REX v PHN

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1279

View download options

REX v PHN

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1279

WARNING: reporting restrictions may apply to the contents transcribed in this document, particularly if the case concerned a sexual offence or involved a child. Reporting restrictions prohibit the publication of the applicable information to the public or any section of the public, in writing, in a broadcast or by means of the internet, including social media. Anyone who receives a copy of this transcript is responsible in law for making sure that applicable restrictions are not breached. A person who breaches a reporting restriction is liable to a fine and/or imprisonment. For guidance on whether reporting restrictions apply, and to what information, ask at the court office or take legal advice.

This Transcript is Crown Copyright.  It may not be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence or with the express consent of the Authority.  All rights are reserved.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
CRIMINAL DIVISION

ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT

CASE NO 202600829/B3

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWCA Crim 1279

Royal Courts of Justice

Strand

London

WC2A 2LL

Friday 25 September 2026

Before:

THE VICE PRESIDENT OF THE COURT OF APPEAL (CRIMINAL DIVISION)

(LORD JUSTICE EDIS)

SIR GARY HICKINBOTTOM

MR JUSTICE CAVANAGH

PROSECUTION APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST A RULING UNDER S.58 CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 2003

REX

V

PHN

_________

Computer Aided Transcript of Epiq Europe Ltd,

Lower Ground, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)

________

MR W EMLYN JONES KC appeared on behalf of the Applicant

MS L O’DONNELL appeared on behalf of the Respondent

_________

JUDGMENT FOR IMMEDIATE PUBLICATION

THE VICE-PRESIDENT:

1.

This is an application by the prosecution for leave to appeal against three rulings made in the Crown Court. The appeal is brought under section 58 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003. We give leave. We observe and record the effect of the provisions of section 71 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003. That provision prevents any publication of any report of these proceedings save for specified basic facts until the conclusion of the trial unless the Court orders that the provisions are not to apply. This anonymised and edited version of the judgment is for immediate publication because it concerns a frequently encountered issue concerning SFR 1 forensic science documents. The prohibition on publication of the full judgment continues in force.

2.

PHN and another stood trial on an indictment containing two counts of burglary, contrary to section 9(1)(b) of the Theft Act 1968.

3.

The Recorder made two evidential rulings in relation to evidence which was to be adduced by the prosecution:

(a)

…….; and

(b)

He excluded an SFR1 containing evidence of a footprint comparison between marks recovered from the scene of the burglary in count 2 and the trainers worn by the defendant at the time of his arrest. An SFR1 is a Streamlined Forensic Report.

4.

On 25 February 2026, the Recorder upheld submissions of no case to answer in relation to both counts on the indictment against the co-defendant and in relation to count 2 only on the indictment against PHN. On the same day the prosecution indicated their intention to seek leave to appeal against the rulings on the submission of no case. The acquittal undertaking was given in accordance with section 58(8) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003. Leave to appeal was refused by the Recorder and he discharged the jury bringing that trial to an end on 27 February 2026.

5.

……..

6.

The prosecution principally appeals against the ruling of 26 February that there was no case to answer against PHN on count 2 of the indictment. The rulings of 24 February 2026 including the exclusion the SFR1 are brought within that appeal by the nomination of the prosecution under section 58(7) of the 2003 Act.

7.

The prosecution submits that those two pieces of evidence should have been admitted and may therefore be taken into account in determining whether there was a case to answer against PHN on count 2. They also submit that even without those two pieces of evidence, there was a case to answer and that this ruling of the Recorder was wrong even if their appeals in relation to the earlier rulings are unsuccessful.

8.

We have received oral and written submissions from both counsel of high quality. We are grateful for them. We will not set them out here in full but we have them well in mind.

The Indictment

9.

It is unnecessary to set out the Indictment in this edited version of the judgment. Both counts alleged that the burglaries had been committed by the same team of three people, PHN, his co-defendant at trial, and Y.

10.

Y, mentioned in those counts was at the time a youth although he has now passed his 18th birthday. He was remitted to the Youth Court and pleaded guilty to these two burglary offences, and an associated charge of dangerous driving. Those convictions were in evidence at the trial of PHN.

The facts

11.

…..

12.

…..

13.

…..

14.

