WARNING: reporting restrictions may apply to the contents transcribed in this document, particularly if the case concerned a sexual offence or involved a child. Reporting restrictions prohibit the publication of the applicable information to the public or any section of the public, in writing, in a broadcast or by means of the internet, including social media. Anyone who receives a copy of this transcript is responsible in law for making sure that applicable restrictions are not breached. A person who breaches a reporting restriction is liable to a fine and/or imprisonment. For guidance on whether reporting restrictions apply, and to what information, ask at the court office or take legal advice.
This Transcript is Crown Copyright. It may not be reproduced in whole or in part other than in accordance with relevant licence or with the express consent of the Authority. All rights are reserved.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL CRIMINAL DIVISION ON APPEAL FROM THE CROWN COURT AT CAMBRIDGE (HHJ MAGEE) [35NT1945124] Neutral Citation No. [2026] EWCA Crim 1183 CASE NO:202601583/A1 |
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand
London
WC2A 2LL
Before:
LORD JUSTICE JEREMY BAKER
MR JUSTICE WALL
MRS JUSTICE SWEETING
Reference by the Attorney General under s.36 Criminal Justice Act 1988
REX
v
JULIE EVANS
__________
Computer Aided Transcript of Epiq Europe Ltd,
Lower Ground, 46 Chancery Lane, London WC2A 1JE
Tel No: 020 7404 1400; Email: rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk (Official Shorthand Writers to the Court)
_________
MS S PRZYBYLSKA appeared on behalf of the Solicitor General
MR T FORD appeared on behalf of the Respondent Offender
_________
APPROVED JUDGMENT
LORD JUSTICE JEREMY BAKER:
On 3 March 2026, in the Crown Court at Cambridge, Julie Evans ("the offender") pleaded guilty to an offence of robbery.
On 1 April 2026, a suspended sentence order was imposed upon her comprising a period of 2 years' imprisonment suspended for an operational period of 2 years with two requirements. Firstly, a rehabilitation activity requirement of 20 days, and secondly, an unpaid work requirement of 300 hours. In addition, a restraining order was made in respect of the victim of the offence for a period of 5 years.
His Majesty’s Solicitor General seeks leave to refer the sentence as being unduly lenient pursuant to section 36 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988.
The offence
The offender and the victim, Richard Strudwick, were known to each other and at the time of the incident had been in an on-and-off relationship for around 7 months.
In the early hours of 5 November 2024, Mr Strudwick was asleep at his home address in Springfield Avenue in March, when he was awoken by a knock at the front door. He inquired who was at the door and upon learning it was the offender, he let her in. She told him that she needed to borrow some money from him in order to buy cocaine because at the time both the offender and the victim were users of cocaine on a regular basis.
Mr Strudwick agreed to lend the offender £40 and gave her his bankcard. The agreement was that she would withdraw the cash from his account, purchase cocaine and then return to Mr Strudwick's home so that they could consume the drugs together. The offender left the flat in order to withdraw the money but later called the victim and informed him that the local cashpoint was not operational and she would need to go further afield. At that point Mr Strudwick realised that he had some cash at his home and so he informed the offender about that and asked her to return. In fact, unbeknown to him the offender had already withdrawn £40 from his bank account using his cashcard.
The offender did return to the victim's home shortly afterwards and he gave her the £40 in cash. She again left the property and returned shortly afterwards with the cocaine, which both she and the victim consumed together. The offender then left again to obtain more cocaine which she said that she would obtain on credit. She left Mr Strudwick’s credit card at his home. In the meantime, Mr Strudwick checked his online banking and realised that in fact the offender had already taken £40 from his account. There was then messaging between the two of them and she gave a story that she had been found in possession of drugs and the police were at her address. In due course there were abusive messages exchanged between the two of them and Mr Strudwick at one point in that exchange threatened to smash the offender's house up if she did not return his money.
