R E X v GUISEPPE FIORELLINI-BERNARDIS

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1290

View download options

R E X v GUISEPPE FIORELLINI-BERNARDIS

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1290

WARNING: reporting restrictions may apply to the contents transcribed in this document, particularly if the case concerned a sexual offence or involved a child. Reporting restrictions prohibit the publication of the applicable information to the public or any section of the public, in writing, in a broadcast or by means of the internet, including social media. Anyone who receives a copy of this transcript is responsible in law for making sure that applicable restrictions are not breached. A person who breaches a reporting restriction is liable to a fine and/or imprisonment. For guidance on whether reporting restrictions apply, and to what information, ask at the court office or take legal advice.

This Transcript is Crown Copyright.  It may not be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence or with the express consent of the Authority.  All rights are reserved.

[2026] EWCA Crim 1290
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL Royal Courts of Justice
CRIMINAL DIVISION The Strand

London

WC2A 2LL

ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT LINCOLN

(MR CHRISTOPHER DONNELLAN KC) [32C80553124]

Case No 2026/02560/A1Thursday 17 September 2026

B e f o r e:

LORD JUSTICE BEAN

MR JUSTICE JAY

MRS JUSTICE HEATHER WILLIAMS DBE

____________________

ATTORNEY GENERAL'S REFERENCE

UNDER SECTION 36 OF

THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 1988)

____________________

R E X

- v -

GUISEPPE FIORELLINI-BERNARDIS

_____________________

Computer Aided Transcription of Epiq Europe Ltd,

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)

_____________________

Mr N Holland appeared on behalf of the Attorney General

Miss R Freitas (Solicitor Advocate) appeared on behalf of the Offender

____________________

J U D G M E N T

(Approved)

___________________

Thursday 17 September 2026

LORD JUSTICE BEAN:

1.

The Attorney General (who at the time of the Reference was Solicitor General) applies, under section 36 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988, for leave to refer to this court sentences imposed on the offender which she considers to be unduly lenient.

2.

On 15 June 2026, in the Crown Court at Lincoln, the offender, Giuseppe Fiorellini-Bernardiis was sentenced by Mr Recorder Christopher Donnellan KC to concurrent sentences, the longest of which was 18 months' imprisonment, all suspended for two years with certain additional requirements.

3.

Mr Holland, who appears for the Attorney General, submits that the sentences should have been of immediate imprisonment and for a longer period.

4.

The offences were all committed on 12 August 2024, or a short time after midnight that night. On that date, the offender accessed an online messaging service called "Chat Hour". He made contact with a user who identified herself as "Ruby Davies". The profile picture associated with that name was an image which appeared to be a photograph of an adolescent female. In fact, "Ruby Davies" and her account were a decoy. The account was being operated by a volunteer for an organisation which attempts to locate paedophiles.

5.

"Ruby" told the offender that she was 14 years old. The conversations began with the offender asking if she was "naughty". A little later he asked for her bra size. She said that she was not comfortable speaking about private things on "Chat Hour". At the offender's request, she sent a link to a conversation on Google Chat.

6.

He then asked for a photograph. She suggested that they exchange photographs. He first sent a photograph of himself wearing only underpants. She sent him a photograph of an adolescent female wearing a nightdress. He told her that she was "super gorgeous". In the next photograph he sent her, he was again wearing only underpants, but he had his left hand inserted into the crotch area. He asked about the underwear she was wearing. He asked her to turn on her camera, but she said that she could not do that. He asked her if she had ever "got wet before", whether she had ever masturbated, or whether she had ever had "a little rub". "Ruby" said that she did not know what he meant.

7.

The offender then sent her a video of himself wearing only underpants. She sent him a photograph of a girl in bed underneath the bed covers. He asked her for a photograph of her without the bed covers, which she declined to provide.

8.

The offender suggested that they might meet and kiss. She said that she had never kissed anyone. He asked if she was okay with him being 43 years of ag, and she replied "as long as ur ok with me being 14 its kool". He said "it's kool".

9.

The offender made repeated requests of "Ruby" for a photograph of her in her underwear, which she declined to provide.

10.

There was discussion about the offender's job and "Ruby's" aspirations to be a model. He asked if she was wearing pyjamas and asked questions about her underwear. He sent further photographs of himself, this time fully clothed.

11.

He asked her if she had ever got "wet down below" when talking to someone. She said that she had not. He said that he anted to teach her to explore her body and sensations. They arranged to meet online at 9.30 pm.

12.

When they did so, he sent "Ruby" photographs of himself. In the first he was wearing a T-shirt and shorts, with the T-shirt pulled up. In the second, the shorts were pulled down to expose his underpants. He told her to "grab a pillow" and put it between her legs. He instructed her to rock back and forth on the pillow and to cup her breasts in her hands. He told her to look at pictures that he would send. He sent her three more photographs of himself. In the first he was naked from the waist up. In the second he was naked, but using his hands to conceal almost all of his genitalia. The third photograph was similar, but with the genitalia a little more exposed.

13.

