
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWCA Crim 1287 IN THE COURT OF APPEAL (CRIMINAL DIVISION) ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT CARLISLE His Honour Judge Barker 03WW0381024 | Case No: 202600888 A22 |
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL
Before:
LORD JUSTICE STUART-SMITH
MR JUSTICE JAY
and
RECORDER OF LINCOLN
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE HIRST)
(Sitting as a Judge of the CACD)
REFERENCE BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL UNDER s.36 CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 1988
REX
-v-
JAMIE HARDY
Mr B Lloyd appeared on behalf of the Attorney General
Ms W Weir appeared on behalf of the Offender
The provisions of the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992 apply to these offences. Under those provisions, where a sexual offence has been committed against a person, no matter relating to that person shall during that person’s lifetime be included in any publication if it is likely to lead members of the public to identify that person as the victim of that offence.
Approved Judgment
Lord Justice Stuart-Smith:
The provisions of the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992 apply to this offence. Under those provisions, where an allegation has been made that a sexual offence has been committed against a person, no matter relating to that person shall during that person's lifetime be included in any publication if it is likely to lead members of the public to identify that person as the victim of that offence. This prohibition applies unless waived or lifted in accordance with section 3 of the Act. For the avoidance of any doubt, we do not waive or lift the prohibition.
His Majesty's Solicitor General applies for leave to refer a sentence which she regards as unduly lenient. The sentence was imposed on the offender on 9 February 2026 in the Crown Court at Carlisle by HHJ Nicholas Barker. The offender had previously pleaded guilty and was entitled to a full one-third discount on account of his plea.
In summary, the details of the sentence imposed by the judge were as follows:
On count 1, which was an offence of sexual activity with a child, contrary to section 9 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003, on his plea of guilty he was sentenced to 64 months' imprisonment.
On counts 2 and 3, which were additional counts of activity with a child, contrary to section 9, upon his plea of guilty he was sentenced on each count to 48 months' imprisonment concurrent.
Count 4 was an offence of meeting a child following sexual grooming, contrary to section 15 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003. On his plea of guilty he was sentenced to 16 months' imprisonment concurrent.
Count 5, was an offence of sexual communication with a child, contrary to section 15A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003. Upon his plea of guilty he was sentenced to 12 months' imprisonment concurrent.
The total sentence was therefore 64 months' imprisonment ie 5 years and 4 months' imprisonment. Other relevant orders were made. A sexual harm prevention order, a restraining order and notification requirements were imposed.
The facts
The offender is now 34 years of age having been born on 12 October 1991. Over the course of just under 2 years the offender, who was aged 30 at the outset, took advantage of the victim (who we call "V") who was initially aged just 14. Having groomed her and solicited indecent images from her, the offender subjected V on a twice weekly basis to vaginal, anal and oral penetration. Count 1 alleged that between 27 September 2022 and 27 September 2024, there was penetration of V's vagina. Count, 2 alleged that between 1 January 2023 and 27 December 2024, there was penetration of her mouth. Count 3 alleged that between 1 September 2023 and 27 December 2024, there was penetration of her anus.
In the period before the index offending began, the offender had become a friend of V's family. The offender came to spend a lot of time with V's stepfather. He would visit often, socialise with the family, go on holiday with them and attend family functions. At the beginning of this period V was 12 years old. The index offending behaviour began when V was just turning 14 years of age. The prosecution described the position as follows: "It may be that as a young girl who was just turning 14, she had a misplaced girlish interest in him" and the offender took advantage of that.
At a family barbecue at V's house in 2022, the offender told V that he had romantic feelings for her. The offender then groomed V, buying her presents, which included teddies and butt plugs. V believed that she had a partner in a naive and innocent way. She believed that she was looking to a future where the two of them could become public when she was older.
As part of the grooming the offender sent V messages; he solicited from her images of her naked breasts. Count 5 represented the sexual communication between the offender and V (between 20 September 2022 and 27 September 2022), during which the offender requested a photograph of V's breasts.
