WARNING: reporting restrictions may apply to the contents transcribed in this document, particularly if the case concerned a sexual offence or involved a child. Reporting restrictions prohibit the publication of the applicable information to the public or any section of the public, in writing, in a broadcast or by means of the internet, including social media. Anyone who receives a copy of this transcript is responsible in law for making sure that applicable restrictions are not breached. A person who breaches a reporting restriction is liable to a fine and/or imprisonment. For guidance on whether reporting restrictions apply, and to what information, ask at the court office or take legal advice.
This Transcript is Crown Copyright. It may not be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence or with the express consent of the Authority. All rights are reserved.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL CRIMINAL DIVISION ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT MANCHESTER (MR RECORDER MICHAEL BLAKEY)(06PP0371922) CASE NO 202602886/A1-202602922/A1 Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWCA Crim 1337 |
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand
London
WC2A 2LL
Before:
LADY JUSTICE MAY
MRS JUSTICE O’FARRELL
MS JUSTICE NORTON
REX
V
MOHAMMED QURESHI
ZARYAB ALI
_________
Computer Aided Transcript of Epiq Europe Ltd,
Lower Ground, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE
Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)
________
MR D JAMES appeared on behalf of the Applicant Quereshi
MR M FRIEND appeared on behalf of the Applicant Ali
MR D CALDER appeared on behalf of the Crown
_________
APPROVED JUDGMENT
MS JUSTICE NORTON:
On 16 December 2025 in the Crown Court at (Minshull Street) Manchester, at a plea and trial preparation hearing, Mohammed Qureshi pleaded not guilty to two counts of possessing a controlled drug of Class A with intent, namely diamorphine and cocaine. Zaryab Ali was not arraigned following an indication that he was considering making an application to stay the indictment as an abuse of process. On 30 January 2026, at a further case management hearing, Mohammed Qureshi was re-arraigned and pleaded guilty to two counts of possessing a controlled drug of Class A with intent, Zaryab Ali was arraigned and pleaded guilty to one count of possession with intent to supply a controlled drug of Class A (cocaine) and one count of being concerned in the supply of Class A drug, namely diamorphine.
On 20 July 2026 both defendants were sentenced to concurrent sentences of 30 months' imprisonment for each offence to which they had pleaded guilty. The applicants apply for leave to appeal against sentence, their applications having been referred to the Full Court by the Registrar.
The facts
On 4 September 2022 at around 1.30 pm a police officer was on patrol in the Rochdale area. His attention was drawn to a silver Volkswagen Golf which had two Asian male occupants. He pursued the vehicle and activated his car's emergency equipment but the driver failed to stop. A lengthy high speed pursuit followed during which the Golf was driven in a dangerous fashion resulting in the officer losing sight of the vehicle.
Shortly afterwards the Golf was seen parked on Hillside Walk. The police were informed that the occupants had transferred to a white Volkswagen Golf. This was registered to and driven by a co-defendant, Abdul Khan. Half-an-hour later the white Golf was apprehended by police officers on Rivington Street. Khan was in the driver's seat, the applicant Qureshi was in the front passenger seat and the applicant Ali was in the rear passenger seat.
A Nike bag belonging to Ali was seized from beneath the driver's seat. This contained a vacuum bag containing 124 grams of cocaine at 83 per cent purity and worth £12,400 together with £903.50 in cash. Qureshi was wearing a Nike side bag found to contain three white plastic packages containing 84 wraps of crack cocaine weighing 5.46 grams and 30 wraps of diamorphine weighing 3.8 grams. Various mobile phones were seized. Messages on Ali's phone showed involvement in the street supply of diamorphine. Cash totalling £245 was seized from the centre console of the car. All three males were arrested and interviewed. Both applicants answered "no comment" to all questions asked.
Both applicants were then released under investigation.
Antecedents and chronology
Mohammed Qureshi was born on 24 July 2000. At the date of the offences he was aged 22 and had one previous conviction for possession of a Class A drug (cocaine) for which he was fined £250 on 15 June 2022. He was subject to bail for an offence of dangerous driving dating back to 11 February 2021. He pleaded guilty to that offence on 15 September 2022 and was made the subject of a suspended sentence order of 9 months' imprisonment suspended for 18 months. He failed to comply with the terms of the order which was subsequently activated in part (7 months) on 27 April 2023. On 26 May 2023 he was sentenced to a concurrent term of 8 weeks' imprisonment for driving whilst disqualified on 1 January 2023.
Zaryab Ali was born on 16 November 2003. At the date of the offences he was aged 18 and was of good character. On 3 February 2025 he was sentenced to a total term of imprisonment for 5 years and 10 months for offences of harassment, possession with intent to supply cocaine and crack cocaine on 13 December 2022 and conspiracy to supply cocaine in December 2023. It would appear that the sentencing judge on that occasion in February 2025 was unaware that there were outstanding allegations of a similar nature. The applicant was still serving the February 2025 sentence when he was sentenced for the offences subject of this appeal in July 2026, although we have been told that due to the amount of time he had spent on remand he was towards the end of the February 2025 sentence.