…...

15.

……..

16.

…….

17.

……

The SFR1

18.

It is first necessary to explain something about what an SFR1 is and how this one had been treated in the proceedings. A SFR1 is a summary of the result of an expert forensic examination. The process is fully detailed in National Guidance for Streamlined Forensic Reporting issued by the Forensic Capability Network (FCN). This was most recently updated in July 2026 as V6.1. Although the document bears some protective markings suggesting that its circulation should be controlled it is in fact published on the FCN website (fcn.police.uk).

19.

The procedure described there has been in existence for nearly 15 years and should by now be very familiar to those who conduct criminal proceedings. It is provided for in the Criminal Procedure Rules Crim PR. Crim PR19.3, so far as relevant, is in these terms:

"Introduction of expert evidence

19.3.—(1) A party who wants another party to admit as fact a summary of an expert’s conclusions must serve that summary—

(a)on the court officer and on each party from whom that admission is sought; and

(b)as soon as practicable after the defendant whom it affects pleads not guilty.

(2)

A party on whom such a summary is served must—

(a)serve a response stating—

(i)which, if any, of the expert’s conclusions are admitted as fact, and

(ii)where a conclusion is not admitted, what are the disputed issues concerning that conclusion; and

(b)serve the response—

(i)on the court officer and on the party who served the summary, and

(ii)as soon as practicable, and in any event not more than 10 business days after service of the summary.

(3)

A party who wants to introduce expert evidence otherwise than as admitted fact must—

(a)serve a report by the expert which complies with rule 19.4 (Content of expert’s report) on—

(i)the court officer, and

(ii)each other party..."

20.

An SFR1 is a summary for the purposes of that rule. It bears this statement of its purpose and status:

"Case management – To the court and to the defence

The prosecution proposes to rely on the forensic evidence contained in this SFR and if there is a trial, to adduce it by way of a s10 CJA 1967 admission to the general effect that the exhibit(s) listed were forensically examined and the examination produced the result(s) described. Therefore should there be a real issue in relation to this forensic evidence, such that the admission cannot be made, the prosecution ask that the defence identify the issue (Crim.PR.3.3 and Crim.PR 19.3(2)).

If this report contains expert evidence, then, in accordance with Crim. PR 19.3(2), the defence is required to serve a response to this report as soon as practicable, and in any event not more than 10 business days after service of the report setting out which, if any of the conclusions in this report are admitted as fact, and where a conclusion is not admitted what are the disputed issues concerning that conclusion.

This SFR is not a witness statement to which the provisions of s9 CJA 1967 and Crim.PR 16 apply, nor is it an expert’s report to which the provisions of Crim. PR 19.4 apply, its purpose being to introduce any expert evidence contained therein as admitted fact. If this SFR contains expert opinion, it is a summary of that opinion served pursuant to Crim. PR 19.3(1).

SFRs assist courts to fulfil their duty to actively manage the case (Crim.PR 3.1) by ensuring that evidence is presented in the shortest and clearest way and by facilitating the early identification of the real issues. (Crim.PR 3.2). Each party must actively assist the court in fulfilling its duty (Crim.PR 3.3)."

21.

In this case, the SFR1 bearing that endorsement was dated 10 November 2025 and was uploaded to the Digital Case System on 15 November 2025. It related to the comparison of footwear marks found at the scene of Burglary 2 with the footwear recovered from PHN and Y. PHN's footwear was called LM06. The report read:

"[Four exhibits] were all black gel lifts that had been used to recover powder enhanced footwear impressions. At least nine footwear impressions of at least four different patterns were recorded across the four lifts. These impressions were fragmentary in nature and overlapping in some areas. Consequently, the overall quality of the impressions was reduced. The lifts were all photographed at the laboratory for enhancement and comparison purposes.

Four of the impressions agreed in pattern with the soles of the training shoes LMC/06. Two of these, which were present on the lift CN/6, aligned with the sole of the left training shoe. The other two impressions, which were present on the lifts CN/7 and CN/9, aligned with the sole of the right shoe. All of these impressions were similar in terms of pattern dimensions and general degree of wear with the soles of the respective shoes. Due to the general nature and poor quality of the impressions, a more meaningful comparison could not be undertaken. There were, though, no differences observed between these impressions and the soles of the shoes LMC/06.

