R v Bilal Alfroh

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1415

View download options

R v Bilal Alfroh

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1415

WARNING: reporting restrictions may apply to the contents transcribed in this document, particularly if the case concerned a sexual offence or involved a child. Reporting restrictions prohibit the publication of the applicable information to the public or any section of the public, in writing, in a broadcast or by means of the internet, including social media. Anyone who receives a copy of this transcript is responsible in law for making sure that applicable restrictions are not breached. A person who breaches a reporting restriction is liable to a fine and/or imprisonment. For guidance on whether reporting restrictions apply, and to what information, ask at the court office or take legal advice.

This Transcript is Crown Copyright. It may not be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence or with the express consent of the Authority. All rights are reserved.

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWCA Crim 1415

CASE NO 202601593 B3

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL (CRIMINAL DIVISION)

ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT MANCHESTER MINSHULL STREET (HER HONOUR JUDGE WOODWARD) [06AI0227625]

Royal Courts of Justice

The Strand, London, WC2A 2LL

Wednesday 21 October 2026

Before:

THE VICE PRESIDENT OF THE COURT OF APPEAL CRIMINAL DIVISION

(Lord Justice Edis)

LORD JUSTICE FOXTON

and

MR JUSTICE SWIFT

____________________

REX

- v -

BILAL ALFROH

____________________

Computer Aided Transcription of Epiq Europe Ltd,

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)

____________________

Miss S Bailey appeared on behalf of the Applicant

Mr A Lodge appeared on behalf of the Crown

____________________

J U D G M E N T

Approved

Wednesday 21 October 2026

The provisions of the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992 apply to these offences. Under those provisions, where an allegation has been made that a sexual offence has been committed against a person, no matter relating to that person shall during that person’s lifetime be included in any publication if it is likely to lead members of the public to identify that person as the victim of the offence. This prohibition applies unless waived or lifted in accordance with section 3 of the Act.

LORD JUSTICE EDIS: I shall ask Lord Justice Foxton to give the judgment of the court.

LORD JUSTICE FOXTON:

1.

The provisions of the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992 apply to these offences. Under those provisions, where an allegation has been made that a sexual offence has been committed against a person, no matter relating to that person shall during that person’s lifetime be included in any publication if it is likely to lead members of the public to identify that person as the victim of the offence. This prohibition applies unless waived or lifted in accordance with section 3 of the Act.

2.

On 2 April 2026, following a trial in the Crown Court at Minshull Street, Manchester before Her Honour Judge Woodward and a jury, the applicant was convicted of one count of controlling or coercive behaviour (count 1), three counts of rape (counts 2, 3 and 5) and one count of assault occasioning actual bodily harm (count 10). He was acquitted of a further count of rape; and the jury were discharged from reaching a verdict in respect of a further four counts of rape.

3.

The applicant’s application for leave to appeal against conviction has been referred to the full court by the Registrar.

4.

We can briefly set out the factual allegations raised by the prosecution, because the focus of the application for leave is the events at the trial, and in particular the fact that the jury did not have access to their documents for a short period during which it is said that they were or may have been deliberating after receiving a majority direction.

5.

The prosecution arose from a report made to the police after the complainant had sought the assistance of a domestic abuse charity. The complainant said that the applicant had been violent, controlling and verbally abusive and had raped her on a number of occasions. Those allegations were reflected in the various counts before the court. Count 1, which resulted in a conviction, was the offence of controlling or coercive behaviour. Counts 2, 3 and 5, of which the applicant was also convicted, were offences of vaginal rape, the first and third of which involved specific incidents, and the second of which was a multi-incident count. Count 10, of which he was also convicted, was an offence of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.

6.

The applicant was acquitted of the vaginal rape offence which formed the basis of count 4. The jury were unable to reach verdicts on other counts.

7.

At trial the prosecution relied upon photographic and video evidence, messages exchanged by the complainant with two third parties, a medical examination, and a prior conviction of the applicant for battery.

8.

The applicant gave evidence at trial. He admitted causing some of the injuries sustained by the complainant, but denied the majority of the allegations of violence. He said that all sex activity with the complainant had been consensual.

9.