He then instructed "Ruby" to remove her knickers. He asked if she was "wet". "Ruby" replied that she thought it was wee. The offender asked her if she had any hair on her vagina. "Ruby" said that she did not. He instructed "Ruby" to look inside her vagina. He told her to resume rocking on the cushion. He sent her a photograph of himself naked, holding his erect penis in his hands. He sent another photograph in which his erect penis was exposed. He then sent a video of his penis in which he handled his penis and then masturbated. "Ruby" said that the offender's "willy" was big. He sent yet a further video of his penis, similar to the previous one. "Ruby" said, "Does that big willy fit into a vagina?" The offender replied "Yes it can. It takes time". The offender asked if her pillow was wet. He told her to put her finger in the wet part of the pillow and then taste it. He instructed her to run a finger up and down her vagina and then put it into her mouth. He asked how it tasted. He said that he would like to suck "Ruby's" vagina. He told her to resume touching her vagina. He informed her that he was masturbating. He told "Ruby" to record herself from behind. He asked for a picture of her underwear. She declined to provide one. He instructed her to insert a finger into her vagina. He told her to suck the finger and then to re-insert it. He asked her how her finger tasted. She said that putting her finger into her vagina had hurt and that there was blood on the finger.

14.

The messages in which the offender was inciting "Ruby" to masturbate continued for almost three hours. The two said good night to one other and stopped sending messages at 20 minutes past midnight.

15.

The following day and the day after that they exchanged further messages. The offender asked "Ruby" how she had felt during their chat and whether she had enjoyed being "wet".

16.

A group of people associated with the organisation behind the "Ruby" decoy attended the offender's home address on 15 August. They called the police who attended and arrested him.

17.

The offender was interviewed on 16 August 2025. He answered many of the questions he was asked by saying "No comment". When he was asked if he owned the devices seized by the police, he confirmed that he did. He provided the PINs to the devices, as well as the username and password for his Google drive account.

18.

It was more than 18 months later before he was brought to court. His first appearance was on 30 March 2026 in the magistrates' court. He entered a plea of guilty to an offence of attempting to cause a child to look at an image of sexual activity. He indicated pleas of not guilty to the other three charges.

19.

However, at the plea and trial preparation hearing in the Crown Court on 27 April 2026, he entered pleas of guilty to all four charges. There was a technical issue about the form of the committal to the Crown Court of the one offence to which he had entered a plea of guilty. This need not detain us as it has no effect on the result.

20.

There was no dispute before the judge, and there is no dispute before us, that the proper approach was to consider the mater as a whole, to impose a sentence on count 3, to treat that as the lead offence, and to impose concurrent sentences on the other charges.

21.

The four charges were: count 1, attempted sexual communication with a child; count 2, attempting to cause or incite a child to engage in non-penetrative sexual activity; count 3 (the lead offence), attempting to cause or incite a child to engage in penetrative sexual activity; and count 4, attempting to cause a chid to watch a sexual act.

22.

It is accepted on all sides that each of the attempted sexual offences was committed, even though the "child" was in fact an adult decoy. The relevant guideline emphasises that sentencers should "approach the assessment of seriousness the same way, regardless of whether activity was caused or incited in person or remotely and regardless of whether harm was caused to a victim in person or remotely".

23.

The treatment of count 3 as the lead offence meant that the categorisation of that offence was important. The prosecution submitted that the attempted harm on that count was penetration of the vagina, and that the harm category was thus plainly category 1.

24.

As to culpability, the guideline lays down that certain factors should be regarded as indicating culpability level A. There is a long list, most of which is inapplicable in the present case. The two relevant factors are significant disparity in age between the offender and the victim and whether sexual images of the victim have been recorded, retained, solicited or shared. There is no suggestion that the offender had any intention of sharing the images with anyone else.

25.

The prosecution submitted before the judge that this was a category 1A offence.

26.

Before considering the aspects of the judge's sentencing which are the subject of challenge, we should mention what is not challenged. The judge found that the offender was not a dangerous offender for the purposes of the dangerousness provisions of the Sentencing Code. He was entitled to do so. Mr Holland does not suggest otherwise. Another undisputed point is that the offender was entitled to a 25 per cent reduction on the notional sentence after a trial since he had pleaded guilty to all the charges by the time of the plea and trial preparation hearing.

27.

The passages in the sentencing remarks with which Mr Holland takes issue are as follows (at pages 20 and 21 of the transcript):

"I …will have to consider what adjustment I make to the offence as it is charged as an attempt but as indicated by Mr Sands [prosecution counsel at the hearing before the judge], it is not a significant downward adjustment. But I have to take account of the whole and overview of the case in relation to each of the offences.

…

In considering the guidelines in relation to the inciting to engage in sexual activity, it indicates that step two is the stage when I have to consider what adjustment to make for the fact that this was a decoy and there was no real child. More particularly I have to consider, as I have already indicated, this was not face to face. The child was not in the room with you, being incited by you to carry out these offences. That is the starting point for where the guidelines are: that there is a real child in front of you.

Of course, if a real child had been in front of you, then a very significant immediate custodial sentence would follow.