One of the other patterns recorded on the lifts agreed with the sole pattern present on the training shoes attributed to Y. The other two sole patterns differed from those present on the soles of both pairs of submitted training shoes.

Conclusion

In my opinion, the findings provide moderate support for the view that some of the impressions recovered were made by the training shoes attributed to PHN."

22.

The PTPH in this case had taken place on 7 July 2025 and a Defence Case Statement had been served on 6 October 2025. The relevant SFR1 had not been in existence at those dates. On 28 November 2025 the prosecution served draft agreed facts which had been amended to include an admission of the effect of this SFR1. On the same day a hearing took place before a different judge which, among other things, resulted in his making this record on the side bar of the Digital Case System which is accessible to all parties and constitutes a record of the hearing and the orders made at it:

"All SFRs agreed except for [the footwear SFR 1 referred to above]. Any objection to be notified by 5 December 2025 otherwise agreed."

23.

It is common ground that the defence never did notify any objection to the relevant SFR1. At that hearing, as Ms O'Donnell has reminded us, they made it clear to the court that they were unable on that date to make an admission in relation to it, and that it was not agreed. However, the judge extended time for the required giving of notice of any objection to 5 December. No such notice was given. Instead, a request was made for images taken of PHN's own shoes. Those images were not supplied until the start of the trial for some reason but a request for images is not the same thing as a notice of objection as required by the rules. When the trial date came, notwithstanding the absence of any prior objection, the defence declined to make the admission sought about it. This had the result that the prosecution made its application to adduce the SFR1 which was opposed.

24.

The FCN Guidance says this about what is expected of the defence when they receive an SFR1:

"Once the prosecution states its intention to rely on the result of the analysis set out in the MG22B (SFR1), there is a requirement on the Defence to comply with their duties under CrimPR 3.2(a); to identify the issues in the case as early as possible.

There are only two possible responses required of the Defence when it is provided with the MG22B (SFR1):

•

That the Defence respond within 10 working days, or as soon as is reasonably practicable (for example at a case management hearing), by identifying the issues, thus instigating production of an MG22C/D (SFR2) by the prosecution team, which should be in Section 9 Criminal Justice Act 1967 format.

•

That the defence sign (or provide written agreement that they will sign) an admission pursuant to Section 10 Criminal Justice Act 1967 to the general effect that the exhibit/s listed were forensically examined and the examination produced the results / opinions described therein.

Where a case has been sent to the Crown Court pursuant to Section 51 Crime and Disorder Act 1998, Regulation 2 of the Crime and Disorder Act (Service of Prosecution Evidence) Regulations 2005 provides that copies of documents containing the evidence upon which the charges are based can be included in the bundle. This does not preclude the inclusion of an MG22B (SFR1), the admissibility of which will need to be addressed at the Plea and Trial Preparation Hearing or other first hearing in the Crown Court (in accordance with CrimPR 19.3(2)) when the Defence should be invited to indicate whether they can agree the content of the MG22B (SFR1) by way of Section 10 admission.

The MG22B (SFR1) states that, should there be a real issue in relation to the forensic evidence, such that the admission cannot be made, the prosecution should ask that the defence identify the issue at the earliest possible stage in proceedings. This requirement upon the Defence does not expect them to identify a technical or scientific issue with the conclusions in the MG22B (SFR1), as it is accepted that at this point they will not have the benefit of their own expert opinion. The requirement is simply that the Defence identifies a reason why the defendant does not accept the conclusions in the MG22B (SFR1), for example..."

25.

The defence made submissions to the judge saying that the SFR1 was not admissible in the absence of agreement and that in any event it ought to be excluded under section 78 of the 1984 Act because:

(a)

No identifying characteristics of the particular pair of trainers were identified.

(b)

The impressions collected were fragmentary in nature and overlapping in some areas meaning the overall quality of the impressions was reduced.

(c)

Due to the general nature and poor quality of the impressions a more meaningful comparison could not be undertaken diminishing the probative value of the report.

(d)

The conclusion of the report was that the findings provided moderate support for the view that some of the impressions were made by the shoes attributed to the defendant.

