R EX v FLORIAN BAJRAMI

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1246

View download options

R EX v FLORIAN BAJRAMI

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1246

Neutral citation: [2026] EWCA Crim 1246
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL Royal Courts of Justice
CRIMINAL DIVISION The Strand

London

WC2A 2LL

ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT LEWES

(MR RECORDER MERCER) [47CC3276821]

Case No 2026/01335/A1 Wednesday 19 August 2026

B e f o r e:

LORD JUSTICE POPPLEWELL

MR JUSTICE NICKLIN

THE RECORDER OF REDBRIDGE

(Her Honour Judge Rosa Dean)

(Sitting as a Judge of the Court of Appeal Criminal Division)

____________________

R EX

- v –

FLORIAN BAJRAMI

____________________

Computer Aided Transcription of Epiq Europe Ltd,

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)

___________________

Mr D Dainty appeared on behalf of the Appellant

___________________

J U D G M E N T

(Approved)

___________________

This Transcript is Crown Copyright. It is not to be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence the express consent of the Authority. All rights are reserved.

Wednesday 19 August 2026

LORD JUSTICE POPPLEWELL: I shall ask Mr Justice Nicklin to give the judgment of the court.

MR JUSTICE NICKLIN:

1.

This is an appeal against sentence brought with the leave of the single judge.

2.

On 4 March 2026, following a trial in the Crown Court at Lewes before Mr Recorder Mercer and a jury, the Appellant, Florian Bajrami was convicted of four offences: Being concerned in the supply of a Class A drug (cocaine, count 1), Possession of a controlled drug of Class A (cocaine) with intent to supply (count 2), Being concerned in the supply of a controlled drug of Class B (cannabis, count 3), and Possession of a controlled drug of Class B (Cannabis) with intent to supply (count 4).

3.

On 27 March 2026, he was sentenced to 12 years’ imprisonment on count 1, four and a half years’ imprisonment on count 2, four years’ imprisonment on count 3, and 12 months’ imprisonment on count 4. All of the sentences were ordered to run concurrently with each other. The total sentence was one of 12 years’ imprisonment.

4.

The Appellant was aged 38 at the date of sentence. He was of previous good character.

5.

The circumstances of the offending were serious. On 19 October 2021, the Appellant was stopped by police while driving a BMW vehicle. He was the sole occupant. Three mobile telephones were found in his possession. The vehicle contained a professionally constructed concealed hide in which police found 88.7 grams of cannabis and a further mobile telephone. A search of the Appellant’s home address led to the recovery of approximately 502 grams of cocaine with purities between 57 and 87 per cent, digital scales and cash.

6.

The mobile telephones were analysed. The prosecution case was that the communications showed organised commercial drug supply over a period of about ten months. The prosecution relied on communications said to demonstrate, amongst other things, the movement of cash, attempts to obtain kilogram quantities of drugs, the breaking down or onward supply of drugs, direct supply to customers and activity across several geographical areas.

7.

The Appellant gave evidence at trial. His case in broad terms was that he had become involved because he was under pressure from an Albanian Organised Crime Group to whom he owed money. The jury rejected the statutory defence advanced at trial.

8.

It is important to say at once – and it has been recognised by Mr Dainty this morning – that the Recorder had presided over the trial. He was therefore very well placed to assess the factual basis of sentence. He was entitled to reject the submission that the Appellant should be sentenced as having played a “lesser role”. He was also entitled to reject coercion as a basis for any substantial reduction in culpability. The issue on this appeal is narrower.

9.

In his sentencing remarks the Recorder rejected the submission that the Appellant had played a “leading role”. He concluded that the appropriate role category was “significant”. He found that the Appellant had some managerial function, an expectation of significant financial reward and an awareness and understanding of the scale of the operation.

10.

On count 1 (Being concerned in the supply of cocaine), the Recorder categorised the offence as category 2 harm “significant role”. He identified the applicable starting point as eight years’ custody, with a range of six years and six months to ten years.

11.

As to count 2 (Possession of cocaine with intent to supply), the Recorder treated the offence as category 3 harm “significant role”, with a starting point of four years and six months’ custody, and a range of three years and six months to seven years.

12.

As to count 3 (Being concerned in the supply of cannabis), he treated the offence as category 2 harm “significant role”, with a starting point of four years’ custody, and a range of two years and six months to five years.

13.

Count 4 (Possession of cannabis with intent to supply) was treated as category 3 harm “significant role”, with a starting point of 12 months’ custody and a range of 26 weeks to three years.

14.