The first arrangement for the two to meet was to meet in the dark on a local cycle track. Knowing that her parents would be concerned as to her whereabouts, the victim began to lie to them about visits to a friend. V went on to claim that she was spending overnight sleepovers at the friend's house. Count 4 represented the meeting between the offender and V following sexual grooming on 27 September 2022.
The offender began sexual activity with the victim straightaway (vaginal sexual intercourse: count 1). At the first attempt this was physically difficult. Therefore the offender introduced lubricant; at which point sexual intercourse was possible.
After about a year of such meetings (which were occurring about twice a week), the offender started pestering the victim for oral (count 2) and anal (count 3) sexual intercourse. She was reluctant but acquiesced. In her police interview, V was asked if she wanted to have oral and anal sex and she replied, "Not at first, but he wanted to and I felt bad so I let him. He just kept asking and begging me if he could". As with the vaginal intercourse, the oral and anal intercourse would occur on average about twice a week.
There were times when V just wanted to lie in bed at his house watching films, however the offender would get angry and say that that was not what he wanted; his wishes always prevailed.
During the period of the offending the offender would also visit V's home. The offender was trusted by V's mother to spend time at the property when the mother was away; the offender was ostensibly looking after V.
Around a year or so before the offending behaviour was reported in December 2024, V was telling the offender that she wanted it to cease. The offender responded with threats that he would tell everyone and that her world would come crashing down. The offender made threats to burn the family’s home down. As such, it took a lot in the end for V to tell her family, but eventually V told her mother who involved the police.
Thereafter, the offender committed an offence of harassment towards the family; this involved retribution for the matter having been reported to the police. The offender wanted the case to be dropped; he would follow the victim to the shops. Between 18 February 2025 and 13 March 2025, the offender committed harassment against the victim's father with the offender engaging in behaviour that was threatening and aggressive. He was separately sentenced on 7 July 2025 to a suspended sentence of 8 weeks suspended for 12 months and was made the subject of a restraining order. On 29 October 2025 he breached the restraining order as a result of which he was fined on 8 November 2025. The breach had involved the offender walking past the victim's mother, daughter and son and winking at them.
The following aggravating features were present. Firstly, the soliciting of the indecent images of the victim. Secondly, a factory reset of his telephone to dispose of the evidence.
The following mitigating features were identified. He had no previous convictions for like offending and he had difficult personal circumstances relating to his background.
The offender
The offender has eight convictions for 14 offences. These included possession of cannabis with intent to supply (for which he was sentenced in 2011 to a community order, subsequently varied to imprisonment as a result of a failure to comply with the order); and two offences of battery in 2013 (for which he was sentenced to a community order, subsequently varied to imprisonment as a result of breach proceedings). The best that can be said was that he had no previous convictions for sexual offending.
The sentencing hearing
V made two personal statements in very similar terms. They explained with eloquent simplicity the disastrous effect of the offender's crimes. In the first she said:
"I believed he loved me.
Jamie's attitude with me could change quickly particularly if I said no to sex, he would get angry at me if I said no and would start threatening me, my home and my family so I done it because I had
to, not because I wanted to.
After 12 months I wanted nothing to do with Jamie but was too scared to leave him because I knew how angry he could get, I was also too scared to tell my parents because of the threats Jamie made to burn down my house. After a while I met a lad at my cousins party and we become friends, we hung out sometimes and I felt safe, comfortable and natural.
He gave me the courage to end things with Jamie but he was still calling me and made me go on video calls with him, I would do this because he kept up his threats to burn down our house. I was
scared of Jamie and what he might do.
Eventually Jamie's threats become too much so I told my friend who encouraged me to open up to my mam and [X] about what had been going on. That was hard, I was scared they would blame me or not believe me, I was worried about my family getting into trouble because they wanted to protect me and more importantly the night I told my parents I was petrified that this was the night we were going to die.
My mam was really good and we sat and talked about it... It’s took me seven months to realise that this was not a normal relationship, that I was groomed and the kind of love Jamie was displaying was wrong.
