R v Letitia Sandys & Anor

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1404

View download options

R v Letitia Sandys & Anor

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1404

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
CRIMINAL DIVISION

ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT MANCHESTER

(HER HONOUR JUDGE BAXTER)[06MM0227225/06MM0141825]

CASE NO 202602632/A5-202602901/A5

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWCA Crim 1404

Royal Courts of Justice

Strand

London

WC2A 2LL

Friday 18 September 2026

Before:

LORD JUSTICE SINGH

MR JUSTICE CHOUDHURY

MRS JUSTICE STACEY

REX

V

LETITIA SANDYS

NICHOLAS GRIFFIN

__________

Computer Aided Transcript of Epiq Europe Ltd,

Lower Ground, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)

_________

MR R ALI appeared on behalf of the Appellant Sandys

MR S BRODY appeared on behalf of the Appellant Griffin

_________

JUDGMENT

(Approved)

MR JUSTICE CHOUDHURY:

1.

On 20 January 2026 in the Crown Court at Minshull St Manchester before HHJ Baxter, Letitia Sandys (then aged 31), pleaded guilty to count 3 on the indictment which was for participation in the activities of an organised crime group contrary to section 45(1) of the Serious Crime Act 2015 (the "Act"). On 6 July 2026, before the same judge, Sandys was sentenced to 27 months' imprisonment.

2.

On 4 February 2026 also before the same judge, the second appellant, Nicholas Griffin (then aged 39), was convicted following trial of count 1, that being conspiracy to supply a controlled drug of Class A, namely cocaine. He had earlier pleaded guilty to count 2 which was conspiracy to supply Class B drugs, namely cannabis. On 6 July 2026, Griffin was sentenced to 6 years 6 months on count 1 (cocaine) and 4 years 6 months on count 2 (cannabis) to run concurrently. We shall refer to all participants by their surnames, but we mean no disrespect by doing so.

3.

Both Sandys and Griffin appeal against sentence with the leave of the Single Judge.

Factual background

4.

Griffin was involved in conspiracies to supply cocaine and cannabis along with Germane Tarrant and Calvin Cousins. The conspiracy ran from 25 August 2024 to 3 July 2025 although Griffin's involvement in the conspiracy did not begin until April 2025. These conspiracies were conducted in the Sale and Altrincham area of Manchester. Sandys was the partner of Tarrant, the leader of the organised crime group running this conspiracy. Tarrant oversaw the day-to-day running of the drug's operation, sourcing the drugs, dividing them for resale, and organising the dealers employed by him, namely Cousins and subsequently Griffin.

5.

Tarrant arranged stash houses at Rosebury St in Moss Side, Abbey Road in Sale and Liverpool Road in Cadishead. He also organised the vehicles used by himself and the dealers, regularly swapping them around to evade the attention of the police. Tarrant manned the drugs line, took orders, and provided customer locations to his dealers. He often used the radio to communicate with Cousins and Griffin to reduce the risk of detection.

6.

Cousins was a trusted friend of Tarrant. He operated as a runner and street dealer from the start of the conspiracy until his arrest on 28 April 2025.

7.

Cousins collected drugs from the various stash houses. He and Tarrant would then travel from their respective homes in Salford and Stockport to deal with drugs in Sale.

8.

Griffin was Tarrant's personal trainer. He began working as a drug runner for Tarrant from 15 April 2025 and was involved in the conspiracy until his arrest on 2 July 2025. Griffin collected the drugs directly from Tarrant and would meet Tarrant at the end of the day to give him the money obtained by selling the drugs and return any unsold drugs. Griffin would be directed to various post codes by Tarrant and was earning up to £600 per week doing this work.

9.

Sandys assisted Tarrant. She accompanied him in the car whilst he was dealing to customers to make him less noticeable to police. She allowed her property at Rosebury Street to be used as a stash house, and she helped Tarrant dispose of drugs and paraphernalia at the Liverpool Road stash house. On some occasions Sandys would meet the runners to top them up with drugs if they ran out, or to collect drugs and money at the end of the day.

10.

Stacy Dulieu was a customer of Tarrant's. She allowed him to use her home in Sale as a stash house in exchange for drugs. Dulieu's involvement was from March 2025 until Cousins’ arrest at the end of April 2025.

11.

On 28 April 2025 Cousins collected a bag from Dulieu's house which contained 50 wraps of cannabis weighing 161 grammes and worth £1500, and 22 wraps of cocaine weighing just under 10 grammes and worth £880. Police officers searched Dulieu's home and found 100 wraps of cannabis weighing 324 grammes worth £3,000 and 112 wraps of cocaine weighing 51.6 grammes and worth £4,480.

