post-contact with the Mother this may improve his sense of security but it will involve some risk of emotional harm at least in the short term and the Guardian agreed Alfie is “bound to experience a sense of loss as contact reduces”.
An Adoption Order will sever the legal links between Alfie and his Mother and Father and the wider maternal family and paternal family. This may in due course provoke an emotional or psychological response to being adopted.
I have addressed the likely effect of a return to the Mother’s care above, I place particular weight on the Guardian’s assessment of the risk of emotional harm from Alfie associating his mother’s care with abuse whilst in her care [E139]. She went on to say that “it would be detrimental to move Alfie to an alternative placement when this one [with his current foster carers and potential adopters] is meeting his needs so well” [E142/70]. In her oral evidence the assistant team manager said:
My understanding from CAMHS is that if he returned to Mother that could create instability…There is no longer a bar to treatment starting but my understanding is that the [court] decision will impact upon the response to the treatment.
My understanding of her evidence was that it would impact negatively on Alfie’s response to treatment were he to return to the Mother’s care.
Range of powers
I have previously refused an application by the Mother for a Resolutions style parenting assessment. I will not repeat my reasons for doing so but I did make clear it was open to the Mother at the conclusion of evidence at the welfare hearing to make a fresh application for an adjournment. In relation to this I can do no better than repeat the Guardian’s evidence in her addendum analysis:
[E172/12]
The findings made by the Court in respect of the Mother are so concerning and worrying that the amount of work she would need to do to change her insight and parenting capacity falls well outside of Alfie’s timescales. Furthermore, if an assessment were to take place, the recommendations that would likely stem from this would take even further time to implement.
Holistic balancing exercise
I come now to consider the balancing exercise that is required by B-S. In light of the Mother’s changed position option 1 and 2 are intertwined but I have addressed them as separate options for clarity.
Realistic Option 1: Adjournment
Factors in favour | Factors against |
Allows Mother further time to demonstrate an ability to care for Alfie | Further delay |
Allows for an assessment of the Maternal Great Aunt | Inferred impact on effectiveness of therapy |
Continued uncertainty for the future | |
Risk of placement breakdown during the adjournment | |
Continuing to be subject to an intrusive court order and a looked after child |
Realistic Option 2: Placement with Mother in the future under Supervision Order or no order
Factors in favour | Factors against |
Potentially consistent with assumed wishes of Alfie | Risk of physical harm from others in light of findings about the Mother’s failure to protect |
Cared for by Mother | Risk of emotional or physical harm from exposure to domestic abuse in light of findings |
Maintenance of relationship with birth family | Risk of emotional or physical harm from drug or alcohol misuse |
Risk of emotional or physical harm from Mother’s poor mental health | |
Risk of emotional harm of a return to the scene of physical and emotional harm | |
Police bail conditions remain in place preventing Mother from having unsupervised contact with Alfie. It is not sustainable to supervise the Mother 24 hours a day | |
Necessity for intrusive 24 hour supervision of care pending trial | |
Risk of future separation in the event the Mother is convicted and receives a custodial sentence | |
Move from current carers with whom Alfie has resided for the majority of proceedings | |
Risk that in the event of a placement breakdown with the Mother the current carers will no longer be a foster care or adoption option for Alfie | |
Risk of reduced effectiveness of CAMHS treatment for Alfie |
Realistic Option 3: Care Order with a care plan of foster care
Factors in favour | Factors against |
Safe care | Potentially contrary to assumed wishes of Alfie |
Potential for reunification with Mother | Cared for by a non-family member |
Maintenance of relationship with birth family | Risk of placement breakdown |
Intrusive nature of Care Order/being a looked after child | |
Lack of permanence | |
Care leaver at 18 | |
Risk of a placement move if the current carers are not able to pursue an adoption application although I acknowledge this risk is speculative, the evidence is they currently would agree to care under this legal regime |
Realistic Option 4: Care and Placement Orders
Factors in favour | Factors against |
Safe care | Potentially contrary to assumed wishes of Alfie |
Permanence | Cared for by a non-family member |
Likely maintenance of the current placement | Severing of legal links to birth family |
Much reduced contact with Mother and Father | |
Much reduced opportunity to understand wider family and life story | |
Risk of adoption breakdown | |
Potential for short term emotional harm associated with reducing contact with Mother |
Comparison of Options