But I have adjusted, having considered very carefully, the range in this case. I have come to the conclusion that it is closer to the equivalent of a Category 2A offence. I am taking an overview of the factors and that puts it in a range of two to six years, with a starting point of three years. I have taken the view that the starting point is at the lower end of that range, the lowest end of that range, of about two years. I regard there [are] no further aggravating features."

The Submissions for the Attorney General

28.

The starting point for a category 1A offence of this type is five years' custody. Mr Holland argues that the reduction from this starting point to a notional two years after trial (and thus 18 months after a plea of guilty) was wrong in principle, as was the decision to suspend the sentence. First, he complains that the judge gave far too great a reduction for the fact that "Ruby" was not real, contrary to the instructions in the sentencing guideline; that the judge must have made too great a reduction for mitigation; and that the offences were too serious for anything other than immediate custody.

29.

In her concise submissions, Ms Freitas, who appears for the offender, naturally relies on the points made by the judge. She submits that the sentence of 18 months' imprisonment, suspended on the lead count, was one which the judge was entitled to impose.

30.

The Attorney General's first point about the reduction which the judge made for "Ruby" being a decoy is, in our view, clearly well-founded. The guidelines states that:

"… in attempts where a child victim does not exist and, but for this fact, the offender would have carried out the offence, only a very small reduction within the category range will usually be appropriate."

31.

Plainly, in the passages we have quoted, the judge made a much more substantial reduction than a very small reduction for the decoy factor.

32.

We also agree that the lead offence could only properly be categorised as 1A. The judge did not explain why he regarded the matter as "closer to the equivalent of a category 2A offence" for sentencing purposes.

33.

However, although we think that the correct category was 1A, there were points properly made in the offender's favour. Firstly, the course of conduct, as we have noted, lasted less than 24 hours. Secondly, the culpability A factors in this case were limited to the disparity in age between the offender and the intended victim and the fact that the offender solicited and perhaps intended to retain the images of "Ruby". In many cases of this type of offence, other graver factors from the category A list are engaged, such as abuse of trust; use of threats; commercial exploitation or motivation and so forth.

34.

Thirdly, the offender's positive good character and absence of previous convictions afforded some mitigation, although it is limited in cases of this type.

35.

The delay in the matter being brought before the court, during which it was hanging over the offender's head, was also a point in his favour.

36.

In the light of all these factors, we consider that a notional sentence after trial at the bottom end of the category range for category 1A for the lead offence, namely four years' imprisonment, would have been appropriate, giving a figure of three years' imprisonment after the credit of 25 per cent for the guilty plea.

37.

The final question is whether the judge was entitled to suspend the sentences. Section 2 of the Sentencing Act 2026 had come into force on 22 March 2026. Since the first plea of guilty occurred after that date, it would have been open to the judge to have imposed a suspended sentence of three years' imprisonment. We do not accept the submission advanced on behalf of the Attorney General that on the facts of this case only an immediate custodial sentence would suffice. The guideline contains the following passage:

"Where there is a sufficient prospect of rehabilitation, a community order with programme requirement … can be a proper alternative to a short or moderate length custodial sentence. Alternatively, in appropriate cases, the Probation Service may be able to address the offending behaviour through a community order with a rehabilitation activity requirement."

38.

In the judgment of the court in R v White [2024 EWCA Crim 1390, it was held that a sentence of three years' imprisonment is one of "moderate" length for the purposes of this guideline. Indeed, it is notable that in that case the court varied what would otherwise have been a sentence of three years' immediate custody to one of two years' imprisonment suspended, at a time when that was then the maximum length of a suspended sentence.

39.

In the present case there is no need to make any such alteration. By the time that the offender appeared for sentence, the judge had before him a pre-sentence report in which the benefits of a rehabilitation requirement were set out. There had been no suggestion of any further offending in the almost two years which had by then elapsed since the offending. The latest information from the Probation Service to this court states that:

"At this time there is nothing to suggest that [the offender's] risk cannot be managed in the community."

40.

We are told that the offender has completed all the unpaid work requirement which the judge imposed. We consider that this is indeed a case where there is sufficient prospect of rehabilitation to enable the judge in the exercise of his discretion to conclude that it was a case in which a suspended sentence would suffice.

41.

We consider, overall, that although the suspended sentences were too short in length, a suspended sentence order was justified.

42.

Accordingly, we grant leave to refer and quash the sentences imposed by the judge on counts 1, 2 and 3. We substitute concurrent sentences, in each case suspended for two years. The sentences will be three years' imprisonment on count 3, a concurrent term of 18 months' imprisonment on count 1, and 18 months' imprisonment on count 2. All of those sentences will be suspended for a period of two years. The suspended sentence of eight months' imprisonment on the charge committed for sentence, with which the Attorney General does not take issue, will remain unaltered. The various requirements attached to the suspended sentence by the judge will likewise remain unaltered.

______________________________

Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400

Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk

______________________________

Document download options

Download PDF (119.3 KB)

The original format of the judgment as handed down by the court, for printing and downloading.

Download XML

The judgment in machine-readable LegalDocML format for developers, data scientists and researchers.