Delay
The applicants were eventually charged by way of postal requisition on 25 September 2025, over 3 years after they had been arrested and released under investigation. In the intervening period, as we have set out, Qureshi had served and been released from a sentence of 7 months' imprisonment. Ali had committed further offences of a similar nature and had been sentenced to, and was still serving, a term of imprisonment in respect of them. No explanation was or has been provided for the length of time it took to charge the applicants, or why, in respect of Ali, these offences were not drawn to the attention of the judge who sentenced him for drug offences in February 2025.
In their note provided for the assistance of this Court, the respondent concedes that there was no good reason for the delay in this case which was unreasonable. The delay, the effects of delay and the impact of that delay on sentence was central to both mitigation in the court below and in argument before us.
Sentence
Sentencing Guidelines applied for these offences each of which the judge found fell into category 3. He found that both applicants had a significant role. The starting point for category 3 significant role is 4½ years. The judge made a reduction of 25 per cent to reflect the guilty pleas entered at or shortly after the PTPH to reach a sentence rounded up in the applicant's favour of 40 months. The judge then made a further reduction of 10 months to reflect the personal mitigation and what he described as the "significant delay" to reach a sentence for each defendant of 30 months' imprisonment. We observe at this point that any reduction in sentence to reflect mitigating factors including delay should have been made before the reduction to reflect the guilty pleas. Had he done so, the final sentence would have been 33 months not 30 months.
Submissions on appeal
It is accepted on behalf of both applicants that the judge correctly categorised the offending as category 3 significant role. It is further accepted that the judge made the appropriate reduction for the applicant's guilty pleas and that he was alive to the issue of delay and made further significant reduction to the sentences to reflect that issue as well as other mitigation. However, on behalf of Qureshi it is submitted that his sentence should have been reduced still further to reflect (a) the time that he had spent in custody for an offence that predated the instant offending but for which he was sentenced after it and (b) the personal mitigation stemming from the applicant's attempts to rehabilitate himself in the lengthy period between his release from custody and the date of sentence.
On behalf of Ali it is submitted that the judge failed to take any or any sufficient account of totality as a result of the sentences imposed in February 2025. Had all matters been joined up and had the applicant therefore been sentenced for all offences at the same time, it is submitted that it is unlikely he would have received a consecutive sentence of 30 months' imprisonment.
Discussion
This case demonstrates the not uncommon difficulties faced by judges when called upon to sentence offenders for offences that have occurred several years previously and where in the intervening period between the date of offence and the date of charge the offender's personal circumstances have changed. That change may be a positive one that comes through rehabilitation, employment or increased maturity, or a negative one as a result of continued offending for which the offender has been sentenced and which therefore raises issues of totality.
Delay
The General Guideline: Overarching Principles states that:
"Where there has been an unreasonable delay in proceedings since apprehension which is not the fault of the offender, the court may take this into account by reducing the sentence if this has had a detrimental effect on the offender."
What may amount to a detrimental effect was considered in R v Barrett [2025] EWCA Crim 840 at [25], where Davis LJ stated that:
"The kind of detrimental effect envisaged by the guideline is where an offender suffers some genuine psychological or even physical harm due to the delay, or where, for instance, it is apparent that an offender has had to put his life on hold waiting for a decision on prosecution."
In R v Timpson [2023] EWCA Crim 453, the Court considered that where there is a delay of many months or sometimes years between the conclusion of the investigation and the decision to charge:
"That type of delay often will result in some reduction in the eventual sentence, particularly in cases where the offender pleads guilty. We observe that the reduction would be most unlikely to be as great as 25 per cent, particularly where the offences were serious, but some reduction would follow."
Both Barrett and Timpson have been recently considered in R v Wilson (Billy-Joe) [2026] EWCA Crim 427. In that case, during the 6 years between the original complaint and the date of trial, the offender had turned his life around. He had not committed any further offences and there was what the Court considered to be "potent evidence of rehabilitation and lasting change". The Court stated that:
"... it could not be said that the offender had suffered a detrimental effect as normally contemplated by [Barrett]... He had not suffered harm and could not be said to have put his life on hold waiting for a decision on prosecution. However, in our judgment, the delay had a different but equally material effect in the present case, namely that it enabled the offender to turn his life around. In the 6½ years since June 2019 (at the latest), he had committed no further relevant offences. More positively, there was evidence before the Judge that he had taken positive steps to improve himself, most particularly by seeking medical help for his anger-related issues; and the fact of his having managed to remain in a successful relationship for well over 6 years, combined with the clear and strong support from his present partner, was potent evidence of rehabilitation and lasting change. These, in our judgment, were consequences of the delay that provided significant mitigation, quite apart from the undesirability of grossly delayed imposition of a custodial sentence."