As to an adjournment, I have previously refused the Mother’s application for the same to allow for a Resolutions style ISW assessment. The Mother says that since then Alfie has been able to start or will shortly start therapy so delay caused by granting either application (assessment of her or Maternal Great Aunt) will be less impactful. To a small extent I accept that but the effects of delay are not just related to commencing therapy: I am entitled to take judicial notice of the fact that delay in permanence means therapy is based on an uncertain future in terms of placement and may be less effective (that is consistent with the Guardian’s position in her position statement for this hearing at paragraph 7 and the hearsay evidence from CAMHS). These proceedings were issued on 30 January 2025, they are now 20 months old, and all the while Alfie has faced an uncertain future. Tellingly, the Guardian has reflected that Alfie has now lived with the current foster carers for longer than he was in the care of the Mother. Delay is unlikely to be limited to the length of time an assessment either of the Mother or Maternal Great Aunt will take. If it is successful there will be further delay in testing its recommendations. Even if successful the court will still, most likely, be faced with the uncertainties that the criminal proceedings present for the Mother’s ability to care for Alfie (in terms of 24-hour supervision by reason of bail or in the event of a conviction). Lastly, within a few months Alfie will be 4 years old; whilst his current foster carers have been assessed positively as potential adopters as time passes Alfie’s prospects of a successful adoption in another family should an application not be pursued by the current carers will diminish and this will be to his lifelong detriment.
In summary in terms of placement and treatment it would be incredibly damaging for Alfie to have to wait any longer. Allied to this, in the event there is a prospective move to the Mother’s care, the Guardian said it would be an enormously difficult transition, from the trauma informed parenting he is currently receiving it “would set up mum and Alfie to fail and would be damaging, the placement is likely to breakdown”. The Guardian could not address a move to the Maternal Great Aunt because the proposal was raised only during submissions. Nevertheless, the considerations she identified concerning delay, transition from the current trauma-informed placement and Alfie’s need for permanence are also relevant to that proposal.
Next, I consider that 14 years in foster care is likely to be incredibly damaging to Alfie. Even if his current carers are assessed to care for him long term his position in the care system would remain precarious and prone to breakdown for a considerable period and when he reaches 18 he will be a care leaver with all the disadvantages that sadly brings. When the assistant team manager gave evidence she said Alfie “doesn’t like seeing doctors, doesn’t like going to hospitals” and said he would be subject to looked after child medicals. She also said that a Care Order without Placement Order would be unsettling and cause “confusion” for Alfie. Alfie is also likely to be impacted by the carers having “hanging over them the possibility of future litigation, applications for contact or for discharge of the Care Order” and in support of that she also agreed that the Mother had previously raised concerns about their care of Alfie which she considered were not merited (dirty fingernails and toenails) and had complained he was placed in a town in which the Intervenor lived. She was asked about the effect of those complaints on the carers and said, “They were upset” and if it were to happen again she would be fearful Alfie may be moved.
The Guardian’s oral evidence was that she could not support long term foster care (or a Special Guardianship Order) in the care of the current foster carers in order to keep alive a possibility of a return to the Mother’s care:
I think Alfie’s greatest need over and above relationship with Mother is a sense of permanency and belonging and the therapy is proxy now [i.e. via the carers] but door is open for it to be direct and seeing Mother once a month could be undermining of the process and although Mother doesn’t accept she’s a trauma for Alfie, she is, she was in that household over those few months and Alfie can’t differentiate between neglectful care and physical abuse.
Many cases are finely balanced. This is not one of them. The professional evidence is well reasoned and overwhelming. This is a child who can wait no longer for a final decision. The evidence is that the Mother is, as she now accepts, not in a position to care for Alfie for now. There is no sensible alternative but for the court making Care and Placement Orders. They are necessary and proportionate to the risks of harm. An adjournment for any further assessment would bring enormous risk and possibly no benefit. A care plan of long term foster care would be positively harmful for Alfie.
Contact
The Mother is currently having twice weekly contact with Alfie. She seeks contact on a three monthly basis but confirmed in submissions she does not make an application for a post-placement contact order.
When the assistant team manager was asked about contact arrangements in the course of her oral evidence she said the foster carers had been spoken to (as potential adopters) and they were aware of the need for the identity of the Mother to be kept “open” which I understood her to mean the need for Alfie to know who his mother is in a real sense. As I understand it they are in agreement with the care plan proposal of direct annual and twice yearly indirect letter contact and “were clear they would review it but what they feel needs to happen first is for Alfie to settle and access therapy and they would review how he is and consider increasing it”.