Since all of this Jamie has picked a fight with [my friend], me and my little brother who is only 12 (11 at the time) outside of a shop, followed me to the same shop some time later although he was never charged for this for reasons I don’t even understand. ... After a previous court case he walked into a bus station right in the middle of me, [my friend] and my mam while looking down at us.
I have pretended for so long that this wasn’t bothering me but it is...
I was scared that something was going to happen and one of us was going to get hurt.
What Jamie has done to me, what he has put me through has changed me completely. I used to be a laid back, easy going teenager who loved spending time with friends and family. Now I can’t stand to be around anyone that isn’t my parents, [my friend] or my Grandparents on occasion.
Rarely do I visit my grandparents and younger brother anymore… I don’t sit down stairs with family for more than 5
minutes because it’s hard for me to be around people.
I have fallen out with everyone I used to be friends with except my one best friend who has been there for me since nursery.
I struggle emotionally and have outbursts all the time, I don’t know how to be around people anymore and trust is something I don’t think I will ever be able to do again.
I feel angry all the time and because of this when my family are talking to me I either ignore them or I snap at them.
I tell my family that I am not bothered about all of this but it's not the truth, I'm angry all the time. I hate going out unless I have to and mostly I have my friend or my mum with me. There are occasions I have gone to the shop on my own, but I'm on high alert and I'm scared so I try to be quick as I can be.
Before all of this with Jamie I always told my mam everything, where I was, what I was doing, who I was with and I could talk to her about anything. I was never worried about going to my mam about things until Jamie made me keep our relationship secret, until Jamie got me to sneak to his house and made me tell my mam I was with a friend she knew quite well and trusted to look after
me.
Jamie has ruined my life, ruined relationships and made me hate myself for not seeing what was going on, I feel fear, I feel shame, I feel guilt...
I need to be able to talk to someone and hopefully try to heal. I will never forget what has happened and I will never be able to forgive Jamie but maybe one day I can be better than I am now."
There was a pre-sentence report available to the judge. The author noted that the offender suggested that over time he and V fell for each other and indicated that he "could not help" who he fell in love with. The author assessed that reflected a lack of any significant remorse. The offender denied that he had groomed V and suggested that she initiated the relationship. He did however accept, when prompted, that she could not legally consent and that as the adult, he was responsible for keeping her safe and not pursuing any relationship with her. The author assessed that the offender took advantage of V's crush on him and then pursued a course of grooming behaviour for his own sexual gratification. During this time, he continued to have a close relationship with V's family, indicating a significant breach of trust. He had an ability to manipulate and control V. The offender lacked insight into what constituted grooming behaviour. He did admit the offending but there was evidence of victim blaming.
The author noted that the index offending indicated a significant escalation in his behaviour. This included the recent breach of restraining order, which raised significant concerns regarding the offender's ability to exercise self-control. The pattern of the index offending raised significant concerns regarding manipulative and deceptive behaviour. Such conduct demonstrated a concerning behavioural pattern rather than an isolated lapse in judgment. The author noted that the index offences were indicative of predatory and manipulative behaviour. In addition, the fact that the offender would become aggressive and make threats to V evidenced behaviour that was controlling and coercive in nature. Although the offender was described as "immature" emotionally, there were significant deficits in this area that the author opined go beyond immaturity. The author recorded that using the offender group reconviction scale the offender was assessed as presenting a low risk of general reoffending (16% in 2 years). The risk of serious recidivism tool also indicated a low risk of reoffending. The OASys sexual reoffending predictor assessed the offender as posing a medium risk of committing contact offences and low risk of image-related offending. However, the author noted that age and limited previous convictions have impacted these assessments. In the author's view they are an underestimate of the risks posed, given the nature of the current offences, the absence of protective factors, social isolation, mental health, attitudes to offending and suspected ongoing drug misuse. The author assessed the offender as posing a high risk of serious harm to female children, likely aged between 14 and 16 years of age. The author also noted that a high risk of harm conclusion has been reached when considering the victim's parents. The author noted that the offender's pattern of conduct demonstrated poor emotional control, a continued disregard for court orders and an inability to regulate his behaviour, reinforcing the assessment of high risk.