The Recorder then addressed totality. He said that consecutive sentences would have been appropriate but that, applying totality, he would not pass consecutive sentences; instead, he would “stack” the sentence on to count 1 and impose concurrent sentences on the remaining counts. He arrived at what he described as a “starting point” of 13 years’ custody, which he reduced to 12 years to reflect the Appellant’s good character.

15.

On behalf of the Appellant, Mr Dainty submits that the Recorder’s approach produced a sentence that was manifestly excessive. The central submission is that, having placed count 1 in category 2 “significant role”, the Recorder should not have imposed a sentence above the top of the identified guideline range for that category. It is submitted that the other counts did not justify that course because they all arose from the same course of conduct.

16.

The prosecution had itself submitted in its sentencing note that the four counts arose from the same overall offending and that the court might identify count 1 as the lead offence and impose concurrent sentences on the remaining counts.

17.

We accept that the appeal has merit. We do not accept the submission that this was anything other than serious offending. A substantial custodial sentence was inevitable. The offending involved Class A and Class B drugs, multiple telephones, high purity cocaine, a professionally constructed vehicle hide, digital scales, cash and a period of activity extending over many months. Nor do we accept that the Recorder’s finding of “significant role” can properly be criticised as too severe. We do not accept Mr Dainty’s submission that this offending fell squarely within the category of “significant role”. On the contrary, there were features of the case which might well have supported a finding of “leading role”. Had the Recorder made such a finding, the sentencing exercise would have taken a different course. But, importantly, the Recorder did not make that finding. He expressly determined “significant role”. Having done so, he identified the applicable range for count 1 as six years and six months to ten years, with a starting point of eight years’ custody.

18.

The difficulty is that the sentence ultimately imposed on count 1 was 12 years, which exceeded the top of the range for the category selected by the Recorder.

19.

A judge, of course, is not bound in every case to remain within a guideline range. There may be cases in which the totality of offending makes it necessary to impose a sentence above the range for a lead offence. But where that course is taken, the reasons must be clear, particularly where the additional counts arise from substantially the same criminal conduct as the lead count.

20.

In the present case, the Recorder’s reasoning did not sufficiently explain why the proper total sentence required movement beyond the top of the count 1 range. The prosecution’s own sentencing note recognised that all four counts arose from the same course of conduct, the storage, movement and supply of controlled drugs, using the same vehicle, phones and operational methods. In those circumstances, there was an obvious need to avoid double counting. That risk was particularly apparent because the cocaine found at the Appellant’s home, which formed count 2, was also part of the factual material relied on in assessing the scale and seriousness of count 1.

21.

We also accept that there is force in the criticism of the categorisation on count 3. The Recorder treated the cannabis supply count as category 2 harm. On the material before us that appears to have overstated the harm category. The cannabis count did not materially drive the overall sentence, but it reinforces the conclusion that the Recorder’s overall totality assessment produced a sentence somewhat higher than was justified.

22.

We emphasise that this is not a case in which the Recorder failed to appreciate the seriousness of the offending, or failed to engage with the guidelines. He also properly took into account all the available mitigation that could be urged on behalf of the Appellant. The error lies in the final step. Having selected “significant role” for count 1 and identified the relevant range, the total sentence of 12 years’ imprisonment was just too high. The appropriate sentence should have reflected the seriousness of the Class A offending, the associated Class B offending, and the additional criminality represented by possession with intent to supply, but without double counting, and while giving proper effect to the Appellant’s previous good character and his available mitigation.

23.

We have considered whether the correct sentence should be at the very top of the count 1 range or slightly above it. In our judgment, a sentence of ten years’ imprisonment properly reflects the totality of the offending. It was and is a substantial sentence. It recognises that the Appellant’s role was “significant”; that the offending was organised and commercial; and that the operation involved both cocaine and cannabis. It also, however, reflects the fact that the Appellant was of previous good character, his available mitigation, and that once the Recorder had rejected “leading role” and selected “significant role”, the sentence had to remain properly anchored to that categorisation.

24.

We therefore allow the appeal. The sentence of 12 yeas’ imprisonment on count 1 will be quashed and a sentence of ten years’ imprisonment substituted. On count 2, the sentence of four years and six months’ imprisonment will remain concurrent. On count 3, we quash the sentence of four years’ imprisonment and substitute a sentence of one year’s imprisonment concurrent. On count 4, the sentence of one year’s imprisonment will remain concurrent. The total sentence is therefore one of ten years’ imprisonment.

25.

Accordingly, and to that extent, the appeal against sentence is allowed.

_______________________________

Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400

Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk

______________________________

Document download options

Download PDF (129.2 KB)

The original format of the judgment as handed down by the court, for printing and downloading.

Download XML

The judgment in machine-readable LegalDocML format for developers, data scientists and researchers.