The Guardian considered the recommendation for direct contact with the Mother. She recorded that Alfie is likely to need a level of direct contact with the Mother post-adoption although this “is likely to conflict with his more pressing need for therapy initially” [E143/74] and she quoted the current foster carers’ concern that “seeing her more regularly would be very confusing for Alfie and might undermine the benefits of therapy” [E143/76].
It seems to me this is a paradigm example of what McFarlane P described might benefit from “a more flexible statement of the road map for future contact”. I am not satisfied it is in Alfie’s welfare interest for there to be a fixed order for contact. Nor am I satisfied on the evidence that it would be right to invite the Local Authority to change their care plan. The insight of the foster carers is spot on. What Alfie needs is time to adapt to the permanency of placement and the treatment he is now receiving. No-one can really predict his response and it requires trust in the foster carers’ ability to reflect his changing with guidance from CAMHS.
In relation to the Father the submission was made that nothing had changed since a care plan filed over a year ago which proposed annual direct contact for him and that should be reflected in the approved care plan. The submission was made on instructions and I want to be clear I make no criticism of his advocate for making it but it is disingenuous from a man who has in the past year had no contact and made no effort to instigate it on the evidence before me. That is something in the order of a third of Alfie’s life. It is a material change and it justifies a different plan.
The Guardian invited the Local Authority to review the care plan and provide for annual letterbox contact with Alfie from the Father in the interests of Alfie understanding his life story. In submissions the Local Authority suggested a recital to the effect that “the Father’s ability to engage with post-adoption contact can be assessed in the post-order adoption counselling process and if the Father engages then the Local Authority will promote indirect contact of once a year”. I invited the Local Authority to consider adding that to the care plan and was told it would not be resisted. I formally do invite the Local Authority to amend the care plan in that way. It leaves open the possibility of indirect contact in a unified document for the post-adoption team. For the avoidance of any doubt, I do not consider direct contact is in Alfie’s welfare interest in the absence of any meaningful relationship with his Father.
Conclusion
In light of the above analysis I make a final Care Order pursuant to section 31 Children Act 1989 and approve the care plan. Having concluded that Alfie’s welfare requires me to dispense with the parents’ consent to placing for adoption I do so pursuant to section 52 Adoption and Children Act 2002 and make a Placement Order pursuant to section 21 of the Act.
I approve the care plan in respect of contact arrangements with the proposed amendment set out above.
Letter to Alfie
I am the judge who made decisions about where you should live and who should look after you. I wanted to write to you because the decisions I have made are very important and are all about you and your future.
When you were younger some very upsetting things happened to you. You were hurt when you were living at home, and it was not your fault. You were a little boy who needed adults to keep you safe. The adults should have protected you. From January 2025, you lived with foster carers. I have read many reports about how you are doing and I have heard from people who know you well. Everyone agrees that you have grown, learned and are happy in their care. They have helped you feel safe and loved. They understand that some of the things that happened to you when you were younger may still affect you, and they are helping you with that too.
I know that your mum loves you very much. I also know that she has kept in touch with you and that you are very important to her.
The difficult question I had to answer was whether it would be safe for you to live with your mum again, or whether another plan would be better for you as you grow up. After listening very carefully to all the evidence, I decided that it would not be safe for you to return to your mum's care and that waiting longer would not be fair to you. You had already spent a long time waiting for decisions to be made about your future.
The most important thing for me was thinking about what would help you throughout your life. I decided that you need a family who can give you permanence, stability, security and a sense of belonging as you grow up. I made orders which will allow your current carers to become your adoptive parents.
I know this decision will make your mum and other members of your family very sad. Making decisions like this is never easy. I thought very carefully about all the different possibilities before reaching my decision.
As you grow up, you may have questions about why these decisions were made. I hope it helps you to know that every person involved in your case was trying to work out what would be best for you. My job was to make the decision that I believed would give you the safest, happiest and most secure future.
I hope that, as you grow older, you continue to feel safe, loved and proud of the brave little boy you have been. I also hope that the people caring for you help you understand your story and the people who have been important in your life.
I wish you every happiness for the future.
Yours sincerely,
His Honour Judge Richard Case