The jury retired to begin their deliberations at the end of the judge’s summing up at 11.45 am on 1 April 2026. They took with them back to the deliberation room a copy of the indictment, the jury bundle, the judge’s written legal directions, the judge’s Route to Verdict, and such notes as they may individually have taken during the course of the trial.

10.

Towards the end of that day the jury sent two written questions to the judge. The judge said that she would answer them the following morning.

11.

The judge provided answers to those questions when the jury returned to court at the start of the court day on 2 April. The jury then retired to resume their deliberations at 10.26 am.

12.

After the jury had been deliberating for seven hours and 12 minutes, the judge and counsel discussed whether it would be appropriate to give a majority direction. Both counsel supported that course.

13.

At 1.45 pm the jury bailiff asked the jury, “Have you reached verdicts on all counts upon which you are all agreed?”, and received an affirmative answer to that question. The jury bailiff informed the jury that because the judge was occupied with other matters, they could not be brought back to court before 2.15pm.

14.

At or around this time the jury papers – or at least some of them – were removed from the deliberation room, apparently because it had been understood from the response to the jury bailiff’s question that verdicts had been reached on all counts and the process of deliberation had come to an end.

15.

However, as the jury were being brought to court it became apparent that they might not have reached unanimous verdicts on all counts, and that there was some confusion as to the position.

16.

When the jury were brought back into court, they were asked: “Have your reached a verdict on all counts on which you are all agreed?”. The Foreperson answered “Yes” to that question. However, given the earlier concerns, the judge sensibly clarified the position through the following exchange with the Foreperson:

“THE JUDGE: I am just checking. I have no reason to believe that you did not understand the question, but have you reached verdicts on all ten counts on which you are all agreed – a unanimous verdict on all ten?

THE FOREPERSON: They are unanimous, your Honour.

THE JUDGE: All right. I am going to ask the question again.

THE CLERK: Members of the jury, have you reached a verdict on all counts on which you are all agreed?”

At that point the Foreperson said “No”.

17.

The judge then gave the jury the majority direction at about 2.30 pm, and the jury retired to continue their deliberations.

18.

Very shortly thereafter, the jury sent a further note to the judge (“the Note”), which the judge received by email at about 2.41 pm. The judge informed counsel later that the contents of the Note had led her to decide to take partial verdicts from the jury.

19.

The judge was engaged in sentencing in another matter when the Note came in, and it was not possible to bring the jury back into court until 3.25 pm. At that point the jury returned unanimous guilty verdicts on counts 1, 2, 3, 5 and 10, a unanimous not guilty verdict on count 4, and stated that they had been unable to reach verdicts, whether unanimous or majority, on counts 6 – 9.

20.

The judge asked the jury to continue their deliberations on those counts, but a further note was then handed to the judge. It stated, “Our notes have been removed from our room and thrown in the bin”. When the judge read this note, she asked the jury to suspend their deliberations and wait in a secure area outside the court while she discussed the matter with counsel.

21.

The judge decided that it was appropriate to make an inquiry as to the position at the point in time after the jury had been asked to resume their deliberations with a view to reaching majority verdicts. With counsel’s approval, each juror was individually asked the following question in writing:

“Did the absence of any of your documents after you returned to the jury room at 14.30 have any impact on your deliberations or how you returned your verdicts after the note you sent at 14.41?”

22.

With the benefit of hindsight, it is unfortunate that that question did not clearly distinguish between any impact on the verdicts, and any impact on the ongoing deliberations. The form of the question may well have reflected the understanding the judge had derived from the Note. In the event, nine jurors answered that question in the negative, but three gave positive answers.

23.

After discussions with counsel, the judge discharged the jury so far as counts 6 – 9 were concerned. The Crown later said that it would not seek to re-try the applicant on those counts.

The Submissions

24.

Miss Bailey, who appears for the applicant before us this morning, as she did at trial, argued that the fact the jury had deliberated – or may have done – for a period of time without access to their papers constituted a material irregularity and one which rendered the convictions unsafe.

25.

In her written submissions, Miss Bailey said that it was not simply a case of the jury being without access to their papers for a ten minute period after the majority direction was given. She pointed to the fact that the jury did not return to court until 3.25 pm to deliver their verdicts. She understandably relied on the affirmative response of a number of jurors to the judge’s written question and suggested that the fact that it was apparent in open court that some jurors had given a positive answer to the judge’s question gave rise to a real risk that the convictions might be perceived by the public as wrongful.