The parties' submissions
It was common ground before the judge that the offences of sexual activity with a child were within category 1A, which indicated a starting point after a trial of 5 years for a single-incident offence. Defence counsel submitted that the offender was entitled to a full one-third credit for his pleas of guilty and urged the judge to bear in mind totality and to avoid double counting.
The sentencing remarks
In his sentencing remarks the judge noted that the victim's family had trusted the offender. The offender had groomed the victim, who was 14 at the outset, when the offender was 30. That was a significant disparity. The offender abused the vulnerability of a young child. It was in breach of the family's trust and the relationship the offender had with them. The offender had embarked upon a course of conduct with the victim - it was wrong to call it a "relationship". He exploited the victim's vulnerability. The offender engaged in vaginal, oral and anal sex with the victim. There was grooming, which included buying gifts of butt plugs and lingerie. The offender made the victim send him naked pictures of herself. The judge also noted that once matters were reported to the police, the offender engaged in harassing and threatening behaviour to the family and the offender was earlier convicted of those offences. The offender reset his telephone to delete material from his phone. There were previous convictions but none that were relevant. The behaviour towards the family that had led to their harassment was an aggravating feature. There would be full credit for the pleas of guilty. Any alleged insight was late in the day.
The judge explained the sentence that he was imposing as follows:
"As far as the guidelines are concerned, there can be no doubt that the sexual activity with a child offending contrary to s.10 of the Sexual Offences Act is in the highest category, of a category A1. That is on the basis that there was penetration of the vagina or the anus and penetration of the mouth. In addition the culpability is in the highest category, I find it so because there was a significant degree of planning that extended over a lengthy period of time. It must be accepted that that planning existed. It must be accepted that there was grooming behaviour used upon [V]. Sexual images were retained, solicited, and there was of course a significant disparity of age between you. That would, for a single offence after trial, have been met with a sentence of five years. Dealing with Count 1 on the indictment as a single offence, that would militate a rise of up to six years. That I find is the step one stage.
However, turning to other factors, there are the multiple incidents taking place over many, many weeks. She describes sex taking place on average twice a week. The fact that this carried on for nearly two years. Your attempts to conceal the evidence. The interference, criminal interference that you conducted towards the family after the matter was reported to the police, and the impact that I have heard so bravely read by [V’s] mother reading [V’s] victim personal statement out, and the fact that this continues to have a significant impact upon her with her requiring to obtain therapy and referral to the crisis team.
Taking all of the offending and seeing Count 1 upon this indictment as the lead offence, it seems to me that before any discount for credit the appropriate sentence is one of eight years. That will be reduced by one third to allow for the discount. That means the sentence is sixty-four months, which is five years and four months. As to the other counts on the indictment, I find that Counts 2 and 3 are to be dealt with by sentences of four years, that is with the reduction, and Counts 4 and 5, Count 4, sixteen months, and Count 5, twelve months. The total sentence is one of sixty-four months’ imprisonment."
Solicitor General's submissions
The Solicitor General concentrates mainly on counts 1 to 3, the penetrative activity contrary to section 9 of the Sexual Offences Act. The Solicitor General submits that the offending in counts 1 to 3 falls within category 1A, category 1 harm because of the fact of penetration, category A culpability for multiple reasons: significant degree of planning; grooming behaviour; abuse of trust; use of threats; sexual images were solicited and retained and significant disparity of age. On this basis, for a single incident of the sexual activity, the starting point would be 5 years' custody with a range of 4 to 10 years. At step 2 the Solicitor General submits that the multiple factors indicating culpability should have caused an upward adjustment from the starting point. The judge adjusted the starting point of 5 years by increasing the notional sentence to 6, for the significant planning that extended over a lengthy period of time; the grooming behaviour; the soliciting of sexual images and the disparity in ages. He did not mention at that point the abuse of trust or the use of threats as influencing that adjustment. The Solicitor General submits that an upward adjustment of only 1 year to reflect the multiple culpability factors is insufficient and that an adjustment up to the very top of the category range, that is 10 years, was required for a single-incident offence.