(e)

There was no other evidence placing the defendant at the scene of the burglary.

(f)

The prejudicial effect of the evidence outweighed the true probative value.

26.

The Recorder excluded the SFR1 finding that the breach of the Crim PR was unsatisfactory but did not alter the position with regard to admissibility. When the SFR1 was not agreed by the defendant, it was for the Crown to ensure that it could properly be admitted as evidence. The order of 28 November did not change that position. The SFR1 had no standing as a witness statement and nor was it an expert report that permitted its admission under section 30 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988. If the report was admissible the Recorder would have exercised his discretion under section 78 of the 1984 Act to exclude it. If it were admitted there would have been a risk in the jury placing undue weight on the report which would have had such an adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings that it ought not to be admitted.

The evidence on which the judge ruled that there was no case to answer

27.

……..

28.

………

The Recorder's Ruling on the submission of no case

29.

…….

30.

……..

Discussion and decision

31.

We will deal first with the Recorder's ruling on the submission of no case to answer. ………..

32.

We therefore allow this appeal and direct that the trial must now take place as soon as it sensibly can be arranged before a Circuit Judge.

33.

………

34.

………..

35.

The position with the SFR1 is more complex. The defence lawyers had failed significantly in their duty to the court by failing to say whether or not they were prepared to make the admissions necessary to admit the evidence in the document. This failure occurred despite the extension of the time limit provided by the rules by the judge on 28 November to 5 December 2025. We do not consider that that failure was mitigated in anyway by what was said at that hearing or by the request for photographic images of the shoes. The requirement of the rule as communicated in the rule itself and on the SFR1 itself is perfectly clear. That response is required to trigger the securing by the prosecution of a full expert report which will be served and dealt with in the usual way. The purpose of the streamlined process is to avoid that expensive step in those cases where the SFR1 is not disputed. Accordingly that significant procedural failure placed the defence on the ruling of the Recorder in an advantageous position as against that which would have prevailed had they done their duty. This is an “unsatisfactory” state of affairs as the Recorder said, using a term which understates its significance.

36.

The prosecution has cited a good deal of well-known authority for the proposition that a party who wishes to adduce evidence must comply with the Criminal Procedure Rules or may face the exclusion of that evidence. There is however no authority of which we are aware which allows evidence to be admitted as agreed evidence where it is not in fact agreed and the party objecting to it is not prepared to make the necessary admission. We consider that there is force in the Recorder's observation that the ruling made on 28 November noted on the sidebar of the Digital Case System could not convert evidence which was not in fact agreed from evidence which was inadmissible to evidence which was admissible as agreed evidence.

37.

It may be, however, that the prosecution approached this difficulty on the wrong basis. Rather than seeking to adduce the evidence of the SFR1 at trial as agreed evidence, they should instead have made an application under section 114(1)(d) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 for it to be admitted as hearsay evidence in accordance with the interests of justice. It might be difficult for the defendant to argue that it was not in the interests of justice to admit evidence which he had had every opportunity to challenge but had not done so even despite a case management order of the court. Obviously, any such decision, should it arise in future cases, will have to be taken having regard to the interests of justice, all relevant circumstances of the case and the fairness of the trial. We should not be taken to indicate the likely outcome of such an application in any such case. We simply observe that the making of that application is the right course for a prosecutor who finds themselves in the position occupied by the prosecution in the present case at the trial in February.

38.

It is not however necessary for us to decide whether the SFR 1 should be admitted under s114(1)(d) of the 2003 Act in this case because our decision about the sufficiency of the evidence on count 2 means that the case will now go back for trial. Inevitably in current circumstances there will be a long delay between now and the time when that trial can take place. This will be plenty of time for the prosecution to get its act together now that it knows what the defence position about this evidence is. The issue is therefore not likely to come before the trial judge in the same way as it presented itself to the Recorder and it is unnecessary for us to determine how the Recorder ought to have approached the position which was before him.

Conclusion

39.

………..

(Footnote: 1)fcn.police.uk


Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London, WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400 Email: Rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk

Document download options

Download PDF (114.0 KB)

The original format of the judgment as handed down by the court, for printing and downloading.

Download XML

The judgment in machine-readable LegalDocML format for developers, data scientists and researchers.