12.

The drugs conspiracies came to light after Cousins was stopped in a black Mercedes motor vehicle in Sale on 26 August 2024. He was found with 58 snap bags of cannabis, £1,740 in cash, and two mobile telephones. The police then began a surveillance operation which brought the conspiracies to light.

13.

On 2 July 2025 police conducted a "strike" at the stash house in Liverpool Road. Inside the property they found 120 wraps of cannabis weighing 390 grammes worth £3,600 and 74.4 grammes of cocaine worth £4,360. Griffin had on him 35 snap bags of cannabis in a rucksack that he was using to deal from.

14.

All were arrested and interviewed that day. Sandys gave a "no comment" interview to police. Griffin provided a full account denying any involvement in the supply of cocaine but admitting his involvement in the conspiracy to supply cannabis.

15.

Telephone analysis of the messages exchanged between the conspirators showed that 3.3 kilogrammes of cocaine and 53.3 kilogrammes of cannabis were supplied over the duration of the conspiracy.

Sentences

16.

The participants in the conspiracy were all sentenced together by the judge on the date mentioned.

17.

In clear and concise sentencing remarks, the judge noted that she had considered the Guidelines for the supply of drugs offences and that because of the quantities of drugs involved found that if this had been a substantive offence of possession with intent to supply it would fall within category 2 of those Guidelines. The judge considered Tarrant's position first. She found him to have a leading role in the conspiracy, it being his business. It was found that Tarrant had substantial links to and influence over others in the chain and that he was in it for substantial financial gain. A category 2 leading role offence gives rise to a starting point of 11 years with a range of 9 to 13 years after trial.

18.

As for Cousins, the judge found that he was in a significant role in that he had an operational function in supplying the drugs for Tarrant, a clear awareness of the scale of the operation and that he was also in it for significant financial gain. A category 2 significant role offence gives rise to a starting point of 8 years and a range of between 6½ to 10 years.

19.

The judge then considered Griffin. She found that he was also in a significant role, that he had an operational function in supplying drugs for Tarrant and in accounting for the drugs and money at the conclusion of the day, that he had a clear awareness of the scale of the operation and that he too did it for significant financial gain. The judge noted however that he was involved for a relatively short period, just over 2 months, and was less trusted than Cousins. Notwithstanding that, the judge considered that the starting point in his case was also 8 years with a range of 6½ to 10 years. The judge then noted that there were aggravating features which warranted an upwards adjustment from the starting point for each of the defendants namely the fact that this is a conspiracy and more than one drug was being supplied. Also, in the case of Tarrant and Cousins there were relevant previous convictions. The judge reminded herself of the principles of totality and the need to ensure that any sentence passed was just and proportionate and properly reflected the overall criminality involved. Taking account of Tarrant's late guilty plea, which warranted 10% credit, the judge imposed a sentence of 9 years and 10 months for Tarrant on count 1 and 6 years concurrent on count 2. That sentence was not reduced further on account of totality. As for Cousins, the judge considered that the aggravating and mitigating features in his case were such that the notional sentence before any reduction for plea would remain at 8 years. He too was entitled to 10 per cent credit for plea which reduced his sentence to 7 years 2 months and 4½ years concurrent on the cannabis count.

20.

The judge then considered Griffin. She noted that there were fewer aggravating features in his case and that he was involved for a much shorter period than both Tarrant and Cousins. She also found that Griffin was clearly new to the world of drugs unlike Tarrant and Cousins. It is noteworthy that whilst there were some minor convictions in Griffin's case, these dated back to when he was a juvenile and there had been a period of 20 years or so offence-free. The judge then weighed in the balance Griffin's personal mitigation, which was his age, his family circumstances, particularly his children, who were still very young, the fact that this was his first custodial sentence, his Military Service and the impact that this had had upon his mental health, his genuine insight and remorse and everything else that the judge had heard and read about him. Taking account of all those matters the judge made a downwards adjustment from the starting point to 6½ years. As Griffin was convicted after trial there was no discount for plea. He was sentenced to 4½ years concurrent for the cannabis.

21.

The judge then turned her attention to Sandys and Dulieu. The judge had noted that there were no Sentencing Council Guidelines for the offence to which they had pleaded guilty, the maximum sentence for which is 5 years. The judge noted case law from the Court of Appeal, which makes it clear that such offences are serious and that the sentence must focus on punishment, deterrence and public protection. Although not mentioned in the sentencing remarks expressly, the case referred to is R v Crimes [2019] EWCA Crim 1108. The judge said that both individuals were important to the running of the drugs operation in different ways, and they both knew the scale of the operation, participating in it for financial gain.

22.