In terms of the appropriate amount of reduction for sentence the Court noted, and agreed with the observation in Timpson, that the reduction would be unlikely to be as much as 25 per cent.
Totality
In R v Green (Michael) [2019] EWCA Crim 196, the Court set out a non-exhaustive list of factors that could be taken into account where a judge was sentencing an offender who had served a previous sentence for similar previous offences. Relevant factors to the application before us include: how recently the previous sentence was imposed; the similarity of the previous offences to the instant offence; whether the offences overlapped in terms of the time they were committed; and whether, if no account is taken of the previous sentence, the length of the two sentences is such that, had they been passed together, to be served consecutively, that would have offended the totality principle. The Court in Green went on to state at [17] that:
"Having considered such matters and any others relevant to the instant case, the judge, having reached the appropriate sentence for the instant offences (taking into account the totality principle in respect of the new offences alone), then has a discretion whether or not he or she should make some further allowance or reduction to take account of the previous sentence."
The approach set out in Green is reflected in the Totality Guideline, which states that:
"The court should first reach the appropriate sentence for the instant offences, taking into account totality in respect of the instant offences alone. The court then has a discretion whether to make further allowance to take into account the earlier sentence (whether or not that sentence has been served in full). The court should consider all the circumstances in deciding what, if any, impact the earlier sentence should have on the new sentence. It is not simply a matter of considering the overall sentence as though the previous court had been able to sentence all the offences and then deducting the earlier sentence from that figure."
The Totality Guideline then goes on to list the non-exhaustive list of relevant factors set out in Green, including those that we have referred to above.
Qureshi
In our judgment, the sentence of 30 months imposed upon Qureshi cannot be criticised. The judge chose the correct starting point of 4½ years. Although Qureshi was on bail for another offence at the relevant time, the judge did not find that to be an aggravating factor as he could have done. The reduction of 25 per cent for his guilty plea was rounded up in the applicant's favour. To reflect the delay and other available mitigation, the judge then made a further reduction of 10 months, which amounted to 25 per cent of the sentence figure reached after credit for a guilty plea to arrive at the sentence of 30 months. That reduction was not only already generous given Timpson but by applying the reduction after rather than before the reduction for guilty plea, the applicant received a lower sentence than he would have received had the relevant deductions been made in the correct order. There was nothing manifestly excessive about the sentence passed.
Neither do we consider that any further deduction should have been made as a consequence of the prison sentence served by the applicant in 2023, where that term of imprisonment resulted from the applicant's second breach of the terms of a suspended sentence order imposed subsequent to the instant offending and where the applicant had already received some benefit, in that the sentence was only activated in part.
We have considered whether a community order should have been imposed instead of an immediate sentence of imprisonment but although the General Principles Guidelines is clear that a community order may be imposed instead of a short or moderate custodial sentence, we cannot say that the judge was wrong not to impose such an order. The sentence of 30 months being neither manifestly excessive nor wrong in principle, we refuse leave to appeal the sentence and that application therefore must fail.
Ali
We reach a different conclusion in relation to Ali. The offences subject of his application were the first in the sequence of offences for which he was subsequently sentenced to 5 years and 10 months' imprisonment. He was 18 and of good character at the relevant time. Had he been dealt with for these offences on their own, close to the date of commission, those factors would have amounted to significant mitigation. In fact, having been released under investigation, he went on to commit other offences of a similar nature. There is no doubt that he should and could have been sentenced for all matters that he faced at the same time. Why the Crown Prosecution Service failed to ensure that he was charged so that this could happen and why no-one brought the outstanding matters to the attention of the judge who sentenced Ali to 5 years and 10 months in February 2025 has never been explained.
We consider, however, that there is force in the argument advanced on behalf of the applicant that given that the instant offences were the first in time when the applicant was only 18 and of good character, and given the principles of totality, had the applicant been sentenced for all matters together he would either have received a concurrent sentence to that passed for the drug offences committed in December 2022 which would themselves have been uplifted to take account of earlier offending or, had a consecutive sentence been passed, it would have been less than the 30 months in the event imposed. Although we observe that in either event had the 2025 sentencing judge been made aware that the subsequent offending had taken place while the applicant was under investigation, no doubt he would have increased the sentences that he in fact passed.
In all the circumstances, in our judgment, the appropriate sentence to be passed for the matters subject of this application for leave to appeal taking account of the principles of totality is one of 18 months' imprisonment and not 30 months.
Accordingly, we grant leave to appeal the sentence of 30 months. We quash those sentences and substitute for them concurrent sentences of 18 months' imprisonment on each count. To that extent in respect of Mr Ali, this appeal succeeds.
Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.
Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London, WC2A 1JE
Tel No: 020 7404 1400 Email: Rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk