R EX v CHRISTOPHER BROOKS

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1235

View download options

R EX v CHRISTOPHER BROOKS

Neutral Citation Number[2026] EWCA Crim 1235

WARNING: reporting restrictions may apply to the contents transcribed in this document, particularly if the case concerned a sexual offence or involved a child. Reporting restrictions prohibit the publication of the applicable information to the public or any section of the public, in writing, in a broadcast or by means of the internet including social media. Anyone who receives a copy of this transcript is responsible in law for making sure that applicable restrictions are not breached. A person who breaches a reporting restriction is liable to a fine and/or imprisonment. For guidance on whether reporting restrictions apply, and to what information, ask at the court office or take legal advice. This Transcript is Crown Copyright.  It is not to be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence the express consent of the Authority.  All rights are reserved.

Neutral Citation Number:[2026] EWCA Crim 1235
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL Royal Courts of Justice
CRIMINAL DIVISIONThe Strand

London

WC2A 2LL

ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT PRESTON

(HIS HONOUR JUDGE GUNN) [04ZL3325623]

Case No 2026/03223/A2Thursday 17 September 2026

B e f o r e:

LORD JUSTICE BEAN

MR JUSTICE JAY

MRS JUSTICE HEATHER WILLIAMS DBE

____________________

R EX

- v –

CHRISTOPHER BROOKS

____________________

Computer Aided Transcription of Epiq Europe Ltd,

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)

___________________

Mr A Bennie appeared on behalf of the Appellant

___________________

J U D G M E N T

___________________

Thursday 17 September 2026

LORD JUSTICE BEAN: I shall ask Mrs Justice Heather Williams to give the judgment of the court.

MRS JUSTICE HEATHER WILLIAMS:

Introduction

1.

On 19 May 2026, in the Crown Court at Preston, the appellant pleaded guilty on re-arraignment to one offence of burglary, contrary to section 9(1)(b) of the Theft Act 1968, committed on 10 October 2023. On 7 August 2026, the appellant, aged 67, was sentenced by Her Honour Judge Gunn to 279 days' imprisonment. He was also ordered to pay compensation in the sum of £580.

2.

The appellant appeals against his sentence with the leave of the single judge.

The Circumstances of the Offence

3.

Nicola Holden and her husband Robert Holden owned Walleach Farm in Turton; it was a working family farm. At around lunchtime on 10 October 2023 Mrs Holden was at home when she heard her dog barking, which indicated to her that someone was in the front yard. She went outside and was met by the appellant, who was quickly moving towards the main road. Mrs Holden shouted at him, and he started to tell her a story about a dog he thought had been run over. Mrs Holden did not believe what he was saying. Mr Holden then joined his wife and asked her what had happened. By now the appellant was going through the main gates of the farm onto the main road. Mr Holden ran towards him, challenged him and told him to stay. The appellant repeated the story about the dog being run over.

4.

Mrs Holden went to look at the CCTV footage. She saw that the appellant had been into an unlocked building on the farm. She re-joined her husband, and the appellant was then challenged further about what had happened. He was asked directly whether he had stolen anything and he was adamant that he had not. The appellant then left in a vehicle. It was later discovered that he had been into the outbuilding and had taken various power tools with a total value in the region of £580, namely a welder, a grinder, a saw, and a cordless drill.

5.

Police traced the appellant via his car registration. On 18 October he attended the police station voluntarily for interview, during which he remained silent throughout. CCTV footage showed that there was also another individual involved in the offence, who has not been identified.

6.

The appellant has 33 convictions for 66 offences between 1973 and 2022, largely for theft and kindred offences involving dwelling and non-dwelling burglary, theft, handling stolen goods and aiding and abetting robbery. In terms of his recent offending, on 4 November 2021 he was sentenced to concurrent terms of seven months' imprisonment for two offences of burglary of a non-dwelling, attempted burglary with intent to steal of a non-dwelling, and theft. On 7 December 2022 he appeared at Bradford Crown Court where a community order was imposed in respect of three offences of burglary and theft in relation to non-dwellings and one offence of theft. That community order was to run to 6 December 2024 and required the appellant to undertake 120 hours of unpaid work.

The Pre-Sentence Report

7.

The author of the pre-sentence report indicated that the appellant denied taking the items from the farm; he claimed that he had only pleaded guilty as a result of his solicitor's advice. He expressed little remorse and the author felt that his understanding of the impact on the victims was limited. However, he expressed a willingness to pay compensation to the value of the items taken. The author noted that Mr Brooks had been diagnosed with stress, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder. He was due to have a hernia operation later in the year. He looked after his adult son, who had a drugs problem, and he frequently visited his sister who was terminally ill. The author felt that the appellant demonstrated some motivation to change, but that this had yet to translate into a sustained behavioural change. The appellant was considered to present a medium likelihood of re-offending, with the risk increasing in the absence of structured intervention.