The judge then said expressly as follows:

"Punishment and deterrence are important parts of this sentence for you two so that people like you with no previous convictions and young children are not tempted to take the risk that you took to get involved with serious criminals for money thinking that your lack of convictions and family circumstances will save you from custody. This is not so and you and other members of the public must understand that."

23.

In Sandys' case the judge found that she played a very important role for this organised crime group throughout the conspiracy and that she had sought to minimise her involvement to the probation officer and to the court until the day of sentence. However, the judge weighed in the balance her mitigation, which included her previous good character - she had no previous convictions- the fact that she was a mother to five young children and all that the judge had heard and read about her. The judge concluded that the appropriate sentence in her case would have been 2½ years after trial. She gave Sandys 10 per cent credit for her plea thereby reducing the sentence to 27 months. The judge considered whether the sentence could be reduced further having regard in particular to the impact that a custodial sentence would have on her children but decided that in the circumstances of the case the offending was so serious that only immediate custody would suffice. The judge said that the message must go out to Sandys and others like her that if they get themselves involved in this type of criminality they will go to prison.

24.

As for Dulieu, the judge noted that as a long-term drug user she became involved with Tarrant and Cousins as a customer, that her part in the criminality was short lived and that her reward for her participation was free or discounted drugs. The judge took account of mitigation in her case which included her age, her previous good character, her family circumstances, in particular her children, and her history of addiction and poor mental health. Taking all of that into account the judge found that the appropriate sentence in her case was 21 months imprisonment. Whilst she was entitled to credit for plea as well the judge, instead of reducing the sentence further, decided that it was appropriate to suspend her sentence. In doing so the judge had regard to the fact that Dulieu had been trying to get to grips with her addiction and also had regard to her much lesser role in the conspiracy. Accordingly, her sentence was suspended for a period of 2 years.

Grounds of appeal

25.

We deal first with the grounds relied upon by Sandys. Mr Ali, who appears for Sandys as he did below, submits that insufficient account was taken by the judge of the fact that Sandys would not have been involved in this conspiracy had it not been for the fact that she was in a relationship with Tarrant. There was insufficient account of the fact that she was a person of good character, that hers was a lesser role in the conspiracy, and that she was the mother of five young children whose lives would be irrevocably affected by her incarceration. In the circumstances, Mr Ali submits that the judge failed to take account of the fact that a custodial sentence in Sandys' case would mean that the children would lose both parents thereby causing exceptional hardship, and the judge erred in considering that an immediate custodial sentence was the only reasonable option open to her. In oral submissions this morning Mr Ali also contended that the sentence of 30 months before reduction for plea was manifestly excessive as it failed to take into account of the lower maximum sentence for the offence to which she pleaded guilty.

26.

In Griffin's case, Mr Brody, who also appeared below, submits that the judge adopted too high an overall starting point, Griffin's involvement being more akin to category 3 conspiracy having regard to the late stage at which he became involved, and the quantity of drugs he supplied from that point. He further submits that Griffin ought to have been identified as having performed a lesser role being somebody who merely delivered drugs for a daily rate acting under the direction of Tarrant. Finally, it is said that the judge failed to afford the defendant a sufficient reduction to reflect matters of personal mitigation which were very substantial in this case and included the fact of Griffin's

Military Service which had resulted in mental health issues.

Decision

SANDYS

27.

As the judge noted, there is no Definitive Guideline for the offence of participating in the activities of an organised crime group contrary to section 45 of the 2015 Act. In those circumstances, judges are required to take account of the statutory maximum sentence for the offence (in this case 5 years), relevant decisions of the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) and Definitive Sentencing Guidelines for analogous offences. The judge was, as we have said, referred to the case of R v Crimes, in which acts comprising theft of motor vehicles and setting fire to a vehicle in an attempt to evade detection of crime were both activities charged under section 45 of the 2015 Act. Given the nature of those activities the Court was referred to the Guidelines for theft and for perverting the course of justice as being analogous. The Court in R v Crimes considered those to be only of very limited assistance but did remark that a sentence of 30 months imposed in respect of the theft of vehicles was "high in the range" that was open to the judge, and that the sentence of 4 years or 48 months imposed for setting fire to a vehicle was "somewhat too long".

28.

We note that the particular activities that formed the basis of the charge against Sandys included travelling with Tarrant when he was dealing to make his activities less noticeable to the police, allowing him to use her property as a stash house and assisting him to dispose of drugs and paraphernalia as well as topping up runners with drugs and collecting money. It is noticeable that were it not for the connection with organised criminal activity, one or two of these activities would not constitute a crime at all. This contrasts with the activities in the Crimes case which were inherently criminal irrespective of the connection with organised crime.

29.

No Guidelines for analogous offences were relied upon by Mr Ali. We have however considered the Guidelines for permitting premises to be used, an offence under section 8 of the Misuse of Drugs act 1971, which, whilst not strictly analogous, does bear some relation to one of the activities in which Sandys was involved, namely allowing her property to be used as a stash house. That offence has a maximum where Class A drugs are involved of 14 years custody. A category A1 offence under those Guidelines, i.e. high harm and high culpability, has a starting point of two years six months and a category range of 18 months to four years custody. Lesser harm or lesser culpability gives rise to a starting point of 36 weeks' custody and category range of high-level community order to 18 months' custody.

30.

The notional sentence before credit for plea in Sandys' case was one of 30 months. However, that figure was the one reached after taking account of the aggravating and mitigating features. Given the extensive mitigation in this case, that would suggest that the judge took a starting point somewhere in the region of 3 years or more. Taking account of the decision in Crimes and the Guideline considered above, which we acknowledge can be only of limited assistance, it is clear to us that a starting point at that level is too high and therefore manifestly excessive. In our judgment, the appropriate starting point, having regard to the maximum for the offence and the other factors set out above, would be no more than 30 months. Weighing mitigation into the balance reduces that to 24 months and credit for plea (10 per cent) reduces that further to 21 months, thus making the sentence eligible for suspension.

31.

We have considered the Guidelines on the Imposition of Community and Custodial sentences and in particular the factors that need to be considered in determining whether it is possible to suspend a sentence. As set out in the pre-sentence report in this case, there is a realistic prospect of rehabilitation in the community, Sandys presents a low risk of reoffending, and there is strong personal mitigation including her good character and the fact that she is a mother to five young children. Perhaps more significantly in this case, immediate (or continued) custody would result in significant harmful impact upon those children. Such harm is particularly acute in this case because the children are not only dependent but very young, ranging in age between 2 and 13 at the time of sentence; and moreover, one of those children has significant learning disabilities which require additional care. It is also relevant to note that Tarrant is the father of the children, and his incarceration means that the children would, if Sandys' imprisonment continued, be deprived of both parents. It seems to us that insufficient account was taken of this important factor by the judge. Whilst it is of course important to ensure that such offences are properly punished, there can be no blanket rule that a custodial sentence must always be imposed irrespective of the particular circumstances of the case.

32.

In addition, there is nothing to suggest that Sandys presents a risk to any other person and nor is there any history of non-compliance with court orders. In fact, the only factor indicating that it may not be appropriate to suspend is the seriousness of the offence. Whilst the judge was of the view that the offending in this case was so serious that only an immediate custodial sentence would suffice, we note that the same approach was not taken in Dulieu's case. In our judgment, Sandys’ offending, whilst serious enough to cross the custody threshold, was not so serious that appropriate punishment could only be achieved by immediate custody.

33.

Accordingly, we allow the appeal in Sandys’ case. We quash the sentence of 27 months and replace it with a sentence of 21 months suspended for a period of 2 years. We impose no further requirements given the fact that Sandys has already served a substantial period of time in custody.

GRIFFIN

34.

In Griffin's case, there are clear Guidelines. We do not accept Mr Brody's argument that Griffin's role in the conspiracy was such that it ought to be categorised as "lesser". In our view, the judge, who had overseen Griffin's trial, and was therefore very familiar with the facts, was entitled to find that both Cousins and Griffin had a significant role in the conspiracy. This gives rise to a starting point of 8 years.

35.

However, we agree with Mr Brody that insufficient account was taken of the difference between Cousins and Griffin's roles, both in terms of the relevant length of their involvement in the conspiracy and the level of trust that each enjoyed from Tarrant within the organised criminal group. That difference warranted a significant downwards adjustment from the starting point in Griffin's case even before any further adjustment for aggravating and mitigating factors. The failure to make such an adjustment renders the sentence in Griffin's case manifestly excessive in our view. In our judgment, the downwards adjustment would place Griffin towards the lower end of the range for a category two offence at 6 years 6 months. Thereafter, as the judge noted, there are fewer aggravating features in his case and substantial personal mitigation as we have identified above. We consider that a further downwards adjustment of 1½ years is warranted on account of those factors. That results in a final sentence of 5 years.

36.

Accordingly, we allow Griffin’s appeal, quash the sentence of 6½ years in his case and replace it with one of 5 years' imprisonment.

Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London, WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400 Email: Rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk

Document download options

Download PDF (133.9 KB)

The original format of the judgment as handed down by the court, for printing and downloading.

Download XML

The judgment in machine-readable LegalDocML format for developers, data scientists and researchers.