As aggravating features, the Solicitor General identifies attempting to conceal evidence by carrying out a factory reset on his phone at a time when he knew the balloon was going up. We would add to that the steps that were taken to prevent V from reporting his crimes and the fact of ejaculation. The Solicitor General submits that these factors should have caused a further increase in the notional sentence, again for a single-incident offence. The only relevant mitigation apart from his pleas of guilty was his absence of similar prior offending which could be of limited impact giving the seriousness and duration of the offending.
The Solicitor General's submissions thus far are on the basis of a single-incident offence but each count was a multi-incident count, alleging a course of conduct lasting over 2 years, involving penetration of each kind (vaginal, anal and oral) twice a week throughout the period. On the most conservative of estimates, that meant that the judge was dealing not with a single incident or even three single incidents (one on each count) but with well over 100 incidents, each of which would constitute an offence contrary to section 9 of the Sexual Offences Act in its own right. The judge increased the notional sentence before plea on count 1, treating that as the lead offence, from 6 years to 8 years to take account of:
The multiple weekly incidents over about 2 years;
His attempt to conceal evidence;
His harassment of V's family and
The impact of the offending on V.
The Solicitor General submits that this is an inadequate adjustment, which has led to a sentence that is not merely lenient but unduly lenient.
Separately, the Solicitor General submits that the judge should have found that the offender satisfied the statutory definition of dangerousness and should have been made subject to an extended sentence. The Solicitor General relies upon multiple features of the evidence, namely:
The nature of the index offending itself, which involved sexual abuse committed for a period of 2 years;
The offender would get angry with the victim and make threats which included to burn the family's home down;
The offender's conduct after the offending was reported;
The level of harm caused to the victim and her family;
The author of the pre-sentence report noting the offender lacked any significant remorse and engaged in victim blaming - the author noted the offender's manipulative and controlling rolling behaviour;
The index offending indicated a significant escalation in his behaviour, including the breach of a restraining order which raised significant concerns regarding the offender's ability to exercise self-control;
The author of the pre-sentence report observed that the index offences were indicative of predatory and manipulative behaviour.
The author assessed that the lack of compliance with the restraining order and the engaging in threatening behaviour raised further concerns in relation to risks posed and risk management;
The author assessed the offender as posing a high risk of serious harm to female children likely aged between 14 and 16 years of age. The author also noted that the "high risk of harm conclusion has been reached when considering the victim's parents". The author noted that the offender's pattern of conduct demonstrated poor emotional control, a continued disregard for court orders and an inability to regulate his behaviour, reinforcing the assessment of high risk.
The offender's submissions
Ms Weir appears for the offender as she did in the court below. She has said on the offender's behalf everything, both in writing and orally, that could properly be said. She submits that the sentence imposed by the judge reflected the overall seriousness of the offending and correctly recognised the mitigation available to the offender. She relies upon his limited criminal history, with offences committed when he was much younger, the absence of any prior sexual offending and submits that the offender was immature for his age, had a lack of previous adult relationships outside his immediate family, and that the loss of both his parents may have impeded his ability to form and sustain healthy adult relationships.
Dealing first with the application of the guidelines, Ms Weir concedes that that the judge could have increased the starting point to a notional sentence of more than 8 years after trial but she submits that he did not err in placing the offending in that bracket of the guideline and that he was careful not to double count the factors that caused the offences to be category 1A by reintroducing them as aggravating features. She submits that there is no gross error in the judge's approach to and application of the guideline.