8.

The author of the report assessed that the appellant's response to previous supervision had been "good". He had completed all 120 hours of the unpaid work requirement in the 2022 community order within three months, which was described as "an outstanding feat". He had been offered 24 appointments with his probation officer and had attended 19 of them, with only one absence marked as unacceptable. The appellant had indicated to the author that he would be willing to do unpaid work hours "as this would give him a sense of purpose to get up and do something" and to help society. The author considered that the appellant’s risk could be effectively managed in the community. If the court was prepared to impose a community-based sanction, the following were recommended: 150 hours of unpaid work and ten Rehabilitation Activity Requirement days.

Section 277A of the Sentencing Act 2020

9.

Section 277A of the Sentencing Act 2020 applies where an adult offender is convicted of an offence on or after 22 March 2026, the term of the sentence is not more than 12 months, and a suspended sentence is available in relation to that sentence. Section 277A(2) requires the court to make a suspended sentence order, unless the court is of the opinion that there are exceptional circumstances which relate to the offence (or the combination of the offence and one or more offences associated with it) or the offender, and which justify not making this order. However, subsection (3) provides that section 277A does not apply in a number of circumstances, including where the commission of the offence constituted a breach by the offender of an order of the court.

10.

As this court noted in R v Morgan [2026] EWCA Crim 886 at [38], where the circumstances come within one of the exemptions in section 277A(3) the section "simply does not apply at all" and the old law applies without amendment, so that the court must consider whether it is appropriate to suspend the sentence by reference to the table of factors listed in the Imposition of Community and Custodial Sentences guideline ("the Table"). As is well-known, the Table lists factors which indicate that it may be appropriate to suspend the sentence, including where there is a realistic prospect of rehabilitation in the community and the offender does not present a high risk of re-offending. The Table also identifies factors which indicate that it may not be appropriate to suspend a custodial sentence, including where the seriousness of the offence means appropriate punishment can only be achieved by immediate custody and where there is a history of poor compliance with court orders and the offender is unlikely to comply in the future.

The Sentencing Remarks

11.

The judge noted that the appellant had pleaded guilty on the first day fixed for trial, after the matter had previously been listed for trial and the complainants had attended court expecting to give evidence. The judge agreed with the parties' analysis of culpability and harm, namely that under the guidelines this was a C1 offence, as the burglary was committed with limited intrusion into the premises, but persons were present. Accordingly, a starting point of six months' custody applied, with an offence range of a medium level community order to one year's custody.

12.

The judge identified a number of aggravating features. The appellant had a very substantial record of acquisitive offending, including numerous previous offences of burglary. She was particularly concerned by the similarities between some of these offences and the present offending. She described his offending as demonstrating a persistent pattern which greatly increased his culpability. Furthermore, the offence had been committed while the appellant was subject to a community order, and the offence involved group activity.

13.

The judge was satisfied that these aggravating features took the offending to the top of the category range (365 days). However, she then took account of the appellant's mitigation. She referred to his age, his health difficulties, his pending operation and to his family bereavements and family difficulties, including the support he provided to his sister. The judge also noted his completion of the requirements under the 2022 community order. The judge reduced her one-year figure by 15 per cent to reflect these matters, giving a figure of 310 days. She then allowed a ten per cent credit for the appellant's guilty plea, and thus arrived at her final figure of 279 days' imprisonment.

14.

The judge explained that she was satisfied that a custodial sentence was warranted. She then turned to consider whether she could suspend the sentence. She noted that section 277A of the Sentencing Act did not apply because the appellant was subject to the 2022 community order at the time when the offence was committed. She explained why she concluded that an immediate custodial sentence was appropriate. First, the appellant had an extensive and highly relevant record of acquisitive crime. Secondly, the offence was committed while the appellant was subject to a community order, which "strongly suggests that such an order has failed to deter you from further offending". The judge indicated that she was unable to accept the recommendation of the author of the pre-sentence report as "the critical fact is that this offence was committed notwithstanding your extensive history of similar offending and whilst subject to community-based intervention. Compliance alone does not provide me with the confidence that a further community disposal would adequately protect the public, deter further offending or properly reflect the seriousness of the offence". The appellant had demonstrated that he was prepared to continue offending despite previous opportunities offered by the court. She also bore in mind the wider interests of justice; the public were entitled to expect that persistent offenders who committed further offences whilst subject to court orders will ordinarily face immediate imprisonment. To suspend the sentence would fail to reflect the seriousness of the offending, undermine the deterrent purpose of sentencing and diminish public confidence in the administration of justice.

The Progress Report

15.

A report from the Prison Offender Manager at HMP Berwyn indicates that whilst in custody the appellant has complied with the prison rules and has not been subject to internal discipline procedures. Due to his short period of time in custody, he has not been suitable for any accredited programme work. He is due to be released on 1 October 2026 (having spent six weeks on remand during the proceedings).

The Grounds of Appeal

16.

No issue is taken with the judge's categorisation of the offence, the level of the guilty plea credit, or the figure of 279 days' custody. The focus of the appeal is upon the judge's decision not to suspend the period of imprisonment.

17.

The two grounds of appeal are closely interlinked. Ground 1 contends that the judge "grossly overweighted" the appellant's breach of the community order in concluding that his level of risk was unmanageable in the community. In his written grounds, Mr Bennie describes the appellant's breach of the community order as "technical", in that all of the requirements of that order had been completed before this offending occurred. In his submissions today, Mr Bennie notes that had the offence been committed from 11 May 2026 and the requirements of the community order completed, as a result of recent legislative changes to Schedule 10 to the Sentencing Act 2020, the appellant's probation officer would have been able to treat the order as terminated, meaning that he would not be caught by subsection (3) and would come within the statutory presumption of a suspended sentence in section 277A of the Act.

18.

Mr Bennie also emphasises the assessment of the author of the pre-sentence report that the appellant's risk was manageable in the community, that the appellant was willing to work with the Probation Service, his pending medical operation and the fact that he had not re-offended between October 2023 and the date when he was sentenced. Mr Bennie also argues that as these factors did not find favour with the judge, this in itself indicates that she must have placed undue weight on the breach of the community order.

19.

Ground 2 alleges that the judge's reasons for imposing an immediate custodial sentence were inadequate. Mr Bennie criticises the degree to which the judge relied upon the breach of the community order in circumstances where the requirements had already been completed, and he repeats his reliance on what he describes as the "anomaly" to which we have already referred. He emphasises that had the appellant been within the section 277A(2) mandatory suspended sentence provision, then there were no "exceptional factors" that would have led to its disapplication in this case. In this regard he refers to the court's discussion in R v Morgan of the limited circumstances that may constitute an exceptional factor.

20.

In terms of the factors identified in the Table, Mr Bennie highlights that the appellant was assessed by the author of the pre-sentence report as having a realistic prospect of rehabilitation, the extent of his personal mitigation, his offer to pay full monetary compensation to the victims and his willingness to work with the Probation Service. Mr Bennie notes that the short period of time the appellant will spend in custody does not allow for significant interventions to reduce his risk. He also refers to the recent statutory sentencing reforms as designed to expand the use and range of alternatives to immediate custody.

Discussion and Conclusion

21.

At the time when he committed the index offence on 10 October 2023, the appellant was subject to the 2022 community order which was expressed to run until December 2024. In the circumstances, and as Parliament provided in section 277A(3) of the Sentencing Act, the mandatory requirement to impose a suspended sentence in relation to terms of imprisonment of 12 months or less, absent exceptional circumstances, had no application. Accordingly, the judge was correct to consider the question of whether it was "appropriate" to suspend the sentence by reference to the factors identified in the Table. We are not persuaded that changes in the law that would only apply if the offence had been committed some two and a half years later (from 11 May 2026) should affect our consideration of this position.

22.

The judge did take account of the factors emphasised by Mr Bennie, including that the appellant had complied with the requirements of the 2022 community order and the fact that the author of the pre-sentence report had assessed his risk as manageable in the community. We consider the judge was right to place weight on the appellant's pattern of recent similar offending and the fact he had committed the index offence only ten months after the imposition of the community order and at a time when, as we emphasise, he would have known that he was still subject to that order. In these circumstances we reject the suggestion that the breach of the community order was no more than "technical" in terms of this sentencing exercise. As the judge said, it indicated that the imposition of the community order had not deterred the appellant's offending. The judge was fully entitled to lack confidence that a further community-based penalty would provide a sufficient deterrent for the appellant or an effective opportunity for rehabilitation. The judge was not obliged to agree with the assessment arrived at by the author of the pre-sentence report and we note that the report, read as a whole, was somewhat equivocal in terms of the appellant's attitude towards this offending.

23.

The question for us is whether the judge's decision not to suspend this sentence was wrong in principle, having regard to the factors set out in the Table. For the reasons we have indicated, we conclude that in all the circumstances, the judge was entitled to conclude that the seriousness of the offending and the likelihood of the appellant re-offending meant that this was a case where it was not appropriate to suspend the sentence.

24.

Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.

_________________________________

Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.

Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE

Tel No: 020 7404 1400

Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk

______________________________

Document download options

Download PDF (114.1 KB)

The original format of the judgment as handed down by the court, for printing and downloading.

Download XML

The judgment in machine-readable LegalDocML format for developers, data scientists and researchers.