26.

Mr Lodge, who appears for the Crown, accepts that the case involves unusual circumstances but submits that there is no basis for suggesting that the convictions are unsafe. He points to the lengthy period during which the jury were in retirement with access to their papers following which they arrived at unanimous verdicts. He submitted that the question the jury were asked by the judge was so laden with ambiguity that a positive response was all but meaningless.

27.

The Registrar directed that the parties file additional submissions addressing the question of whether the court should order an investigation by the Criminal Cases Review Commission. Neither counsel positively sought such an order; both accepted that the issue raised could be dealt with by this court as a matter of law.

Conclusion

28.

We accept that the jury ought to have had access to their papers at all time while deliberations were continuing, and that it is very unfortunate that the papers were removed from their room. Unless and until verdicts had been taken on all counts in court, that was not a wise or appropriate course.

29.

However, the issue remains as to whether those events render the convictions in any way unsafe. First, we should say that we are satisfied that the court is able safely and fairly to determine that issue on this application. There is no necessity to refer the matter to the Criminal Cases Review Commission for further investigation.

30.

We are completely satisfied that the events relating to the jury papers do not in any way undermine the safety of these convictions. It is clear that the jury had already reached unanimous verdicts on those counts which were the subject of convictions before they were brought back into court at 1.45 pm, both because that is what they told the jury bailiff and because the Foreperson said as much in court. The confusion arose from the fact that the jury had not, as initially suggested, reached unanimous verdicts on all counts.

31.

By the time that the jury were brought back into court, deliberations had continued for eight hours and 20 minutes, and for the vast majority of that period the jury had had access to all their papers. It was only for a very short period (ten minutes) before returning to their room after the majority verdict direction and the sending of the Note received by the judge at 2.41 pm that the jury did not have access to their papers. That Note led the judge to take partial verdicts and the obvious inference from the events which followed is that the Note indicated that the jury were able to, and would, deliver unanimous verdicts on a number of counts, and identified those counts on which the jury were unable to agree.

32.

Unlike counsel in the course of their preparations for the appeal, we have seen the Note and we are able to confirm that that obvious inference is indeed the correct one. The Note confirmed that the jury were in a position to give unanimous verdicts on all counts, except counts 6 – 9. So far as counts 6 – 9 were concerned, the Note indicated that the issues had been thoroughly explored and no one was likely to change their mind.

33.

Again with the benefit of hindsight, we think that the judge could have said more about the contents of the Note when the issue arose as to the removal of the jurors’ papers and in particular confirmed that the Note showed that the unanimous verdicts delivered in court had already been reached by the jury when the Note was sent to the judge at 2.41 pm.

34.

In our view, it is not credible that the verdicts of a jury whose deliberations have continued for such a lengthy period with access to their paper, to the point that they had reached unanimous verdicts on six counts, could be rendered unsafe by the fact that they did not have access to their papers during the ten minute period it took to communicate their position to the court. Nor is it credible that deliberation on the counts on which they had reached unanimous verdicts by 2.41 pm might have continued during the period it took to bring the jury back to court at 3.25pm. Indeed, it is striking that the jury raised no issues in relation to access to their papers when giving their unanimous verdicts, but only when asked to continue deliberations on counts 6 – 9.

35.

Against a background in which deliberations on counts 6 – 9 were continuing, it is perhaps not particularly surprising that some jurors answered “Yes” to the compendious question of whether the absence of their papers had impacted their deliberations or verdicts. But those answers cannot sensibly be understood as statements that the verdicts which had been reached on a unanimous basis were impacted by the absence of the jury’s papers after they returned to their jury room. A fair-minded and informed observer who had regard to all the known facts would have no concerns as to the safety of the convictions.

36.

For those reasons, and notwithstanding, Miss Bailey’s submissions which were commendable for their realism, we refuse the application for leave to appeal against conviction.

__________________________________

Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400

Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk

______________________________

Document download options

Download PDF (97.8 KB)

The original format of the judgment as handed down by the court, for printing and downloading.

Download XML

The judgment in machine-readable LegalDocML format for developers, data scientists and researchers.