Turning to the question of totality, Ms Weir submits that counts 4 and 5 should properly be considered as part of the same course of conduct charged under counts 1 to 3 and that they were properly brought into account as such by the judge. She submits that an uplift of more than 50 per cent from 5 to 8 years is just and proportionate and does not fall outside the range of sentences a judge applying his or her mind to the relevant factors could reasonably consider appropriate. On dangerousness,Ms Weir points out that the judge was not addressed on the question of dangerousness either by the prosecution or the defence. She submits that the test is not satisfied. The offender is 34 years of age and has no other specified offences or sexual offences in his antecedent history and his offending was committed against one person who was known to him. She recognises the terms of the pre-sentence report, which we have summarised above, but submits that any risk can be properly managed by the rehabilitative work he was undertaking in prison. Even if a finding of dangerousness is made, Ms Weir submits that there is no demonstrated need to impose an extended sentence.
Additional materials available to this Court
We have the advantage of a report from the prison, for which we are grateful. Early on in his sentence, his conduct has been broadly appropriate. The report does not take matters further.
Discussion and resolution
The judge was entitled to pass concurrent sentences and to treat count 1 as the lead offence but, if he was going to do so, the sentence on count 1 had to reflect the overall criminality of the offender's conduct.
We start from the agreed position that all of the offending covered by counts 1 to 3 fell to be categorised as 1A offences for the reasons we have outlined. That meant that for a single offence of penetrative sexual activity the starting point was 5 years' custody, with a category range from 4 to 10 years' custody. The starting point of 5 years for a single incident category 1A offence required to be increased because of the multiple culpability factors that applied: significant degree of planning; grooming behaviour; abuse of trust; use of threats; sexual images were solicited and retained and significant disparity of the age. The individual factors need only to be listed for their seriousness to be clear. Taken together, they required an increase in their notional sentence to at least 7 years. The judge could have gone higher without being at risk of criticism. He in fact increased the starting point to a notional sentence of 6 years. We consider that to be manifestly too low in the light of the particular collection of multiple culpability A factors.
We also consider that the judge's increase of 2 years to cater for the other features that had to be reflected in count 1 is inadequate by a substantial margin. The judge was not dealing with a single-incident offence; he was dealing with a course of offending over 2 years, during which the offender twice a week committed an offence against V that taken on its own would have justified and required passing of a substantial category 1A sentence. Of course, there is no question of imposing scores of consecutive sentences and the final sentence imposed must reflect the principle of totality. The totality of this offender's highly culpable conduct involved a wicked exploitation of V over 2 years, which has had severely damaging consequences for V, as he stole her adolescence. It was offending of the maximum seriousness for this kind of case.
In these circumstances we have considered whether it could be sufficient to stay within the category range for a single category 1A offence when sentencing the offender for his conduct over the period of 2 years. We have taken full account of Ms Weir’s submissions but, in truth, the offender has little or no mitigation other than his guilty pleas. We do not consider that an aggregate sentence of only 10 years before reduction for plea would be an adequate reflection of the duration and persistent seriousness of that course of conduct. In our judgment, the least upwards adjustment to a notional sentence of 7 years for a single incident must recognise and reflect the wicked persistence of the offender's conduct over 2 years, together with the other aggravating features of his conduct during that extended period.
In our judgment, giving all due allowance for totality, this course of offending over such a long period is so serious that the least uplift that could be justified on the facts of this case would be one that led to a notional aggregate sentence of 13 years before reduction for plea. That would indicate a sentence on count 1 of 8 years and 8 months' imprisonment. For these reasons, we consider that the sentence imposed by the judge was unduly lenient by a very significant margin and must be increased.
We have separately considered the question of dangerousness. In our judgment, the material available to the judge now to us would have justified a finding of dangerousness. Furthermore, had the sentence of 5 years and 4 months been adequate as a custodial term, the case for imposing an extended sentence would have been compelling. However, the sentence that we are imposing is of a different order and will afford ample opportunity for the offender to address his risk characteristics. In these circumstances, we do not consider it necessary on a Reference to impose an extended sentence.
For these reasons, we quash the sentence imposed by the judge on counts 1, 2 and 3 and substitute on each count a sentence of 8 years and 8 months concurrent. All other orders remain in force as before.