At around 6.15 am the offender attended Mr Strudwick's home address and he let her in. They were both in the living room of the address when the offender shoved Mr Strudwick in the chest causing him to fall back into his armchair. She then jumped on him and punched him to the head on a number of occasions. The offender tried to grab Mr Strudwick's mobile phone which was in his hand and shouted: "You don't know who you're dealing with. Give me your rings and the £40 you owe me and I'll leave". She also threatened to stab him with a knife, although there is no evidence that she had possession of one. Mr Strudwick tried kicking the offender away, but she stood over him and held him down by pinning his arms and she dragged Mr Strudwick off the chair onto the floor. He tried to crawl away but was unable to do so and, in the course of that altercation the offender picked up a plastic perfume bottle and television remote control and struck the victim on a number of occasions. The effect of that was that Mr Strudwick was bleeding from his head when the offender removed two rings from his fingers and a wallet from his back pocket before leaving the address.
The wallet contained £20 in cash, a photograph of the victim's daughter, and a bankcard. The two stolen rings were valued at £480 and £85 and were additionally of significant sentimental value, the latter ring being his late wife's engagement ring.
Mr Strudwick in due course pressed the panic button that he had at his premises. He was taken to hospital and treated for his injuries where it was found that he had suffered bruises, scratches, cuts, bumps to his head, arms, face and a fracture of his nose. The offender was arrested on 7 November 2024 and denied the offence.
So far as the victim was concerned, there were two victim personal statements in November 2024 and February 2026, and it included references to him being scared to go out in case the offender had got somebody to hurt him. He was afraid to be alone at home and sore from the attack. Latterly he still had some feelings of anxiety and was always looking over his shoulder. He preferred not to go out alone and he liked to be accompanied by another person.
The offender
The offender was born on 25 September 1977 and was aged 47 at the time of the offending and is now 48 years of age. She had no previous convictions before this offence.
There was a pre-sentence report available to the court dated 31 March 2026. In that report it was acknowledged that the offender accepted responsibility for the offence but sought to blame her behaviour on substance misuse at the time.
It was evident from the history which the author of the report obtained from the offender that she had a troubled childhood and that there had been abusive relationships within the family at the time which had had a significant effect on her life. She had taken to misusing substances in her late teens and early 20s, commencing with cannabis going through alcohol and recreational cocaine until she was addicted to crack cocaine over the years leading up to the offence.
Since the offence, the offender had taken steps herself to deal with that problem, in that she had desisted from drugs and alcohol. Moreover, she had been at a residential rehabilitation centre; albeit she had had to leave in circumstances which were deemed to be understandable.
The author's assessment of the offender was that she appeared to be highly vulnerable to relapses in circumstances that destabilized her, particularly in relationship difficulties and that she lacked the skills required to manage her emotional stresses and interpersonal challenges, She was reported to have been suffering also from PTSD, anxiety and depression.
Generally, she was assessed as having a low risk of general reconviction and reoffending, albeit there was a medium risk of her causing serious harm to specific individuals who she might be in a relationship with.
The offender had written a letter of apology to the court, addressing the victim’s situation in sincere terms, whilst explaining that she had been highly dependent on crack cocaine at the time and that her mental health was poor. She sought the victim’s forgiveness and pointed out that her addiction had already caused difficulties in her life, in particular with her son. She disclosed that she had now stopped using drugs and was extremely keen to get away from her addiction and enter a new and drug-free and alcohol-free phase of her life.
The sentencing hearing
In sentencing the offender, the Recorder noted that under the Domestic Robbery Guideline a factor of high culpability was present, namely the use of a weapon to inflict violence, together with a lesser culpability factor, namely very little or no planning. The Recorder concluded that he would place culpability into medium culpability B and that the appropriate degree of harm was within category 2 harm. Therefore, this was an offence with a starting point of 5 years' custody and a category range between 4 and 8 years.
In addition, he observed that,
"... there is an element of this offence that is an atypical dwelling robbery insofar as this occurred in the context of a rolling argument between you and Mr Strudwick which
commenced earlier in the day, and was against the background of your communal drug usage. You clearly entered – and it’s accepted – entered the property lawfully... – albeit in
the context of the argument, however within a short period it descended into violence and that’s when the robbery occurred. And it’s also – I think it’s accepted on the part of the Crown that there is some reduction in relation to the unusual nature, which is perhaps not entirely within the kind of offences that’s anticipated by the guideline."
The Recorder did not consider that there were any particular aggravating factors. In particular he did not consider that the domestic context of the offence aggravated the offence, as that had already been taken into account. In respect of mitigating factors, he noted that the offender was of good character. He accepted there was genuine remorse. There was some background of mental disorder and the offender had already taken steps to address her offending.
In the light of those matters, the Recorder stated that,
"When I look at all of those factors I take the view that, most unusually in a case of this nature, that all of those factors that I’ve identified permit me to reduce the overall sentence to one of three years imprisonment after trial."
He identified that the offender was entitled to full credit for her early guilty plea, and reduced that period by one-third to 2 years' imprisonment.
The Recorder then proceeded to consider whether the period of imprisonment could be suspended or whether it had to be served immediately,
"I have to ask myself the question is does that need to be immediate custody or could it be suspended? It is clear to me that the prospects of rehabilitation are high, given the steps that
you have already taken. Given the length of time that has passed and your previous good character, the risk of your reoffending is low. And, given the fact that there is significant personal mitigation in terms of your early life and the mental health issues from which you suffer, all of those factors point towards me being able to suspend the sentence and, unusually given the unusual circumstances of this offence, I am not obliged in my view to pass an immediate custodial sentence in relation to it."
Submissions
On behalf of the Solicitor General it is accepted that the Recorder was entitled to place this offence within category 2B of the offence specific guideline. However, it is submitted that the use of the weapon to inflict violence outweighed what was described in the guideline as “very little or no planning”. Moreover, there had been a threat of violence by a weapon which had not been produced, namely a knife, which was a category B factor. It is submitted that as a result of these matters, there should have been an uplift from the appropriate starting point before a consideration of aggravating and mitigating factors.
Furthermore, it is submitted that even if a starting point of 5 years' imprisonment was appropriate, the Recorder had erred in his identification of aggravating factors, in that he ought to have recognised that the fact that the offence was committed whilst the offender was intoxicated by drugs was an aggravating factor and also that there was a domestic abuse context to this offence arising out of the relationship between the offender and the victim. That those matters ought to have raised further the notional sentence before a consideration of mitigating factors. Although it is accepted that there were mitigating factors, it is submitted that undue weight was given to those factors which resulted in an unjustified reduction in the notional sentence after trial to 3 years.
Finally, it is submitted that even if 2 years' imprisonment was an appropriate sentence, having regard to the factors in the Overarching Guideline in relation to the imposition of community and custodial sentences, this offence was so serious that appropriate punishment could only be achieved by a period of immediate custody.
On behalf of the offender, it is submitted that this was an unusual case, as the Recorder found, in that that the offence arose in the course of a relationship between the victim and the offender. In any event, it is pointed out that the appropriate starting point under category 2B was 5 years’ custody, and there were no aggravating factors. In particular, it is submitted that the fact that the offence was committed whilst under the influence of drugs has to be tempered by the fact that the offender suffered a cocaine addiction.
Moreover, that since the offence, the offender has taken very significant steps to seek help with her addiction, which is a factor which ought to be taken into account, both in terms of reducing any period of custody and also justified the imposition of a suspended sentence of imprisonment.
In that regard there is a recent report from a residential rehabilitation centre, known as Sefton Park, which makes it clear that the offender arrived there on 30 June 2026 and is going to be resident there until the end of September, albeit she may be able to remain for a longer period if additional funding is provided to her. In that report it is said that:
"Since working with Julie [the author had] witnessed positive growth in several areas. Julie came to Sefton Park determined to achieve sobriety and make beneficial changes to her life-style. She has spoken openly about experiencing shame and remorse regarding aspects of her past and is demonstrating a willingness to reflect on these experiences and take accountability for her actions.
Julie is currently deputy leader within her peer group at the house. Julie has consistently engaged with her therapeutic groups. She attends all her groups, participates openly and is willing to share her experiences and reflect alongside her peers. Her continued engagement demonstrates a commitment to the changes she has been working towards.
Throughout my professional contact with Julie, I have observed someone who is making meaningful efforts to understand herself, take responsibility of her choices and develop healthier ways of managing her life and relationships. The progress I have witnessed has been encouraging."
In the event, it is submitted on behalf of the offender that although this was a lenient and merciful sentence, it was the correct one in the circumstances which pertained and was not an unduly lenient sentence with which this Court ought to interfere.
Discussion
This was undoubtably an unpleasant offence of domestic robbery committed in a dwelling house. Whilst we appreciate that under the offence specific guideline, there was a high culpability factor, namely the use of a weapon to inflict violence, the Recorder having found that there was very little or no planning, we are satisfied that he was entitled to place this offence within category 2B. Moreover, we are disinclined to the view that, prior to any consideration of aggravating and mitigating factors, there was any need to uplift the notional period from the appropriate starting point of 5 years’ custody.
As to the presence of factors which are said to have aggravated the offence, we consider that the domestic context adds little in the circumstances of this case. In relation to the fact that the offender, no doubt like the victim, was under the influence of drugs at the time of the offence, this appears to have taken place in an addictive context in relation to which the offender has sought considerable assistance.
Therefore, although there is some aggravation arising from her intoxication at the time of the offence, it has to be balanced by the mitigating factors in this case, which include the fact that the offence was wholly out of character, as the offender had no previous convictions of any sort let alone for violence or anything of this nature. Furthermore, the Recorder was entitled to consider that the remorse which had been expressed by the offender was genuine, and that much of her life had been adversely affected by the emotional difficulties arising from her difficult childhood, which the offender had, not perhaps untypically, sought to deal with in her late teens and 20s by way of drug and alcohol abuse, which led her into the kind of situation in which she found herself in her mid-40s, namely being addicted to substances, in particular cocaine, which directly led her into contact with the offender.
In those circumstances, although the reduction from the appropriate starting point of 5 years, to a notional term of 3 years may be considered to be generous, we do not consider that in the context of this case it was unwarranted. Moreover, when it came to considering whether the resulting term of 2 years’ imprisonment could be suspended in its operation, the Recorder was clearly justified in taking into account the steps which the offender had taken to deal with her drug addiction and to turn her life around.
In this regard, we are satisfied from reading the pre-sentence report and the most recent document from Sefton Park, that this offender has taken very significant steps to change her life around from the circumstances in which she had found herself at the time of the commission of this offence. Furthermore, although the offence was serious, the offender had not been assessed as presenting a high risk of reoffending or harm, there was strong personal mitigation, and there was a realistic prospect of rehabilitation in the community.
In these circumstances, we are satisfied that the Recorder was entitled to suspend the period of imprisonment in this case, and we note that when doing so he did not lose sight of the need for both a rehabilitative and a punitive element to be imposed on the offender, which he effected by requiring the offender to undertake 300 hours of unpaid work.
We remind ourselves of the principles upon which this Court will consider whether a sentence is to be regarded as being unduly lenient, as described by Carr LJ (as she then was) in R v Solomon [2022] EWCA Crim 1333, at [50] namely that,
"References under s.36 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 are made for the purpose of the avoidance of gross error, the allaying of widespread public concern at what may appear to be an unduly lenient sentence and the preservation of public confidence in cases where a judge appears to have departed to a substantial extent from the norms of sentencing generally applied by the courts in cases of a particular type: see Attorney General's Reference No.132 [2001], R v Johnson [2002] EWCA Crim 1418, [2003] 1 Crim App R (S) 41 at para.25. We remind ourselves that the hurdle for appellate interference to be justified is a high one. The sentence in question must be not only lenient, but unduly so."
Conclusion
Taking all these matters into account, whilst we are prepared to grant leave in this case, we do not consider that the sentence is unduly lenient and therefore refuse the Reference.
Epiq Europe Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.
Lower Ground Floor, 46 Chancery Lane, London, WC2A 1JE
Tel No: 020 7404 1400 Email: Rcj@epiqglobal.co.uk